Silent Rejections

Started by aznb0y129
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

aznb0y129

Oh hamburgers!
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Not that this has happened to me yet, but I've read several posts from former applicants saying that some schools don't even bother to notify you that you've been rejected. You'd think after taking our secondary fees and stringing us along for months and months, they could have the decency to mail a form letter for 40 cents?
 
Not that this has happened to me yet, but I've read several posts from former applicants saying that some schools don't even bother to notify you that you've been rejected. You'd think after taking our secondary fees and stringing us along for months and months, they could have the decency to mail a form letter for 40 cents?

I'm in the same boat as you, we have quite a few schools in common. Did you bother calling any of them to check your status?

I want to call but it's probably pointless.
 
aaahhhh...the ol' "silent but deadly" maneuver!

maybe they just like to keep applicants around in case lots of accepted ones withdraw to go elsewhere.
I don't know 😕

should we start a list saying which ones we have been complete at for 2+ months but no communication at all?
 
I'm in the same boat as you, we have quite a few schools in common. Did you bother calling any of them to check your status?

I want to call but it's probably pointless.

Not yet, I was planning to wait until the end of October. And even then, I was planning to use email b/c I figured it would be less intrusive.
 
should we start a list saying which ones we have been complete at for 2+ months but no communication at all?

That's a decent idea. I'll get the ball rolling (mine are virtually 2 months)

Rochester: Complete 8/19
Jefferson: Complete 8/19
Drexel: Complete 8/19
Northwestern: Complete 8/21
 
should we start a list saying which ones we have been complete at for 2+ months but no communication at all?
that might not be a bad idea...but I dont think I can participate in said list.
Because although I have been "complete" at many schools since late July to early August, I had a pending MCAT score that probably made a majority of schools postpone review of my application.
Which is why I think I just recently scored so many interviews--cuz they had already seen my app, but were just waiting for an MCAT that supported how smart I claimed to be 😉 lol

and for what its worth--I'm still getting the cold shoulder from two DO schools that I feel more than competitive for.

I'm guessing all this waiting to hear back from schools has a lot to do with all schools getting "unprecedented" numbers of applications. Every school I have interviewed with has told me about how crazy it has been this year in regards to years prior.
 
That's a decent idea. I'll get the ball rolling (mine are virtually 2 months)

Rochester: Complete 8/19
Jefferson: Complete 8/19
Drexel: Complete 8/19
Northwestern: Complete 8/21

I wouldn't assume rejection even if you've been complete for 2+ months. I received a few invites around the 2 month mark and still haven't heard from a chunk of schools that I am still hopeful for.

As for Rochester, they get a ridiculous # of applications and don't necessarily review them in the order they receive them, so you could be complete for a LONG time and still get an invite to interview!

From the Northwestern thread last year, it seems like they didn't start giving out rejections until January and beyond.

Not sure on Jefferson and Drexel.
 
i think i heard jefferson does the silent rejection.
 
Not sure on Jefferson and Drexel.

These two schools are notorious for NEVER getting back to many people. I saw a post here from a student who reapplied to Drexel this year--and just got a rejection letter from LAST year. And some people still haven't gotten an official rejection two years later.
 
I've been complete for 2 months at 6 schools and heard no news =(. I just assumed that was normal since on my interview trail all the medical students were saying that they didn't get interviews until january.
 
These two schools are notorious for NEVER getting back to many people. I saw a post here from a student who reapplied to Drexel this year--and just got a rejection letter from LAST year. And some people still haven't gotten an official rejection two years later.

Things like that really piss me off because when you call and ask, they tell you to be patient but you end up waiting forever, literally. And clearly they have no intention of interviewing those people, so how hard can it be to reject them? Maybe it's just me.
 
Things like that really piss me off because when you call and ask, they tell you to be patient but you end up waiting forever, literally. And clearly they have no intention of interviewing those people, so how hard can it be to reject them? Maybe it's just me.

I completely agree with you...it just gives you closure on these schools rather than false hope that is drawn out for months.
 
Why are we talking about silent rejections in October? My powers of delusion obviously run deeper than yours. I'll be daydreaming about Case, Penn & Emory until March.
 
Why are we talking about silent rejections in October? My powers of delusion obviously run deeper than yours. I'll be daydreaming about Case, Penn & Emory until March.

I dunno how much time I am supposed to wait after having been complete before I should start thinking about silent rejections. 2 months seems appropriate to me.

