specialty quiz
- Thread starter desalmada
- Start date
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2002
- Messages
- 502
- Reaction score
- 5
- Points
- 4,571
- Location
- Seattle, WA
- Resident [Any Field]
Here... but be careful how much stock you put in this. I took it multiple times and it was different each time.
<a href="http://www.med-ed.virginia.edu/specialties/" target="_blank">http://www.med-ed.virginia.edu/specialties/</a>
<a href="http://www.med-ed.virginia.edu/specialties/" target="_blank">http://www.med-ed.virginia.edu/specialties/</a>
Hi there--
I took it and ended up with three closely-grouped top picks: 1) nuc med 2) plastics and 3) gen surg. Since I'm going into gen surg (with the distant hope of doing peds surg), I thought those results were pretty well on target.
Are you *interested* in allergy/immunology?
SMS
I took it and ended up with three closely-grouped top picks: 1) nuc med 2) plastics and 3) gen surg. Since I'm going into gen surg (with the distant hope of doing peds surg), I thought those results were pretty well on target.
Are you *interested* in allergy/immunology?
SMS
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2002
- Messages
- 43,316
- Reaction score
- 27
- Points
- 4,716
- Location
- wherever I go, there I am
- Attending Physician
My top was radiology & dermatology, with pathology as a close 2nd.
Wasn't considering any of those. The ones I am considering ranked 8 (OB/Gyn), 18 (IM), 21 (EM), and 33 (FP). Funny, my 1st choice came up last on this!
Wasn't considering any of those. The ones I am considering ranked 8 (OB/Gyn), 18 (IM), 21 (EM), and 33 (FP). Funny, my 1st choice came up last on this!
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2002
- Messages
- 954
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 4,571
- Location
- India
- Website
- members.tripod.com
I got Gastroenterology, Radiology, and Emergency Medicine.
I think this has more relevance in the Allopathic Students section, since we med students are the ones who have yet to decide about what specialty to take.
I think this has more relevance in the Allopathic Students section, since we med students are the ones who have yet to decide about what specialty to take.
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2000
- Messages
- 39,952
- Reaction score
- 18,721
- Points
- 7,171
- Website
- forums.studentdoctor.net
- Attending Physician
We had a rather lengthy thread on this very topic months ago - too bad Search is still disabled. At any rate, it was pretty accurate when I took it - all Surgical specialties at the top, mostly lifestyle ones. 😀
I've taken the test a few times over the last several months to see if the outcomes are the same. With one exception, pediatrics and ophthalmology are always at the top of my list. I don't know what to think about that, since I have NO idea what I want to do. At least I'm consistent. 😀
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2002
- Messages
- 230
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 4,551
Hi SMS, no I'm not really interested in "allergy/immunology!" I was thinking more along the lines of family medicine, which ranked outside the top twenty! 🙄
Just goes to show you that when you think you know yourself well...you don't! 😛
Just goes to show you that when you think you know yourself well...you don't! 😛
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2002
- Messages
- 21
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
I just tried that quiz. I ended up with General Surgery, Optho, and GI as my top 3. The rest of the top 20 surprised me. I am actually considering Peds and OB/GYN; those were #20 and #21
I am sure if I repeated the test later today the outcome would be different!! Oh, well!
I am sure if I repeated the test later today the outcome would be different!! Oh, well!
Here... but be careful how much stock you put in this. I took it multiple times and it was diffferent.
Interesting...I had taken this quiz during my second year of med school. Pediatrics was number one on the list. I took it with a grain of salt. I am now at the end of my third year and I thought that taking the quiz produce different results. Well...Peds came up number one again. Surgery and subspecialties are consistently at the bottom of the list. Pediatrics was my favorite rotation during thrid year. Maybe that's a sign... 😛
Interesting...I had taken this quiz during my second year of med school. Pediatrics was number one on the list. I took it with a grain of salt. I am now at the end of my third year and I thought that taking the quiz produce different results. Well...Peds came up number one again. Surgery and subspecialties are consistently at the bottom of the list. Pediatrics was my favorite rotation during thrid year. Maybe that's a sign... 😛
Here... but be careful how much stock you put in this. I took it multiple times and it was diffferent.
