Think of foreign medical school graduates, particularly those who aren't US citizens. Should they be given a position resulting in denying a qualified US citizen the chance to become an ophthalmologist? That's a question which could be posed as a separate post. Anyway, those successful foreigners don't always have the best qualifications but usually have some edge, for example connections or something unusual.
QUOTE]
Actually many of the FMGs would crush many US 4th years on paper; ie, number one in a class of 300, great letters from well known people, a dozen publications (not 10th name on a poster), possibly been in practice and/or have done a clinical fellowship in the US (you don't need to complete a US residency to do a US clinical fellowship). The reason many don't get a spot is either poor fit for the program, language barrier, or the perception that they are not "trainable" because they are already stuck in their way of doing things.
With a ~90% match rate for US grads I don't think there is a great conspiracy to keep US grads out of Ophthalmology.