regarding interviews

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

shock-me-sane

RN, PhD to come
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2006
Messages
144
Reaction score
0
Not quite as bad since doctors aren't exactly known for their social skills.

Definitely heard of some weird stuff though. I lucked out, the hardest question I got from my 3 interviews was "Tell me about your philosophy for clinical work". I hadn't even thought about it at that point since because of the schools I was applying to, I was told over and over that no one would care about clinical work there and not to even mention it unless they brought it up first.

I stumbled out "Ummm....CBT?" and then made some crap up about motivating clients.

Apparently it didn't sound too bad because I was waitlisted and I think I might have made it in if I hadn't pulled my app after getting accepted elsewhere.
 
Any prior interviewees have any insight?
I didn't get any weird questions at any interviews (I had 3) and I didn't find the interview process bad at all. It was actually kind of relaxed. They asked typical questions. In fact, I over-prepared for the interviews. It just seemed like they wanted to make sure people weren't serial killers or something.
 
I only had one rough interview, but it gave me a funny story about the quite prominent psychologist who (a) said she thought I was probably lying about loving research, just because most other people are, (b) didn't believe I knew how to do SEM and started quizzing me, then (c) started asking me if I thought a female-dominated profession would lead to more dating opportunities for me, with a nice heterosexual assumption thrown in there that I had a good time divesting her from.

My other interview days went great. One ended in hugs. If anything spoils it, I'd say it's more likely to be a bitter current grad student or two, or psychotically competitive applicants.
 
I had one tough interview from an ex-military psychologist who decided that his interview room = boot camp. He grilled me and argued with/challenged everything I said. The most difficult question was "tell me about a time in your life when you dealt with a diversity issue and how you handled it?" Umm...

I was able to provide him with a story that satisfied him, but I gotta say that thinking on your feet like that can really cause you to work up a sweat! You can't really prepare for those kinds of questions!
 
Can you guys list some of the questions you were asked?
 
The most difficult question was "tell me about a time in your life when you dealt with a diversity issue and how you handled it?" Umm...

You'll hear that question in a number of different iterations, but you'll hear it at most/all of your interviews.

Diversity can be a 'hot' topic. Dealing with adversity is popular, and looking at your thought process....and this question hits all three, which is why it is probably pretty popular.

-t
 
Can you guys list some of the questions you were asked?

Here's some questions that have been compiled from several years of grad students going to interviews and passing them along. I got them in UG from a new grad student in my lab:

Questions They Will Ask You
  • Tell me about yourself.
  • What are your greatest strengths/weaknesses?
  • Why this program?
  • Why this mentor?
  • What makes you a good fit for us?
  • What in your background has prepared you for graduate study?
  • How well do you think you would handle graduate school?
  • What part do you think would be the hardest for you?
  • Tell me about your research—be prepared to discuss it in depth, particularly your stats
  • Give me an example of a masters thesis you might like to do
  • What do you like to do for fun? Books, movies, etc.
  • Why do you want to get a PhD? Why not just get a Masters or a PsyD?
  • What sets you apart?
  • What is your primary orientation? (CBT, etc.)
  • Where do you want to be in ten years?
  • How can this program help you get to where you want to be in ten years?
  • What type of clinical experience have you had?
  • What was the hardest part/biggest challenge of your clinical experience?
  • What will you do if you aren’t accepted?
  • What other schools have you applied to? Where have you been accepted?
  • Why did you first decide to apply to this program?
  • What made you first interested in psychology?
  • How do you motivate yourself?
  • What has been your biggest achievement so far?
  • Tell me about a professor/colleague that you didn’t like and tell me why you didn’t like them.
  • What is an area that you need to improve in?
  • Tell me about a time you had to resolve a conflict and tell me what you did.
  • What is your social life like?
  • How do you rank among other students at your school?
  • If you had a year off, what would you do?
  • What do you like to do during the summer?
  • How many years do you want to graduate in?
 
Great list!

-t

It was extremely helpful to me, and I promised to "pay it forward". I also have "Questions You Should Ask," and "Questions You Should Ask Current Grad Students," if anyone is interested. I just didn't want to make a mile-long post. 🙄
 
oh please post those as well. That's quite helpful!

