Ranking NYC programs

[drfutureir]

---

Members don't see this ad.

There are so many programs in NYC and the surrounding area. Just want to get a better idea of the "supposed" prestige/overall strength/rank. Please help out

programs i'm looking at (in no particular order):
Montefiore / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
Jacobi / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
SUNY Health Science Center (in Brooklyn)
NY Methodist Hospital (in Brooklyn)
Maimonides (in Brooklyn)
NY Presbyterian (Columbia) (in NYC)
NY Presbyterian (Cornell) (in NYC)
Icahn at Mount Sinai, Beth Israel (in NYC)
Icahn at Mount Sinai (in NYC)
Icahn - St. Luke's
Hofstra North Shore-LIJ
NYU

 

[Strawman123]

There are so many programs in NYC and the surrounding area. Just want to get a better idea of the "supposed" prestige/overall strength/rank. Please help out

programs i'm looking at (in no particular order):
Montefiore / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
Jacobi / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
SUNY Health Science Center (in Brooklyn)
NY Methodist Hospital (in Brooklyn)
Maimonides (in Brooklyn)
NY Presbyterian (Columbia) (in NYC)
NY Presbyterian (Cornell) (in NYC)
Icahn at Mount Sinai, Beth Israel (in NYC)
Icahn at Mount Sinai (in NYC)
Icahn - St. Luke's
Hofstra North Shore-LIJ
NYU

Cornell=NYU>Columbia>>>>>all others.

 

[qxrt]

Isn't Beth Israel shutting down all of its residency programs in a year or two?

 

[Radz123]

If you're thinking IR then Mt Sinai should be your number one. No clue about Diagnostic prestige.

 

[josecanseco]

Which of the "big name" academic places would a average-below avg applicant have a shot at?

 

[justadumbbunny]

Which of the "big name" academic places would a average-below avg applicant have a shot at?

I don't think any of the 'big names' have a large number of avg to below avg matches. There are probably exceptions at every program, but I would think the main university programs in NYC are matching above avg applicants for the most part.

There are good programs in NYC that the avg applicant would have a shot at - Sinai affiliates, Lenox Hill, Maimonides, etc.

I would also consider Winthrop which isn't technically in the city but accessible by train if you wanted to commute and a solid program.

 

[RadLyfe]

Can you help with ranking these mid tier NYC programs?

University Programs:
Montefiore / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
Jacobi / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
SUNY Health Science Center (Kings County/University Hosp Brooklyn)
Hofstra North Shore-LIJ

Affiliates/Community:
Maimonides (in Brooklyn)
Icahn at Mount Sinai - Beth Israel
Icahn at Mount Sinai - St. Luke's/West
Harlem Hospital

 

[RadsonRads]

Can you help with ranking these mid tier NYC programs?

University Programs:
Montefiore / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
Jacobi / Albert Einstein (in the Bronx)
SUNY Health Science Center (Kings County/University Hosp Brooklyn)
Hofstra North Shore-LIJ

Affiliates/Community:
NY Methodist Hospital (in Brooklyn)
Maimonides (in Brooklyn)
Icahn at Mount Sinai - Beth Israel
Icahn at Mount Sinai - St. Luke's/West
Harlem Hospital

Monte is pretty solid. After that, I would say Hofstra-LIJ. Then Beth Israel (although isn't this program closing??? I am pretty sure Beth Israel hospital is closing, last I checked), then St. Lukes, then SUNY Downstate (horrendous area and population, but makes for some good training!), Harlem Hospital, Maimo, Jacobi, and I didn't even know NY Methodist had a program?

 

[CherryRedDracul]

I don't think any of the 'big names' have a large number of avg to below avg matches. There are probably exceptions at every program, but I would think the main university programs in NYC are matching above avg applicants for the most part.

There are good programs in NYC that the avg applicant would have a shot at - Sinai affiliates, Lenox Hill, Maimonides, etc.

I would also consider Winthrop which isn't technically in the city but accessible by train if you wanted to commute and a solid program.

There were rumors a couple of years ago that NYU and Cornell were filtering out anyone with a sub-250 Step 1. How much truth there is to that, I don't know.

 

[GadRads]

There were rumors a couple of years ago that NYU and Cornell were filtering out anyone with a sub-250 Step 1. How much truth there is to that, I don't know.

Absolutely false. Last year, I know some people who interviewed and matched at both programs with 240's.