Interesting...I had taken this quiz during my second year of med school. Pediatrics was number one on the list. I took the results with a grain of salt. Presently, at the end of my third year, I thought that taking the quiz produce different results. Well...Peds came up number one again. Surgery and subspecialties are consistently at the bottom of the list. Pediatrics was my favorite rotation during thrid year. Maybe that's a sign... 😛
Interesting...I had taken this quiz during my second year of med school. Pediatrics was number one on the list. I took the results with a grain of salt. Presently, at the end of my third year, I thought that taking the quiz produce different results. Well...Peds came up number one again. Surgery and subspecialties are consistently at the bottom of the list. Pediatrics was my favorite rotation during thrid year. Maybe that's a sign... 😛
1. pediatrics (49)
2. ob/gyn (48)
3. tons of random subspecialties (47)
okay so do i just ooze sensitivity or what...too much sugar yuck <img border="0" alt="[Laughy]" title="" src="graemlins/laughy.gif" />
(gulp...ewe straight salt is yucky. oh wait, was i suppose to through it over my shoulder or swallow it? oh well the grain of salt is now taken 😛 )
2. ob/gyn (48)
3. tons of random subspecialties (47)
okay so do i just ooze sensitivity or what...too much sugar yuck <img border="0" alt="[Laughy]" title="" src="graemlins/laughy.gif" />
(gulp...ewe straight salt is yucky. oh wait, was i suppose to through it over my shoulder or swallow it? oh well the grain of salt is now taken 😛 )
I don't really believe the results of these tests but I took it anyway and answered it as honestly as I could and here are my top 5 and bottom 2.
1 radiology 46
2 nuclear med 44
3 pathology 40
4 preventive med 40
5 aerospace med 39
35 general surgery 28
36 orthopaedic surgery 26
Well, I'm going into radiology and if I didn't get into radiology, I was seriously considering pathology as well so looks like it was pretty close for me. I did like surgery a lot though, but I just don't have the motivation or desire to work that hard.
1 radiology 46
2 nuclear med 44
3 pathology 40
4 preventive med 40
5 aerospace med 39
35 general surgery 28
36 orthopaedic surgery 26
Well, I'm going into radiology and if I didn't get into radiology, I was seriously considering pathology as well so looks like it was pretty close for me. I did like surgery a lot though, but I just don't have the motivation or desire to work that hard.
1. Occupational med 44
1. neurology
3. pathology 43
3. Allergy/immunology
3. endocrinology
Endocrine or allergy are possibilities, but the others I haven't remotely considered!
last 3
oncology 35
peds 34
fp 34
Not thinking of family practice, but peds is a possibility!
Maybe i should take the test again in a different mood...
1. neurology
3. pathology 43
3. Allergy/immunology
3. endocrinology
Endocrine or allergy are possibilities, but the others I haven't remotely considered!
last 3
oncology 35
peds 34
fp 34
Not thinking of family practice, but peds is a possibility!
Maybe i should take the test again in a different mood...
the quiz told me I am most qualified to be a ---
DERMATOLOGIST!
funny, b/c nowhere in the whole test did I remember a question that read
"I especially enjoy the finer things and life and find the concept of taking call absolutely crazy".
haha...interestingly enough, "Colon and Rectal Surgery" was number 2 on my list. If there's any sort of similarity between this and derm, i'd like someone to enlighten me...
DERMATOLOGIST!
funny, b/c nowhere in the whole test did I remember a question that read
"I especially enjoy the finer things and life and find the concept of taking call absolutely crazy".
haha...interestingly enough, "Colon and Rectal Surgery" was number 2 on my list. If there's any sort of similarity between this and derm, i'd like someone to enlighten me...
I got...