Of course if all the applicants on the board show up asking the same questions it'll be a bit of Deja Vu for profs and grad students :laugh:
 
oh please post those as well. That's quite helpful!

Of course if all the applicants on the board show up asking the same questions it'll be a bit of Deja Vu for profs and grad students :laugh:

Your wish is my command. I wouldn't worry about the redundancy of questions. There's nothing new in grad school interviews: they've heard them all before!

Questions to Ask Professors
  • Is the atmosphere here more collaborative or competitive?
  • How many years does it usually take students to graduate?
  • What type of placements do students usually get?
  • What type of internships do students usually get? How many get their first choice?
  • How does the class schedule work? (All courses in first two years, or spread out)
  • How much is the stipend? Is it guaranteed? Is it for research or for TAing?
  • How does mentoring work?
  • What are the strengths or weaknesses of your program?
  • What makes a student successful in this program?
  • How many publications do students usually leave this program with?
  • Where do students leaving this program usually work – academia, hospitals, or private practice?
  • Have you had any graduate students that did not work out? If yes, why? How was this resolved?
  • What are the summers like in your program? Do the graduate students participate in practica, also take classes, just do research, or what?

Questions to Ask Students
  • What made you decide to come here?
  • What do you like the most about this school?
  • What do you like the least?
  • How was the transition?
  • Was anything not like you expected based on your interview?
  • How is your relationship with your mentor?
  • How is your relationship with the other students?
  • Do you like it here?
  • What is the lab atmosphere like?
  • Are you comfortable with your mentor?
  • Do you think you are getting the training you need to do what you want to do?
  • Have you had any disagreements with professors? How have they been resolved?
 
Questions NOT to ask.

1. Have you slept with any of your students? and if so how many? (Seems to be all the rage in education these days.)
2. Have any of your students been hospitalized as a result of attending your program?
3. How do you deal with caffine abuse amongst the graduate students?
4. Do you feel that sleep deprivation is an effective teaching tool?
5. How much money can I get out of the program for coming here?
6. My number one choice is X, so tell me why I should consider your program?
7. Do you have a problem with the Aryan Brotherhood (or alternatively you can simply say republicans? <yes, I vote republican>)
8. Will you pay my moving expenses to attend your program? (Mine did actually.)
9. Do you have a shooting range on campus?
10. Can I just quit after I get my Master's Degree?

Sometimes less is more... Don't volunteer too much at the interviews. They don't want to hear that you have been hospitalized for suicide attempts and borderline personality disorder... Just because you are mentally ill doesn't in itself qualify you for a career in mental health. That would be like putting the drug addict in charge of the pharmacy!


Things to remember:

1. Be humble but confident
2. Good Eye Contact!
3. Listen attentively and try to avoid rolling your eyes when a professor you have no interest in is telling you about the psychology of the left handed bacon stretcher.
4. Stay on point. Don't talk too much about your personal life!
5. Keep it short, but interesting.
6. If the professor likes to talk, let them talk. If you can't take it anymore, then be assertive take control of the conversation but you better have a point and keep on target.
7. You'll learn more about the program if you stay with grad students.
8. If you don't know something, don't bull****, answer straight forward. Better to admit your shortcomings than attempt to bluff your way through. "I was hoping to learn (more) about that in graduate school" is always a great answer.

Mark
 
They paid for your moving expenses? Wowza!
 
They paid for your moving expenses? Wowza!

Special exception. I had to join the military to go to the school I am going to. Most people are unwilling to join the military to get a Ph.D. in clinical psychology... with the downside of being in the Navy comes significant perks.

1. My graduate school time counts towards retirement.
2. I get paid to go to school (and I get paid pretty damn well.)
3. No tuition
4. I don't have to compete for an internship (but I have to go to a Navy one in San Diego or DC.)
5. My moving costs are paid
6. Full medical and dental
7. I have a job guaranteed for 6 years after internship (time I am required to serve.)

For me, I was willing to put my ass on the line for those benefits. The likely downside is that in 6-8 years I will have to spend some time in Iraq or Afganistan for a year. The reality is that nearly all military psychologists will be deployed to a combat zone in the next 10 years at least once.

