- Joined
- Aug 4, 2013
- Messages
- 2,371
- Reaction score
- 621
edited
Last edited:
Some schools like GW (I think) take the best of each subsection, so you might not be as bad as you think, BUT some average and others will consider you to have regressed.
You say you have good ECs, how are your letters? Do you have the money/time to blow on an application season? Look at the GPA/MCAT Grid for your race and see what your chances roughly are
https://www.aamc.org/data/facts/app...mcat-gpa-grid-by-selected-race-ethnicity.html
I'd say apply broadly (and look at each specific school and how they check out MCATs......BUY the MSAR and scour the websites), and you may have a chance. A 28/29 MCAT isn't necessarily a death sentence as long as the rest of your application looks good. Apply *strategically*.....meaning no Hopkins, Mayo, etc. If you're realistic about where you apply to, you'd have a shot. Also, I don't know how open to DO you are, but you'd be a very strong applicant there. I applied both DO and MD with a 25 MCAT (6P/10V/9B.....Physics/Gen Chem killed me, clearly), and ended up with 3 MD and 4 DO interviews. I'll be matriculating in the fall.
If you want to be a physician, this will not keep you from that. You just have to either apply smart and/or apply DO.
it's really long.
MD:
University of new mexico, Marshall, Central michigan, university of missouri-kansas, Frank H. netter, University of s. carolina greenville, florida state, university of arkansas, n.e. ohio medical uni, Commonwealth medical school (PA), tennessee, Michigan State, wright state university, boonshoft university of s dakota, cooper medical school of rowan, university of n dakota, university of AZ tucson, Rush, university of s. carolina: columbia, louisiana state N.O., florida atlantic uni, University of Kansas, UC Riverside, Virginia tech, university of oklahoma, oakland university, Virginia commonwealth, Albany, nevada, george washington, indiana school of medicine, medical school of WI, university of illinois, Tulane university, oregon, fsu, jefferson, university of hawaii, college of nebraska, UC Davis, temple, uni of vermont, university of washington, university of kentucky, university of minnesota, medical college of georgia, toledo, chicago-med franklin, buffalo, brown, university of ny upstate medical, state uni of ny downstate ,university of colorado, chapel hill, tufts, uc irvine, and university of cincinnati.
I took out crieghton because they require humanities letters of recommendations
DO: everything
Ok.....I think you may not have thought this through. You have waaaaaaaayyy too many state schools in there. It's a pretty rare instance that some of your choices even consider OOS applicants. U of Hawaii, for instance. If you're not a resident of Hawaii, of Hawaiian descent, or a resident of Alaska (there's a weird unspoken relationship between Hawaii and AK), then they pretty much don't look at your application. Many others in your list are similar, but to a slightly less stringent aspect. Buy the MSAR, and calculate the percentage of OOS applicants are accepte/matriculate and go from there. Otherwise, you'll be wasting a LOT of money.
how many and what MD schools did you apply to if you don't mind me asking? I bought the msar and my list above is pretty much what i'm going to apply to and based off of that and a few other sites. The rest of my app is great it's just these scores. Also, what was your gpa?
I got the MSAR and I've been using OOS data (Pretty much taking every school w/ over 50%). My parents do own a house in hawaii so maybe that'd help.
it's really long.
MD:
University of new mexico, Marshall, Central michigan, university of missouri-kansas, Frank H. netter, University of s. carolina greenville, florida state, university of arkansas, n.e. ohio medical uni, Commonwealth medical school (PA), tennessee, Michigan State, wright state university, boonshoft university of s dakota, cooper medical school of rowan, university of n dakota, university of AZ tucson, Rush, university of s. carolina: columbia, louisiana state N.O., florida atlantic uni, University of Kansas, UC Riverside, Virginia tech, university of oklahoma, oakland university, Virginia commonwealth, Albany, nevada, george washington, indiana school of medicine, medical school of WI, university of illinois, Tulane university, oregon, fsu, jefferson, university of hawaii, college of nebraska, UC Davis, temple, uni of vermont, university of washington, university of kentucky, university of minnesota, medical college of georgia, toledo, chicago-med franklin, buffalo, brown, university of ny upstate medical, state uni of ny downstate ,university of colorado, chapel hill, tufts, uc irvine, and university of cincinnati.
