Darkchild didnt say they were smarter, he said they were better able to get into medical school. It is only because of premed hubris (that pisses off other majors/professions) that you equated smarter with ability to get into med school.
Private top ranked schools are much more likely to give grants and other forms of aid to needy students (to my knowledge, these schools have a need-blind admissions process).
Finally, as someone who went to a relatively public school (about 3000 students, 700 in my grad class) who is now an "elitist, pretentious, prick," I can say that my opportunities for research, class participation, and overall academic experience are much greater than I would have otherwise.
The fact is, these schools arent creating class warfare, I know several students at my institution and private schools that have hefty scholarships and aid because of their socioeconomic position. Sure a few students in each class are legacies from each family, but sometimes you get richarse legacies at public schools as well (one Bush sister goes to Yale, other goes to UT-Austin), but most students are pretty much alike. I think Cerberus would be hard pressed to identify a public/private school student based on talking to them, without asking them straight up. The fact is, college kids are college kids, and the belief that private school kids are "elitist, pretentious, pricks" is as wrong as the belief that public school kids are "dumb, whiny, lazy bums who would rather spend money on a new car than their education".
Originally posted by Cerberus
Personally I think this is complete BS. Great, a nobel prize winner teaches you physics wooopieeee does that mean you are gonna come out of physics knowing more about physics than joe state school? I doubt seriously doubt it. It does not follow that because someone is a great scientist they will be a great educator. Not to mention the curriculum for the premed classes is pretty much the same anywhere you go. Also I'd like to know what percentage of these super smart ivy kids went to private prep schools while the rest of us dummies were stuck in public schools. Does that make them smarter? No, maybe a little more prepared but i guarantee i know some dumb state school kids that could pwn your ivies in any scientific subject.
Yup ivies are more likely to get into any ivy medschool but is that because they are smarter or more prepared? Or is it because they are part of the good ole boy system that accepts those from ivy league schools simply because they are from ivy league schools?
Honestly I would rather go to a lowly state school than a school full of elitist, pretentious, pricks anyday