Recommendation question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Hatman

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2007
Messages
125
Reaction score
0
I am goin to be a re-app this year and thought that I might as well obtain new recs. I asked one of my previous profs for an app and he responded with "I will write you a great rec but are you sure you want me to write one because I only knew you for a semester." Do you guys think I should take the rec or not because he is hesitant? It's tough trying to get to know a science prof for more than a semester because of their busy schedule and in my case, I met this great prof during my last undergrad semester. What do you guys think? Suggestions?
 
A great rec is one that speaks of your character and personality and how you would be great for medicine rather than performance in a class.

You could try meeting with the guy to discuss your goals and stuff, but if he is going to write you a "Jim took my class and got an A" letter, save him as a last resort.
 
I would try to meet with him before he writes it. Then he could write at least a little more than your academic performance. Otherwise, I'd try someone else.
 
A great rec is one that speaks of your character and personality and how you would be great for medicine rather than performance in a class.
True, but how well you can really judge someone's character and (to a lesser extent) personality is very debatable. I think the prof's just being honest.
 
I would try to meet with him before he writes it. Then he could write at least a little more than your academic performance. Otherwise, I'd try someone else.

Agreed. I'd ask to meet with him, bring a photo, your curriculum vitae, and a copy of your transcript. (Also bring a copy of the AMCAS application if it is complete at that time.) At the meeting, discuss your goals and allow him to get to know your personality. Then he will be able to write a LOR with depth and insight into who you are. Give him the tools he needs to write you a really great letter.
 
Top