To the person who originally posted this question, it will ultimately just depend on who you enjoy spending your time with most. All of my closest friends are much less academic than I am, many without degrees. They are my closest friends because we have similar values and "they get me." I'm just thankful I have a personality that makes them want to keep me around, since our levels of education are so "different." A doctorate is a far cry from guaranteeing this kind of connection with someone else who has a doctorate. Although I have made lifelong friends with some of my classmates, once again because they are people I would have bonded with if we had never met through school.
Also, I am a woman and I care tremendously about NCAA football, don't be so insulting!