Reapplying after withdrawing post-interview

[springfields]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

I understand that reapplying after being accepted to any medical school = bad. But withdrawing after an interview, I never heard of that affecting someone’s application.
Would it be safe to assume that it would have no bearing on reapplying?

 

[Engrailed]

I understand that reapplying after being accepted to any medical school = bad. But withdrawing after an interview, I never heard of that affecting someone’s application.
Would it be safe to assume that it would have no bearing on reapplying?

But why did you withdraw???
And would you apply to that school again? Why or why not

 

[springfields]

But why did you withdraw???
And would you apply to that school again? Why or why not

I would not apply to this school again.

 

[Nugester]

I would not apply to this school again.

I think you need to provide a little more info on why you withdrew.

 

[Engrailed]

I think you need to provide a little more info on why you withdrew.

And was it a case of applying to a school that you did not really intend on attending @springfields

 

[springfields]

I think you need to provide a little more info on why you withdrew.

Can you please help me understand why that would help you answer the question? Not trying to be sassy, but what is the relevance?

 

[Kirby Smart]

Can you please help me understand why that would help you answer the question? Not trying to be sassy, but what is the relevance?

Because it's relevant to whether they would care or not...I wouldn't want to interview you again if I was a medical school if I knew you interviewed last cycle and withdrew cause you weren't interested or something. It's a waste of their resources. But it if there was some reason you were forced to withdraw your app then maybe this is something you've already explained to them or that you can explain to them.

 

[springfields]

Because it's relevant to whether they would care or not...I wouldn't want to interview you again if I was a medical school if I knew you interviewed last cycle and withdrew cause you weren't interested or something. It's a waste of their resources. But it if there was some reason you were forced to withdraw your app then maybe this is something you've already explained to them or that you can explain to them.

When you apply to medical schools, they don’t ask you to check a box and explain why you are reapplying if you previously withdrew from a school post-interview, unlike reapplying after being accepted somewhere. Where would you have to explain your reasoning to adcoms?

 

[Bonne Nuit]

Where would you have to explain your reasoning to adcoms?

At an interview, maybe? And some secondaries do ask you discuss whether you've applied there before.

Edit: I'm confused. OP, are you a reapplicant who is asking whether you'd have to explain to medical school B why you elected to withdraw post-interview from school A? In that case, no, nobody cares.

 

[springfields]

Alternatively, what about those people who remove themselves from waitlists to reapply to medical schools?

 

[drducky.]

I think youre perfectly fine. I dont think anywhere on the app even asks for this. No one will even know besides the 1 school you withdrew from

 

[Bonne Nuit]

Alternatively, what about those people who remove themselves from waitlists to reapply to medical schools?

Why would you need to remove yourself from any waitlist while you prepare a new cycle's application?

 

[springfields]

At an interview, maybe? And some secondaries do ask you discuss whether you've applied there before.

If they ask you at an interview, then they clearly found you worthy of using their resources to interview you.

And some secondaries do ask if you applied to other schools, but they want to know what years, which schools, and how did you improve since then. Some secondaries ask why you are reapplying after being accepted someplace. But I never seen a secondary ask why you are reapplying after withdrawing post-interview.

 

[Kirby Smart]

When you apply to medical schools, they don’t ask you to check a box and explain why you are reapplying if you previously withdrew from a school post-interview, unlike reapplying after being accepted somewhere. Where would you have to explain your reasoning to adcoms?

I mean, idk about the process of adcoms seeing if you're a reapplicant. If you don't admit on a secondary to being a reapplicant do they not know? I'm assuming they're easily able to cross check whether you've applied before.

In this case, they'd probably see that you withdrew after being interviewed, no? If I noticed that as an adcom I'd make sure to ask you about it at an interview, but I'm not sure if this is the process or not.

 

[springfields]

Why would you need to remove yourself from any waitlist while you prepare a new cycle's application?

You’re right. Please disregard what I said 🙂

 

[Bonne Nuit]

OK so for whatever reason, I think the way this question was worded is confusing.

Here is my understanding of the scenario you're posing. Please correct me if I'm wrong:

Someone interviews at Med School A and withdraws post interview. You are asking whether it is necessary to elaborate to Med Schools B, C, D, E etc. about why one withdrew post-interview at A. This hypothetical person is NOT planning on re-applying this cycle to School A.

Is my understanding correct?

 

[springfields]

OK so for whatever reason, I think the way this question was worded is confusing.

Here is my understanding of the scenario you're posing. Please correct me if I'm wrong:

Someone interviews at Med School A and withdraws post interview. You are asking whether it is necessary to elaborate to Med Schools B, C, D, E etc. about why one withdrew post-interview at A. This hypothetical person is NOT planning on re-applying this cycle to School A.

Is my understanding correct?

Sort of, but you apply to Schools B, C, D, E, etc another cycle in the future.

So, for 2018 cycle, you apply to School A and you withdraw post-interview. Then for 2019 cycle, you apply to School B, C, etc.

 

[Bonne Nuit]

Sort of, but you apply to Schools B, C, D, E, etc another cycle in the future.

So, for 2018 cycle, you apply to School A and you withdraw post-interview. Then for 2019 cycle, you apply to School B, C, etc.

OK, I understand better now, thank you for clarifying.

No, there is no reason to elaborate to any third party about why School A wasn't a good fit in a previous cycle. As a matter of fact, it's probably best to avoid it unless asked directly (very unlikely). I would assume School A would have to be a pretty bad fit to withdraw post interview, and you know the adage "If you don't have anything nice to say..."

 

[Kirby Smart]

Sort of, but you apply to Schools B, C, D, E, etc another cycle in the future.

So, for 2018 cycle, you apply to School A and you withdraw post-interview. Then for 2019 cycle, you apply to School B, C, etc.

Oh, I assumed you meant applying to school A, withdrawing post-interview, and applying to school A again the next cycle.

I don't see why your scenario would affect applying to any other school.

 

[Nugester]

Sort of, but you apply to Schools B, C, D, E, etc another cycle in the future.

So, for 2018 cycle, you apply to School A and you withdraw post-interview. Then for 2019 cycle, you apply to School B, C, etc.

You are fine in this situation.

 

[Nugester]

Can you please help me understand why that would help you answer the question? Not trying to be sassy, but what is the relevance?

Misunderstood. If you aren't applying to "A" again withdrawing/reject is all the same to B, C, D etc.