Rosen's and Tintinalli's

[vtucci]

For those of you who have the most recent versions of both Rosen and Tintinalli, what are you thoughts about the strengths and weaknesses of each text.

We have Tintinalli as required reading but I was considering buying Rosen.

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[Old_Mil]

For those of you who have the most recent versions of both Rosen and Tintinalli, what are you thoughts about the strengths and weaknesses of each text.

We have Tintinalli as required reading but I was considering buying Rosen.

While the pocket and just the facts versions are ok, big tint is one of the most repetitious, poorly edited, and internally inconsistent textbooks I've ever seen. Both Rosens and Harwood-Nuss are far better.