Mark

PS - I actually love being in the military.
 
My buddy did the Navy internship (in MD/DC) a few years ago and seemed to really enjoy it. I heard it was great training, and he was able to pick where he wanted to train (obviously barring an emergency).

-t
 
All right. Getting an interview is among the most exciting feelings in the world, I will admit. Nonetheless, I would like to put out there to anyone who has yet to have one, it's can be really hard to anticipate what's to come.

I went to an interview last year and the entire process of interviewing was kept very under wraps until we arrived: rotating group interviews. Woop.

I interviewed in the first time slot of the morning with my number one profressor of interest at that school. I sat with two strange girls who were terribly underprepared (one was socially very awkward and had a very messy sneeze in front of all the candidates during a presentation earlier in the morning, and the other has just moved to the U.S. and didn't understand most of the questions being asked of her). The professor clearly had no prepared questions. He made stuff up as he went and it became clear to me that he had some odd orientations regarding clincial training and some pointed opinions in terms of the work he has done. His previous research was not representative of his current leanings- in fact, I'm still not all that sure what he was reasearching.

He asked us what kind of work we'd been doing, and I supplied information about the children's mental health clinic that works in multidisciplinary teams, including a child psychiatrist and a behavioral pediatrician, and he said coldly, while rifling through papers that I could only assume were my resume and statement,

"Hon, it's not your fault that you work with the people you do. You just work with them..."

I was disgustingly insulted by his tone and insinuation, and can only imagine that he was directing his comments at my work with professionals who prescribe medication. I calmly acknowledged his skepticism, but defended my work rather intelligently. At that moment, however, my heart sank knowing that I'd traveled across the country to interview with some bozo, who I could never really have anticpated was such a bozo until I met him in person.

Some of his questions were:

"You have two parents who deal with a difficult child for many years, and then when the problems get better, the parents divorce. Why do you think this happens?"

"You have a little boy who isn't getting along with the kids in his class, what do you do?

I mean, I'm all for creativity in interviewing, but I just felt like I'd walked into a trap. He was looking for specific answers, but gave really no indication what they were.

Oh, and my favorite question he asked was,
"Who do you like more, Dr. Phil or the Super Nanny?"

I said Super Nanny. He agreed, but at that point in the interview, I wasn't really feeling like impressing him because I knew it was an awful fit that never would have worked.

I hope everyone has better interview experiences this year than I did with this guy!
 
Not having interviewed anywhere, I have nothing to add, but I just had to comment about the med school bizarre interview thread. It made me choke on a slivered peach. The psychologists really are a well-adjusted bunch compared to the MDs, aren't they?
 
I totally believe in pay it forward...that's why I'm checking out these posts.

I was asked in multiple interviews: Is there a book that you read that influenced your decision to pursue clinical psychology? I knew this in advance, so I started reading Irvin Yalom...anything by him is good reading and will assist you in understanding the therapeutic relationship.

Why did you choose clinical psychology and not counseling psychology or social work?

Describe your past "clinical" experiences - make sure you know what "clinical" pertains to: i.e. talking, listening, interacting with patients or research participants - I used to change the bandages on patient's wounds. - it was definitely medical, but I related the experiences to psychology because of the significant exchanges with patients during this process and describing how it was applicable to how they were feeling (mental status) and treatment adherence. I also got a ton of clincial experience through volunteering at a rape crisis center.

If you don't have any clinical experience, get out there and volunteer...it's not too late...it's the holidays! :idea:Show up at a soup kitchen and serve food, be creative - call your local YMCA or local hospitals to see if they need help. You could help distribute toys or read books to children. You could spend time at nursing homes. This is important. For humanities sake, they want to see your dedication to the field because once you are in a program, it becomes encompassing.

😉
 
I hope everyone has better interview experiences this year than I did with this guy!

Another strange interview moment.. this one brought to you by University of Kansas.

We had been traveling all day and informally talking but nothing remotely like an interview had occurred. We are at the after party and just about two beers in. Another interviewee (who I might add was quite accomplished and intelligent) and I were called by our potential research mentor to come talk (mind you she was a few beers in too.) We had the interview in the living room floor of some professors house. In what could only be described as a potential graduate student death match. (She won BTW.)

