Prescribing Rights to Psychologists in Louisiana

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.


Nor Cal Psych R2
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Mar 30, 2003
Reaction score
:thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown: :thumbdown:


American Psychiatric Association, 1000 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 1825,
Arlington, VA 22209

For Information Contact: For
Immediate Release:
Jason Young, 703-907-8582 or c: 202-669-5929 April 20,
[email protected] Release No.

APA Deeply Concerned over Louisiana House Vote
to Give Prescribing Rights to Psychologists
"Patients' Lives at Risk," Warns Goin

The American Psychiatric Association (APA) is deeply concerned over
yesterday's vote by the Louisiana House of Representatives to grant
psychologists, who are not physicians, the right to prescribe powerful brain
medications. The House voted 62-31 to pass HB 1426, which would permit
self-professed "medical psychologists" to prescribe psychotropic medications
- drugs that act on a patient's brain - by getting training that is far
short of medical school and residency.

"Proponents of this bill are putting patients' lives at risk," said APA
President Marcia K. Goin, M.D. "While many people are uncertain about which
mental health professionals have medical training, the public should not be
fooled by this bill. Psychologists are not medical doctors and, under the
bill, wouldn't be required to get the training necessary to safely prescribe
potent medications. This bill ignores the real needs of patients and
families struggling with mental illnesses and instead creates a substandard
level of care."

In addition to giving psychologists prescribing rights, the bill would
subject prescribing psychologists to the lone oversight of the state Board
of Examiners of Psychologists, a regulatory board whose members are not
trained in the practice of medicine and cannot judge anyone's medical
competency. The Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners has jurisdiction
over judging medical competency in the state - including for physicians, lab
personnel and even acupuncture assistants - but the bill's proponents would
not allow language into the bill to include oversight from the medical

"This is a classic case of the fox guarding the henhouse," said Goin.
"Under this bill, psychologists will be judging their own ability in the
medical field. This system cannot and will not ensure the high quality of
care that patients want or deserve. Patients and families have said they
don't want to be guinea pigs for this unsafe system of care, but so far
their concerns have fallen on deaf ears."

The bill, similar to measures that have failed in the past, has been on a
fast track to the governor this time around. The Senate is expected to hold
a floor vote soon on either the House-passed version or its own companion
measure, SB 754.

"The term 'medical psychologist' is calculated to deceive," concluded Goin.
"There is no such thing. Psychologists can help with a broken heart, too,
but the logic of this bill would make them cardiac surgeons. For the sake
of safe patient care, we urge Louisianans to reject this legislation."

Members don't see this ad.
This system is simply not working :mad: Over the last several years APA has been lobbying hard to prevent these bills, but it seems they failed to score this time.
The bottomline is people are not getting standard care and no one is giving a damn about it. As far as my knowledge goes there has been only one study assessing the outcome of psychologist(non MD) scripting and it didnot show any wonderful benefit. And it was one of those armed forces unit(Sorry, I can't recall the exact ref) which does not reflect regular community practice.
However, w/ the recent confusion on the SSRIs and suicidality I doubt whether there will be any "med psychologists" taking the added risk of med-ck. Atleast that's what happening in New Mexico.
I wouldn't worry abou this. It's unlikely that psychologists will be willing to shoulder the additional malpractice premiums that prescribing will bring. Can you imagine what would happen in a court of law if a psychologist was the defendant? "Doctor...wait, you're not a MEDICAL doctor?" :laugh:
I keep telling you guys that lack of diligence against outsiders trying to get in on our scope is killing us.

What happens in New Mexico has repercussions in Hawaii, and what happens in Louisiana has repercussions in New York. We can simply NOT sit back and worry about our own state, we have to worry about all states simultaneously.

This is a common tactic by the outsiders. They "sneak in" laws in one state before MDs are paying attention, and after that, its all downhill because once a state establishes a precedent, the other states are MUCH more likely to follow suit.