Something with ice cubes

Discussion in 'MCAT Study Question Q&A' started by Scarletblack, Jun 21, 2008.

1. Scarletblack 2+ Year Member

Joined:
Jun 3, 2008
Messages:
130
0
Status:
Pre-Medical
There was a weird question that I found (I don't remember where):

A large ice cube floats in a cup of water. Several coins are embedded in the ice cube. What happens when the ice cube melts?

(a) The water level falls
(b) The water level stays the same
(c) The water level rises
(d) Cannot be determined

Ok so for a regular ice cube, the water level would stay the same because Archimede's principle states that

"A body wholly or participally immersed in a fluid will be buoyed up by a force = weight of the fluid it displaces."

So a smaller volume of water is displaced because the ice cube is less dense. However as it melts, it becomes more dense and has less volume so the water level would be the same.

However, here, I thought the coins are even MORE dense and thus should make the water level rise.

But the actual answer is that (a) it falls. Why is this?

2. seraph524 M0 2+ Year Member

Joined:
Sep 19, 2006
Messages:
1,588
1
Status:
MD/PhD Student
This scenario was brought up a couple of days ago by another poster...

The reason the water level falls is that an un-encapsulated coin displaces a volume of water equal to its own volume, while an encapsulated coin in ice displaces a volume of water that represents the mass of the coin in ice. And since it is in ice, it will displace an even higher volume since ice has lower density than water.

In other words, if a coin is 2 grams, and is in ice, it will displace water by a volume of ice that weights 2 grams. However, if the coin is merely at the bottom of the cup, it will only displace a volume of water equal to its own metal volume.

Stop hovering to collapse... Click to collapse... Hover to expand... Click to expand...
3. physics junkie 5+ Year Member

Joined:
Nov 20, 2006
Messages:
539
2
There is actually no way to tell. If the ice cubes were very, very large or the coins were very small or of equal density to water you would get different answers. Seraph got the principles right but the actual question is bull****.

Joined:
May 19, 2008
Messages:
163
2
Status:
Pre-Medical
5. BerkReviewTeach Company Rep & Bad Singer Vendor 10+ Year Member

Joined:
May 25, 2007
Messages:
3,853
623
One can assume that metallic coins are more dense than water and therefore more dense than ice. But it's those damn wooden nickels that cause the problem on a question like this. What if they are balsa wood coins?

Once again, it brings up the point, don't take any wooden nickels.

Stop hovering to collapse... Click to collapse... Hover to expand... Click to expand...

Joined:
Nov 20, 2006
Messages:
539