We actually were very nearly forced to spar to the intellectual death. I think the professor found it somewhat amusing. The other girl was a better fit than I was to be honest, and I am glad that she got the spot. In the end (I think) it had come down to me and her.

Mark
 
One piece of advice I have is look at the interview reviews on this site. Many of us from last year posted as much info as we could to help you and I wish we would have had them as they would have been very helpful. It will help you understand what to expect.

Also, I would say that it isn't uncommon for at least one interview to go terribly (though I had six so one was bound to go wrong). My first one was awful but my second one was the perfect match, so don't get discouraged, sometimes a school just isn't for you. You are interviewing them as well!
 
One piece of advice I have is look at the interview reviews on this site. Many of us from last year posted as much info as we could to help you and I wish we would have had them as they would have been very helpful. It will help you understand what to expect.

Also, I would say that it isn't uncommon for at least one interview to go terribly (though I had six so one was bound to go wrong). My first one was awful but my second one was the perfect match, so don't get discouraged, sometimes a school just isn't for you. You are interviewing them as well!

Irish,
I thought I had looked at the reviews and they are just Likert scale ratings. Are you refering to something different?
 
Irish,
I thought I had looked at the reviews and they are just Likert scale ratings. Are you refering to something different?

It is if you just go to the page for that school but down below you should see the detailed ratings that we wrote. For instance, here is mine for West Virginia University. http://share.studentdoctor.net/interviewpsych/show_entry.asp?ID=14

I at least tried to share a lot of information on what to expect and I think others did as well.
 
1. How do you like my SDN Psychology posts? Or who is your favorite SDN person?

2. What do people do for fun in this God forsaken town?

3. Did you have a dearth of good applicants lately, or are these current graduate student really your first choices?

4. Professor (to a woman), I can't help asking, are they real?

5. Professor, are your aware that your clothes do not match?

6. Have you accepted the Lord?

7. Since this is only my back up school, which of my first choices do you think I should attend.

8. Is there any chance the school could bump me up to first class on my flight home?

9. Professor, after I graduate, would you mind stepping down from your position so I can have it?

10. Professor, let's be honest. My credentials are really subpar. How much money is it going to take for you to accept me?

11. (To a graduate student) So who did you have to do a sexual favor for to get in here?
 
1. How do you like my SDN Psychology posts? Or who is your favorite SDN person?

2. What do people do for fun in this God forsaken town?

3. Did you have a dearth of good applicants lately, or are these current graduate student really your first choices?

4. Professor (to a woman), I can't help asking, are they real?

5. Professor, are your aware that your clothes do not match?

6. Have you accepted the Lord?

7. Since this is only my back up school, which of my first choices do you think I should attend.

8. Is there any chance the school could bump me up to first class on my flight home?

9. Professor, after I graduate, would you mind stepping down from your position so I can have it?

10. Professor, let's be honest. My credentials are really subpar. How much money is it going to take for you to accept me?

11. (To a graduate student) So who did you have to do a sexual favor for to get in here?

Hahaha. During my phone interview I flat-out told the prof that I was considering taking a year off to get into a different program rather than going to that school. I also said I wasn't a huge fan of the city.

Somehow, I still got in. But I think it was a slow year anyway, haha.
 
It is if you just go to the page for that school but down below you should see the detailed ratings that we wrote. For instance, here is mine for West Virginia University. http://share.studentdoctor.net/interviewpsych/show_entry.asp?ID=14

I at least tried to share a lot of information on what to expect and I think others did as well.

Thanks for pointing out these descriptive details. Very interesting.

"I am also not 100% sold on Morgantown, though it looks alright." - posted by Anonymous, 2007. :laugh::laugh::laugh:
 
For the record I do like Morgantown a lot more now. My fear was all the darn hills in the winter but so far, knock on wood, so good. Other than that it is a nice college town and the people are very friendly. The weather has also been much milder so far than I expected 🙂.

"Their grad students are awesome and definitely went above and beyond!" also posted by Anonymous, 2007 on WVU.
 
That would be awesome, you should let me know if you end up here or if you come out to interview as I can help with that (if you haven't been already). If there is anything I can do to help let me know!
 