I took out creighton because they require humanities letters of recommendations and I don't have one. Any recommendations of what to cut off? This list comes from MSAR, us news and LizzyM data.
DO: everything
it's really long.
MD:
University of new mexico, Marshall, Central michigan, university of missouri-kansas, Frank H. netter, University of s. carolina greenville, florida state, university of arkansas, n.e. ohio medical uni, Commonwealth medical school (PA), tennessee, Michigan State, wright state university, boonshoft university of s dakota, cooper medical school of rowan, university of n dakota, university of AZ tucson, Rush, university of s. carolina: columbia, louisiana state N.O., florida atlantic uni, University of Kansas, UC Riverside, Virginia tech, university of oklahoma, oakland university, Virginia commonwealth, Albany, nevada, george washington, indiana school of medicine, medical school of WI, university of illinois, Tulane university, oregon, fsu, jefferson, university of hawaii, college of nebraska, UC Davis, temple, uni of vermont, university of washington, university of kentucky, university of minnesota, medical college of georgia, toledo, chicago-med franklin, buffalo, brown, university of ny upstate medical, state uni of ny downstate ,university of colorado, chapel hill, tufts, uc irvine, and university of cincinnati.
I took out creighton because they require humanities letters of recommendations and I don't have one. Any recommendations of what to cut off? This list comes from MSAR, us news and LizzyM data.
DO: everything
what state are you from? Some of these schools don't make sense to me unless you are a resident or have really strong ties to the area.
I'd still rethink the Hawaii app. Unless you are a resident yourself, are Hawaiian, or Alaskan, they accept only geniuses. Seriously.....look at the MSAR data, and those handful of OOS students each year are either insanely gifted or from Alaska.
Source: my cousin works for the U of Hawaii and tried to get me to apply there. Logistics just wouldn't work with a family.
I'll comment on what I know (though some of this is contigent on your state of residency):
Edit - I noticed CA as your state of residency so I've updated this
Pretty much no chance at the following:
USD - No chance unless you have STRONG ties (i.e., grew-up there), or are native american.
UND - I know we have a pretty awesome hockey team and our 100+ F summers with 85%+ humidity and -30+ F (-70 when you factor in windchill) is a god send for most people, but unfortunately 0% chance unless you're a former long term resident, WICHE, MN, or native. 7 spots are reserved for native american students and 11 OOS spots are reserved for MN/WICHE applicants, the rest go to IS.
Tulane - They have a very strong preference for MCAT > GPA. IIRC the means for matriculants are ~34 MCAT 3.4 GPA
Oregon - For OOS you pretty much need a 3.6+ and 32+ for consideration
Hawaii - Slim chances unless you have STRONG ties
U of MN - Very slim chance at TC campus, 0% at the Duluth campus
Brown - Most matriculants come from their BS/MD program
U of Wash - Unless you truly are commited to rural health, no chance.
I would consider adding NYMC to your list.
California, what schools should I take out? I took out utah's medical school bc it requires ties to their area.
I got the MSAR and I've been using OOS data (Pretty much taking every school w/ over 50%). My parents do own a house in hawaii so maybe that'd help.
California, what schools should I take out? I took out utah's medical school bc it requires ties to their area.
makes sense, will do. I'd love to go to med school in hawaii though
will do. i'll take all those off. what exactly defines strong ties btw? Does having parents w/ a condo in hawaii count as strong ties? 😛 I will add NYMC, any other recommendations of what to add? thanks for your help I really appreciate it 🙂.
I'd take out pretty much every state school except those in California. If you grew up somewhere else, did undergrad somewhere else, or your parents are now in a different state, then think about applying to any of those states. Otherwise, good luck with that one. It really is a big, fat waste of $$ applying to most OOS schools. Sprinkle a couple in that you'd LOVE to go to, but your list is WAY too state-heavy.
I'd take out pretty much every state school except those in California. If you grew up somewhere else, did undergrad somewhere else, or your parents are now in a different state, then think about applying to any of those states. Otherwise, good luck with that one. It really is a big, fat waste of $$ applying to most OOS schools. Sprinkle a couple in that you'd LOVE to go to, but your list is WAY too state-heavy.
okay for clarification, what exactly counts as a state school? I want to apply broadly as possible and maximize my chances of getting in.