1 ER
2 Rads ( 😎 )
3 Thoracic Surgery (wtf!?)
And if I had to pick my top 3 they'd be...
1 Rads
2 Anesthesia
3 Path
I certainly hope know one uses this quiz to actually choose their specialty...
1 ER
2 Rads ( 😎 )
3 Thoracic Surgery (wtf!?)
And if I had to pick my top 3 they'd be...
1 Rads
2 Anesthesia
3 Path
I certainly hope know one uses this quiz to actually choose their specialty...
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2002
- Messages
- 200
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 326
I took it and got:
1) allergy and immunology 48 (a little surprising)
2) infectious disease 43
3) hematology 43
I am just about to start my 3rd year, so I will still have ample opportunity to fine tune my choices, but I would say that infectious disease is definitely at the top of my list so far, with hematology running a close second. Although I don't put much stock into these types of quizzes, it was neat to see that these were among the top 3.
1) allergy and immunology 48 (a little surprising)
2) infectious disease 43
3) hematology 43
I am just about to start my 3rd year, so I will still have ample opportunity to fine tune my choices, but I would say that infectious disease is definitely at the top of my list so far, with hematology running a close second. Although I don't put much stock into these types of quizzes, it was neat to see that these were among the top 3.
M
m2006
I must have answered some questions with my eyes closed. My top 3:
1. Aerospace Med (46)
2. Occupational Med (45)
3. Nephrology (45)
I'm not even considering them. Luckily, colon & rectal surgery was at the bottom of my list-- I can't say it ever crossed my mind to enter that field. I'm leaning towards EM or Trauma Surgery which showed up in the middle of the list...interesting, though.
1. Aerospace Med (46)
2. Occupational Med (45)
3. Nephrology (45)
I'm not even considering them. Luckily, colon & rectal surgery was at the bottom of my list-- I can't say it ever crossed my mind to enter that field. I'm leaning towards EM or Trauma Surgery which showed up in the middle of the list...interesting, though.
Hey,
I got 1.Physical Medicine & Rehab
2. Neurology
3. Rheumatology
I have thought about going into PM&R since I first heard about the specialty. I took the test previously, and PM&R was in at the top of the list then also.
I got 1.Physical Medicine & Rehab
2. Neurology
3. Rheumatology
I have thought about going into PM&R since I first heard about the specialty. I took the test previously, and PM&R was in at the top of the list then also.
1) physical med & rehabilitation
2) pediatrics
3) aerospace medicine
I want to go into medical oncology, which was ranked number 5 on my results.....
Still, I'm not sure I'd put too much weight in this test.
2) pediatrics
3) aerospace medicine
I want to go into medical oncology, which was ranked number 5 on my results.....
Still, I'm not sure I'd put too much weight in this test.
Very cool- surgery and ortho were my #1 and #2 (I want to do general surgery), and pediatrics, my least favorite 3rd year rotation, was the very last!
- Joined
- May 31, 2002
- Messages
- 118
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 4,551
before i took the quiz i was thinking about radiology and plastic surg (not too seriously, just toying with different ideas). I've taken the quiz twice and radiology, urology, and plastic surg. have been in the top 4 both times. of course, i'm not sure what it means though..
I took it twice on two different days and got neurosurgery both times.
- Joined
- Apr 23, 2002
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
Just took the test:
1. PM&R ( am considering)
2. ER (
3.Rad. onc
4.Derm
7. Peds ( My #1 choice as of now)
35. Cardio
36. Gen surgery
2 out of my top ten I am actually considering.
1. PM&R ( am considering)
2. ER (
3.Rad. onc
4.Derm
7. Peds ( My #1 choice as of now)
35. Cardio
36. Gen surgery
2 out of my top ten I am actually considering.
Thoracic surgery
Urology
...yikes!
Urology
...yikes!