That would be awesome, you should let me know if you end up here or if you come out to interview as I can help with that (if you haven't been already). If there is anything I can do to help let me know!


I was actually out that way last week for New Years; I stayed in a house next to Wisp (ski resort maybe an hour east of morgantown?).

-t
 
I was actually out that way last week for New Years; I stayed in a house next to Wisp (ski resort maybe an hour east of morgantown?).

-t

Psychodynamic T4C trained as a behaviorist in the Mountains of West Virginia while haning out with Irish80122. This could not be any better if it were scripted in Hollywood! :laugh: Is one school allowed to have so much pull on SDN?
 
Psychodynamic T4C trained as a behaviorist in the Mountains of West Virginia while hanging out with Irish80122. This could not be any better if it were scripted in Hollywood! :laugh: Is one school allowed to have so much pull on SDN?


:laugh:

A couple years ago I did some research and interventions using very behavioral ideas/techniques; it felt like I was cheating on my orientation! If Irish works with kids, I could work with that....though if not, I may have to use a lot of "air quotes" and "winks" when I'm talking.

-t
 
Tell me about a professor/colleague that you didn't like and tell me why you didn't like them.

Okay, for jobs, when you're asked "who was your most difficult employer and why?" You're not supposed to answer that one -- you do not give any indication that you've had a bad experience w/ employers.

Is this also the case for graduate interviews -- or will they think that you are bsing? Tbh, I haven't had a bad experience w/ a professor or colleague but I do want to prepare to present someone for this question if we are expected to answer it.
 
During an interview I had in 2006, the POI was completely inappropriate. He made me very uncomfortable by telling me I had a nice smile and told one of the other (smaller) girls interviewing: 'Don't take this the wrong way, but I like my women small.' Needless to say, as that was my only offer, I am re-applying this year with hopefully better results.
 
During an interview I had in 2006, the POI was completely inappropriate. He made me very uncomfortable by telling me I had a nice smile and told one of the other (smaller) girls interviewing: 'Don't take this the wrong way, but I like my women small.' Needless to say, as that was my only offer, I am re-applying this year with hopefully better results.

Wow. I would have let someone know about that.

-t
 
During an interview I had in 2006, the POI was completely inappropriate. He made me very uncomfortable by telling me I had a nice smile and told one of the other (smaller) girls interviewing: 'Don't take this the wrong way, but I like my women small.' Needless to say, as that was my only offer, I am re-applying this year with hopefully better results.

Where do people get off? It's amazing what people in positions of power will say. During my interviews last year, I had a POI ask me if I, or someone I knew, had HIV because he thinks research interests are often motivated by personal interest...so...1. excuse me? and 2. He was interested in HIV research, not me...
 
Wow. I would have let someone know about that.

-t
Sorry that this happened to JH2550a.

To whom could she have complained without shooting herself in the foot? Based on reading many posts and talking to people, I am sure there all types of breaches in etiquette and illegal questions asked on these interviews. Of course, it is usually your word against the professor's (although in this case the person has another candidate in the room). However, the minute one complains or takes some type of legal action, the possibility of getting accepted goes out the window. Even if a program was forced to accept someone due to legal action, how would the person be looked at or treated in the program? Professors are so academically incestuous that they might even let their colleagues at other schools know about the person as a trouble maker. The ultimate irony would be if one could win a legal case against one schools and use the money to pay for his/her education at another school! :laugh:
 
It was mentioned earlier in this thread that diversity is a hot topic when it comes to interviews. I am afraid to be asked during the interview "how will you be able to add diversity to our program?" I am a 22 year old, caucasian female and I would have no idea how to answer this question. Do you have any suggestions on how this question could be answered? Thanks!
 
Hi all!

I have a question regarding post-interview contact. In your thank you email, is it better to be brief, "thank you for meeting with me, i enjoyed getting to know you and the dept...etc" or is it better to be more specific and lengthy (ex. describe specifics about the interview/dept)? Any suggestions would be helpful.

Thanks!
 
