I talked to a handful of current students, as you mentioned. I had current students (I think from their first class) physically tell me they had gunners (with the mentioned sins above). Then - and this is the gut instinct thing here - a lot of the people interviewing with me just gave me the creeps man. The people just did not seem mature, they interrupted you/others when having conversation, they never talked about anything but medical school, it was all just a vibe. But perhaps I am being way too harsh, I certainly dont know, its hard to get over your own biases you know? And maybe a large chunk of the people interviewing dont even get in? I know they are a school that screens harder post-interview rather than pre-interview. And realistically, I dont know if I would have been able to pick up the weird vibes had I not had an AMAZING (or what I would perceive as amazing) interview day at a different school like 3 days before my interview at MUCOM.
MUCOM was one of my top picks for sure pre-interview. On paper they are seriously excellent and have some serious promise for the future. But I just had to follow my gut after visiting - and my gut said that I personally would not fit in. But the thing is, if your gut says you were happy there, then dont let anyone else tell you otherwise, you know? If YOU fit in fine, then it doesnt matter whether or not other people didnt like the atmosphere. Thats the whole core of this "find your fit" business. Some people are naturally very happy at a school, while others would literally pick not becoming a doctor rather than going there, it just is what it is. That is the kind of stuff that is hard to put on paper and explain to people. Its like, yea the school has thing A, B, C that are awesome and draw me to the school, but for whatever reason I just feel like its the right fit. It doesnt make sense, its hard to explain, but I think you need to follow your bodily cues. If you felt good there, then you will do just fine there, trust your gut. I mean heck, this is even part of the business with religion at schools. Some people truly thrive with the religious aspects that are found at schools like LUCOM and Loma Linda, etc. Hey more power to em, you know? If they trust that they would do well there, then good for them, thats great that they found the school where they fit. Others would hate those types of environments - ie they wouldnt "fit." Thats perfectly fine too, thats part of the reason why there are like 180 different schools, different strokes for different folks.