That doesn't mean I won't continue to wait though, albeit impatiently.
 
i'd rather not get any rejections or at most get an email. dont need to rub it in. if a girl rejects you, do you want a letter as well? but overall this is meaningless. result is the same. more worried if i dont get in anywhere, what do i do then? i'd be kinda embarassed to ask my profs to write me letters for a different profession...
 
i'd rather not get any rejections or at most get an email. dont need to rub it in. if a girl rejects you, do you want a letter as well? but overall this is meaningless. result is the same. more worried if i dont get in anywhere, what do i do then? i'd be kinda embarassed to ask my profs to write me letters for a different profession...

I disagree. Your analogy doesn't quite work because you don't know the girl has rejected you: you just continue to wait until May for some kind of response while she hems and haws and basically jerks you around for a while. If she is going to reject me, I'd rather her do it upfront so I don't waste my time waiting around for her and I can move on.
 
I disagree. Your analogy doesn't quite work because you don't know the girl has rejected you: you just continue to wait until May for some kind of response while she hems and haws and basically jerks you around for a while. If she is going to reject me, I'd rather her do it upfront so I don't waste my time waiting around for her and I can move on.
well if a girl isnt all over me, i dont trouble myself thinking about her anyway
 
well if a girl isnt all over me, i dont trouble myself thinking about her anyway

I hope you don't hold the same philosophy towards med schools. Unless you've cured cancer and AIDS recently, none of them are going to be "all over you." There are hundreds of equally competitive applicants who would be more than happy to take your spot.
 
I hope you don't hold the same philosophy towards med schools. Unless you've cured cancer and AIDS recently, none of them are going to be "all over you." There are hundreds of equally competitive applicants who would be more than happy to take your spot.
more like thousands 😛
 
Why are we talking about silent rejections in October? My powers of delusion obviously run deeper than yours. I'll be daydreaming about Case, Penn & Emory until March.

I'm totally with you, it seems REALLY early to assume 8+ wks completion = rejection. I'm not going to start thinking about the silent rejection option until at least Jan. So many people (non-sdn) have marveled at how early I started interviewing and said they got their acceptances from dec/jan/feb interviews.

I do agree that it would be nice if schools just went ahead and told you right away if you have zero chance.
 
I think this list should be used to write down the schools known to drag students along. So anyone can add the schools they haven't heard from in 2+ month but if they do hear from them, they should take it off.

Rochester: Complete 8/19
Jefferson: Complete 8/19
Drexel: Complete 8/19
Northwestern: Complete 8/21
Columbia - Don't send rejections till March
 
Rochester : Complete 8/19
Jefferson: Complete 8/19
Drexel: Complete 8/19
Northwestern: Complete 8/21
Columbia : Don't send rejections till March[/quote]
NYMC : Complete 8/05
 
Just for fun, I'd like to see a school write this:

Dear Applicant,

We reject you from the entering class of University of Your-Name-Here Medical School.

Sincerely,

The Admissions Team

I'm on the fence if it should also include something like "May God have mercy on your soul," or "Have a nice day."
 
Just for fun, I'd like to see a school write this:



I'm on the fence if it should also include something like "May God have mercy on your soul," or "Have a nice day."
I have a friend who received an email from a school which started like this "...We wish to inform you that we are unable to offer you a seat....". I received a rejection letter last year from a NY school saying "...thanks for coming to the interview...." and went on to say that they are unable to offer me a seat. But the problem is that they never invited me for an interview. It seems these schools are taking us, applicants for granted. It doesn't matter what they do and they think that students will continue to apply.
 
Thomas Jefferson.. Repeat Thomas Jefferson.

They took my money, never to be heard from again.
 
Rochester : Complete 8/19
Jefferson: Complete 8/19
Drexel: Complete 8/19
Northwestern: Complete 8/21
Columbia : Don't send rejections till March
NYMC : Complete 8/05[/QUOTE]

I completed Jefferson September of 2006. Never heard from them again. Thought I'd give it another try this go 'round. Nothing as of yet.
 
I disagree. Your analogy doesn't quite work because you don't know the girl has rejected you: you just continue to wait until May for some kind of response while she hems and haws and basically jerks you around for a while. If she is going to reject me, I'd rather her do it upfront so I don't waste my time waiting around for her and I can move on.

Yeah, girls are wierd and probably have cooties. Except for MrsAgreeable who has yet to be found🙁. Lol, it wasn't the best of analogies but it was close enough