I would make sure to be genuine, as people can usually tell if you are making a contact to make a contact, or if you are doing it for a real reason. For instance, after one of my internship interviews I e-mailed the TD to follow-up on a book recommendation in a particular area (I hadn't gotten the full title). I was able to get the title and discuss the pro's and con's of another book that we both had read. Does that make a difference in where I get ranked....probably not, but I found it helpful for the book recommendation, and also as a way to see the rational of one text recommendation over another. I had other interviews where I *wanted* to follow-up (more as a neurotic, "I want to make sure they remember me"), but realized that it wouldn't be genuine so I decided against it....as each site explicitly said that further contact isn't needed, but if I had other questions and whatnot I could call/e-mail.
 
I usually tried to reference a certain part of the interview that was especially salient to me. For example, in one discussion with my POI we talked about possible future research and she made a really interesting observation about my (then current) senior thesis project. I was able to incorporate her suggestion in my writing and it was really helpful. So I thanked her for that, told her what I did with it, and thanked her for granting me the interview to begin with.

But I'm with T4C...I wouldn't do it if it wasn't genuine. Just a simple thank you is better than trying to force something.
 
I have to wonder if thanking profs for the interview could perhaps be construed as a little manipulative. I mean, it's not like they are doing it as a favor -- they have to interview applicants. It's part of the process. Otherwise, they can't make their own decisions. Also, I seriously doubt that a thank-you note is going to sway anyone's decision either way.

I would say, if someone went out of their way to do something for you (i.e. a prof/grad student picked you up at the airport, or your POI gives you a textbook for free b/c it's an area you are really interested in, or if someone lets your wife/husband attend social events in the interview weekend), it's probably worth thanking the group or person. Otherwise, you might reconsider sending that thank you.

Just my 2 cents.
 
I have to wonder if thanking profs for the interview could perhaps be construed as a little manipulative. I mean, it's not like they are doing it as a favor -- they have to interview applicants. It's part of the process. Otherwise, they can't make their own decisions. Also, I seriously doubt that a thank-you note is going to sway anyone's decision either way.

I would say, if someone went out of their way to do something for you (i.e. a prof/grad student picked you up at the airport, or your POI gives you a textbook for free b/c it's an area you are really interested in, or if someone lets your wife/husband attend social events in the interview weekend), it's probably worth thanking the group or person. Otherwise, you might reconsider sending that thank you.

Just my 2 cents.

I respectfully disagree. They have to conduct interviews, true, but they didn't have to choose any one of us. Most profs extend a lot of courtesy while you're there, are very friendly, often have applicants to their homes, etc. At the very least it's the polite thing to do.
 
I don't see how a simple thank you could be seen as anything other than polite. It's not supposed to sway their decision. It's just the right thing to do. And I think in this day and age it makes you stand out a little too because I suspect a lot of people just don't send thank yous anymore.

I have to wonder if thanking profs for the interview could perhaps be construed as a little manipulative. I mean, it's not like they are doing it as a favor -- they have to interview applicants. It's part of the process. Otherwise, they can't make their own decisions. Also, I seriously doubt that a thank-you note is going to sway anyone's decision either way.

I would say, if someone went out of their way to do something for you (i.e. a prof/grad student picked you up at the airport, or your POI gives you a textbook for free b/c it's an area you are really interested in, or if someone lets your wife/husband attend social events in the interview weekend), it's probably worth thanking the group or person. Otherwise, you might reconsider sending that thank you.

Just my 2 cents.
 
I got some advice from a young psychologist who was on the admissions committee when he was in school.

*MOD NOTE: We don't allow links to people's blogs/websites as a general rule. -t*

I remember the interview process as not being too painful, so don't stress too much. One thing to remember is that programs are looking for people to train. In other words, while it's important to be confident and well-qualified, I always remembered to point out that I am or was still a student first and foremost and that I want to be there to learn what I don't know. I was on the actual admissions committee my last year of graduate school and the people who got slammed first were the ones who saw themselves as experts in whatever area they liked or the field of psych. in general. This is especially important for small programs. If they are going to take you, they want to know that you're thirsty for the knowledge they have, not how smart you are already.

Oh, and always have at least a question or two for every person you meet, even if you know the answer already. Otherwise you appear disinterested and programs hate making offers and then getting rejected.
 
Top