Unfortunately not. I do know some people who interviewed there but weren't impressed. That is from word of mouth and I have no first hand experience. I was also surprised to hear that because Emory's psychiatry department is one of the best in the country. So take what I said with a grain of salt.
Unfortunately, word of mouth is going to weigh heavily on your choice because there is no official ranking. Here's the way I went about it....
1) do you want to settle in the area--if you want to do private practice, Forensic Psychiatry is going to be heavily connection based. You can't set up a private practice without good connections. Wherever you go for fellowship will give you something of a head start in that geographical area should you choose to stay there. If you relocate, you'll be starting over again.
A personal note, the place where I graduated from, in more ways than one hinted they'd like me back, but they have no forensic psychiatry position for me. If I went back, I'd be starting from square one forensic psychiatry-wise.
2) Does the place teach enough psychometric tests: MMPI, SIRS, HCR-20, M-FAST are very useful and can give insight with a specific amount of statistical validity that is more accurate than simple clinical opinion. I've seen forensic psychiatrists know nothing of how to use this type of testing, and when they went up against someone in court who did have the testing, they had nothing to counter it with.
personal note: was doing an elective with a FP who didn't know how to use the above tests, he went against someone who did. I asked him how I could learn more about those tests. The guy (who had a narcicism streak) pretty much got very annoyed with me that I wanted to know more about those tests.
3) The quality & distance of the forensic facility: Most forensic psychiatric programs are a long distance away from the prison/forensic facility that holds the patient/client. Most places I interviewed at required I drive over 500 miles a week to get lectures at the medical campus, but have to drive about 2-4 hrs a day-each way(no kidding) to get to the prison. Some places even had a bed for the fellow to sleep in because they didn't want them driving 8 hrs a day.
4) Does the program director or any of the staff come off as "defense ******?" There are unfortunately plenty of forensic psychologists & psychaitrists willing to say someone's schizophrenic for the right amount of money. Go to a place where you feel the faculty are intellectually honest.
Likewise, several fellows I've kept in contact with tell me that there are several forensic psychiatrists who are very narcissistic. They earn a lot of money and they tend to be into their appearance, wear the $5000 suit, etc. Just like anyone with a cluster B-these types can be hard to get along with. Try to get a feel for the program since unlike residency, its usually only you, the PD, maybe 1-2 other fellows and the coordinator. Its easy to fly under the radar if you don't like the PD and there's 40 residents. If its only you or maybe 1-2 more and you don't get along, that's going to be a very uncomfortable year.
5) the reputation of the program director (very important): what are this person's qualifications, publications, reputation for honesty?
Rochester's PD is excellent, but Rochester isn't exactly a place that grabs people due to the bad weather.
OK, Ciccone is the head of Rochester. He's considered a giant in the field & well respected.
The PD at Albert Einstein is Merrill Rotter. I've talked to 4 fellows I know who did fellowship in NYC, all of them said they felt Rotter was the best, and 3 of them weren't under his supervision which really said something IMHO. Haven't asked Anasazi what he thought of the NYC PDs.
The PD at NYU is Richard Rosner: another giant in the field. He writes one of the gold standard texts in the field. Rosner from what I heard word of mouth has suffered from some health problems & isn't as active anymore.