University of new mexico, Marshall, Central michigan, university of missouri-kansas, Frank H. netter, University of s. carolina greenville, florida state, university of arkansas, n.e. ohio medical uni, Commonwealth medical school (PA), tennessee, Michigan State, wright state university, boonshoft university of s dakota, cooper medical school of rowan, university of n dakota, university of AZ tucson, Rush, university of s. carolina: columbia, louisiana state N.O., florida atlantic uni, University of Kansas, UC Riverside, Virginia tech, university of oklahoma, oakland university, Virginia commonwealth, Albany, nevada, george washington, indiana school of medicine, medical school of WI, university of illinois, Tulane university, oregon, fsu, jefferson, university of hawaii, college of nebraska, UC Davis, temple, uni of vermont, university of washington, university of kentucky, university of minnesota, medical college of georgia, toledo, chicago-med franklin, buffalo, brown, university of ny upstate medical, state uni of ny downstate ,university of colorado, chapel hill, tufts, uc irvine, and university of cincinnati.
I took out creighton because they require humanities letters of recommendations and I don't have one. Any recommendations of what to cut off? This list comes from MSAR, us news and LizzyM data.
... You must've read something wrong. The bolded are all schools that take less than 50% OOS
Marshall - Can't apply unless you are resident of WV or a state that touches WV.
NE Ohio Med - only takes ohio residents, mostly via BS/MD
and public ones are automatically state schools? I don't get it.MSAR will tell you whether it is public or private
okay for clarification, what exactly counts as a state school? I want to apply broadly as possible and maximize my chances of getting in.
what are you calculating? I'm looking at the MSAR and it shows that 4% of their class is OOS.wait what? I calculated out of state students accepted and got totally diff numbers off the msar that was just released. starting with university of new mexico which shows
74.20%.
wait what? I calculated out of state students accepted and got totally diff numbers off the msar that was just released. starting with university of new mexico which shows
74.20%.
and public ones are automatically state schools? I don't get it.
How did you get that number...
what are you calculating? I'm looking at the MSAR and it shows that 4% of their class is OOS.
i was using apps verified, i should be using interviewed right?
wait what? I calculated out of state students accepted and got totally diff numbers off the msar that was just released. starting with university of new mexico which shows
74.20%.
wait what? I calculated out of state students accepted and got totally diff numbers off the msar that was just released. starting with university of new mexico which shows
74.20%.
what are you calculating? I'm looking at the MSAR and it shows that 4% of their class is OOS.
Are you looking at IS vs OOS applications? Because I don't think ANY state school has an OOS matriculant percentage over 50%! Most are between 0% and 15ish%. If it says "public" on MSAR, it's a "state" school. There are very few private universities that have heavy regional or state bias, so those are always your best bet when applying out of state.
ok, should i be applying to the schools closer to 15% OOS? I have a lot less options than I thought I did =/ based off of this.
ok.. so if you were just looking at how many they interview out of the apps they get for OOS, it would be 3%
Are you looking at IS vs OOS applications? Because I don't think ANY state school has an OOS matriculant percentage over 50%! Most are between 0% and 15ish%. If it says "public" on MSAR, it's a "state" school. There are very few private universities that have heavy regional or state bias, so those are always your best bet when applying out of state.
No, you should be applying to schools closer to 20%.
In my opinion, you should look at two things when considering an OOS public school: percentage of OOS applicants interviewed, and then percentage of OOS accepted or matriculated. Many times, it's hard to get an interview at those schools, and just as hard to get an acceptance.
Example: U of Kansas had somewhere around 4,000 OOS applicants last year. They interviewed 135, accepted 29, and 14 matriculated. Their IS stats are much more favorable and they accept roughly half of their IS interviewees.
yes, these are the two numbers I gave him
Agreed.
Yeah....I'm slow on my phone, and by the time I had it all typed up and hit enter, there was a half dozen new posts! Darn slow fingers!
20% OOS? that still seems really not worth the effort...
20% OOS? that still seems really not worth the effort...
20% OOS? that still seems really not worth the effort...
20% seems decent. At this point im willing to take a few hits if it gives me more of a chance of getting in.
20% is the lowest I'd go. Also, I suggest reading the mission statements for a lot of the schools you have on your list... for example, unless if you grew up in the inland empire, don't bother with riverside. Your mcat will hold you back from california schools, unless if you are URM.
Florida schools also have very high OOS tuition rates. You really need to do more research about your schools.