- Joined
- Mar 24, 2012
- Messages
- 5
- Reaction score
- 0
I am coming up to the 3/4 mark of my second year, and frankly I feel as if the past year and a bit has been me "phoning it in" 8 or 9 days out of 10. I hate myself for doing this, because it isn't fair to anybody--not to the future patients, not to the other students, not to our instructors and support staff, not to my family and friends, and not to myself. All passion seems gone from my pursuit of medicine about 95% of the time, whether it is lectures, labs, case based learning (CBL) sessions, or clinical skills sessions (my school has a CBL and systems-based curriculum). I kept thinking that it was a bad unit, or I was experiencing a bit of depression, or I was being lazy, or...I don't know what else. None of these explanations hold water after more than a year. I have never consistently felt this way before, not even in the worst period of grad school when I was suffering from very bad depression (suicidal, barely able to get out of bed, crying at my desk), and it seemed like my projects were going nowhere. I still thought it was important to show up to the lab and give it my best.
I have begun to seriously reflect on my personality, strengths and weaknesses, and passions. My passions are how the mind works, politics and policy, and teaching. I also still have an interest in chemistry and the physical sciences (but I think pursuing a PhD would be the wrong thing to do--I left with a masters degree after deciding against this). None of these subjects, outside of the two week block of psychiatry and some aspects of immunology and (integrated) pharmacology, ever come up in any sustained way during the first two years of medical school. A 1 year masters in public policy is starting to look very attractive as a springboard to an alternative career that I actually care about.
I came into medical school, in my mid to late 20s (after a change from a PhD career track in chemistry and some additional preparation), with what I believed were the right reasons--a mix of motives including intellectual curiosity about a challenging field, making a difference in the lives of people, a passion for psychiatry, and a well-paying and secure profession. What I thought was a mature, robust, and realistic mix of motives. My interest in psychiatry was reinforced through a small research project in the area last summer: my favorite part of that job by far was talking to the psych. patients in interviews. I have been told that I have great analytical and critical thinking skills, as well as a nice bedside manner. But I hate, hate, hate the mountains of memorization--the brachial plexus isn't harder than quantum mechanics or advanced organic chemistry (easier, if anything), but it is soul crushingly boring.
I have heard from some people that clerkship and beyond, despite their significant challenges and stresses, are far more satisfying than the preclinical years. Others have said that preclinical students don't realize how easy they have it and that "you ain't seen nothing yet". It seems to depend on the person, the school, and the chosen specialty, from what I can piece together. Is clerkship still mostly memorizing mind numbing information in between scrambling to learn how to navigate the hospital's records, professional hierarchies, doing "real" histories and exams, and doing the occasional procedure? Is 95% of medicine shoveling tedium into your mind, mixed with a robotic application of probability algorithms?
I realize that neither life, nor especially medical school, is all puppy dogs and rainbows for 99.9% of people, but at what point does it go beyond "sucking it up" to unnecessary self-punishment, as well as the wrong career path? What if I stick with this, survive, and then emerge from it in my mid to late 30s still hating my life? I refuse to believe that all jobs/life in the "real world" must make a person miserable.
I have been speaking with a psychiatrist, a counselor, my school's director of student affairs, and will be speaking to the assistant dean in the near future on this subject. In the meantime, any constructive and mature input would be appreciated.
I have begun to seriously reflect on my personality, strengths and weaknesses, and passions. My passions are how the mind works, politics and policy, and teaching. I also still have an interest in chemistry and the physical sciences (but I think pursuing a PhD would be the wrong thing to do--I left with a masters degree after deciding against this). None of these subjects, outside of the two week block of psychiatry and some aspects of immunology and (integrated) pharmacology, ever come up in any sustained way during the first two years of medical school. A 1 year masters in public policy is starting to look very attractive as a springboard to an alternative career that I actually care about.
I came into medical school, in my mid to late 20s (after a change from a PhD career track in chemistry and some additional preparation), with what I believed were the right reasons--a mix of motives including intellectual curiosity about a challenging field, making a difference in the lives of people, a passion for psychiatry, and a well-paying and secure profession. What I thought was a mature, robust, and realistic mix of motives. My interest in psychiatry was reinforced through a small research project in the area last summer: my favorite part of that job by far was talking to the psych. patients in interviews. I have been told that I have great analytical and critical thinking skills, as well as a nice bedside manner. But I hate, hate, hate the mountains of memorization--the brachial plexus isn't harder than quantum mechanics or advanced organic chemistry (easier, if anything), but it is soul crushingly boring.
I have heard from some people that clerkship and beyond, despite their significant challenges and stresses, are far more satisfying than the preclinical years. Others have said that preclinical students don't realize how easy they have it and that "you ain't seen nothing yet". It seems to depend on the person, the school, and the chosen specialty, from what I can piece together. Is clerkship still mostly memorizing mind numbing information in between scrambling to learn how to navigate the hospital's records, professional hierarchies, doing "real" histories and exams, and doing the occasional procedure? Is 95% of medicine shoveling tedium into your mind, mixed with a robotic application of probability algorithms?
I realize that neither life, nor especially medical school, is all puppy dogs and rainbows for 99.9% of people, but at what point does it go beyond "sucking it up" to unnecessary self-punishment, as well as the wrong career path? What if I stick with this, survive, and then emerge from it in my mid to late 30s still hating my life? I refuse to believe that all jobs/life in the "real world" must make a person miserable.
I have been speaking with a psychiatrist, a counselor, my school's director of student affairs, and will be speaking to the assistant dean in the near future on this subject. In the meantime, any constructive and mature input would be appreciated.
Last edited: