- Joined
- Jul 28, 2008
- Messages
- 35
- Reaction score
- 0
So in those "where should I go?" threads some people raised the question: just how much higher is ivy school's specialization rate than that of a state school's? And would it be worth it to go? I would like to know you guys' take on this.
Personally, I think that if one isn't looking to specialize, one's money would be best served at a cheaper alternative. The advantages are real. One would be in way less debt, living closer to home, and the plan of opening that dream private practice can start earlier. One would also probably get more clinical training.
This is also what I was told at my Columbia interview. My interviewer told me, rather emphatically I might add, that if I just want to become a skilled clinician or GP, I should not come here.
Now let's assume that I do want to specialize (I don't have an earthly clue right now. Next couple of days will be spent in turmoil). Columbia touts 95+ specialization rate, but we all know that it kind of beefed that number up with GPR and AEGD, so let's just focus on the "money makers" if you will. In 2006, there were 14 OMFS, 5 Pedo, 1 Perio, 3 Endo, 4 Pros, and 8 Ortho. That's 35 students out of class of 75, which is about 47%. These numbers are obtained from the broceure given during my interview.
I don't have the figures for "regular" state schools, but I have heard figures ranging from 5 to 15%, which is substantially lower than that of an Ivy's. If I am mistaken, please do let me know.
Now of course that begs the question is the high specialization rate in the Ivys due to the school's reputation and focus, or the type of students that they recruit (in which case they will specialize anywhere they go)? I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle, leaning more toward the students' side.
But I don't think a name recognition should be discounted as superfluous. For example, Columbia gets away with using H/P/F.
As an aside I really like that system as I really hate to compete for that extra point or that higher ranking ("Can I get some points back for this question?" Oh dear Lord stop the pre-meds). I'd go there just because of that lol.
So back to the original question. Is it worth it to put in the extra investment (20~40K more in expense, living far away from home, slower start up time) to go to an Ivy's like Columbia (it's true, their stuff is pretty crappy) for that 30%+ increase in chance to specialize?
Personally, I think that if one isn't looking to specialize, one's money would be best served at a cheaper alternative. The advantages are real. One would be in way less debt, living closer to home, and the plan of opening that dream private practice can start earlier. One would also probably get more clinical training.
This is also what I was told at my Columbia interview. My interviewer told me, rather emphatically I might add, that if I just want to become a skilled clinician or GP, I should not come here.
Now let's assume that I do want to specialize (I don't have an earthly clue right now. Next couple of days will be spent in turmoil). Columbia touts 95+ specialization rate, but we all know that it kind of beefed that number up with GPR and AEGD, so let's just focus on the "money makers" if you will. In 2006, there were 14 OMFS, 5 Pedo, 1 Perio, 3 Endo, 4 Pros, and 8 Ortho. That's 35 students out of class of 75, which is about 47%. These numbers are obtained from the broceure given during my interview.
I don't have the figures for "regular" state schools, but I have heard figures ranging from 5 to 15%, which is substantially lower than that of an Ivy's. If I am mistaken, please do let me know.
Now of course that begs the question is the high specialization rate in the Ivys due to the school's reputation and focus, or the type of students that they recruit (in which case they will specialize anywhere they go)? I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle, leaning more toward the students' side.
But I don't think a name recognition should be discounted as superfluous. For example, Columbia gets away with using H/P/F.
As an aside I really like that system as I really hate to compete for that extra point or that higher ranking ("Can I get some points back for this question?" Oh dear Lord stop the pre-meds). I'd go there just because of that lol.
So back to the original question. Is it worth it to put in the extra investment (20~40K more in expense, living far away from home, slower start up time) to go to an Ivy's like Columbia (it's true, their stuff is pretty crappy) for that 30%+ increase in chance to specialize?