Hercules
Son of Zeus
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2000
- Messages
- 1,354
- Reaction score
- 397
- Points
- 5,246
- Age
- 47
- Location
- Mobile, AL
- Attending Physician
1 obstetrics/gynecology 48
2 obstetrics/gynecology 48
3 pediatrics 46
4 pediatrics 46
5 physical med & rehabilitation 45
6 physical med & rehabilitation 45
7 occupational med 45
8 occupational med 45
9 aerospace med 44
10 aerospace med 44
Why did it double up on me like that? Did that happen to anyone else? Well ob/gyn is what I want to do right now, so I guess it's comforting that it's both my #1 and #2. Aerospace med, that would be cool, but I think there are only like 3 or 4 residencies in the country aren't there?
2 obstetrics/gynecology 48
3 pediatrics 46
4 pediatrics 46
5 physical med & rehabilitation 45
6 physical med & rehabilitation 45
7 occupational med 45
8 occupational med 45
9 aerospace med 44
10 aerospace med 44
Why did it double up on me like that? Did that happen to anyone else? Well ob/gyn is what I want to do right now, so I guess it's comforting that it's both my #1 and #2. Aerospace med, that would be cool, but I think there are only like 3 or 4 residencies in the country aren't there?
- Joined
- May 1, 2001
- Messages
- 766
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 4,591
Here's the latest results:
1 thoracic surgery 49
2 obstetrics/gynecology 49
3 colon & rectal surgery 49
4 dermatology 48
5 infectious disease 48
.
.
.
31 urology 42
32 aerospace med 41
33 preventive med 41
34 cardiology 41
35 general internal med 40
36 family practice 35
I have taken it 4 times over a span of many months. Thoracic surgery is always #1 (??) although the rest fluctuate a bit. I don't really want to be a thoracic surgeon, but perhaps I should reconsider.
1 thoracic surgery 49
2 obstetrics/gynecology 49
3 colon & rectal surgery 49
4 dermatology 48
5 infectious disease 48
.
.
.
31 urology 42
32 aerospace med 41
33 preventive med 41
34 cardiology 41
35 general internal med 40
36 family practice 35
I have taken it 4 times over a span of many months. Thoracic surgery is always #1 (??) although the rest fluctuate a bit. I don't really want to be a thoracic surgeon, but perhaps I should reconsider.
My resuls are
1 radiology 46
2 radiology 46
3 urology 40
4 urology 40
5 thoracic surgery 37
6 thoracic surgery 37
7 general surgery 34
8 general surgery
I'll have to take this test again in my third year to see if my scores hold up.
1 radiology 46
2 radiology 46
3 urology 40
4 urology 40
5 thoracic surgery 37
6 thoracic surgery 37
7 general surgery 34
8 general surgery
I'll have to take this test again in my third year to see if my scores hold up.
Um, sorry, dude, but they were called The Fat Boys. The Phat Boys is, admittedly, a cooler name, but those dudes were large and in charge and not afraid to plaster it all over their 1980s rappin' selves.
hornet871
David Green
hornet871
David Green
Rank Specialty Score
1 dermatology 46
2 rheumatology 44
3 pediatrics 44
34 general surgery 33
35 family practice 30
36 emergency med 30
Derm? And I hate Rheum? WTF? Happy to see peds at no. 3, though, since that's what I'm going into! The bottom 3 also make some sense.
1 dermatology 46
2 rheumatology 44
3 pediatrics 44
34 general surgery 33
35 family practice 30
36 emergency med 30
Derm? And I hate Rheum? WTF? Happy to see peds at no. 3, though, since that's what I'm going into! The bottom 3 also make some sense.
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2002
- Messages
- 3
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
you guys should be careful when using this quiz. I think it is pretty out dated since it is based on Anita Taylor's book. While the most recent edition was pubished in 1999, her data was originally compiled in 1986.
I had a lot of anguish before I realized this.
Also realize that there are a lot of variations in personalities within larger fields, For example Surgical Oncologists or Transplant surgeons are more inclined toward complex problems and "IM type" issues than your classical general surgeon.
Interventional radiologists are completely different from mammographers and body radiologists. Even within GI, there are hepatologists who may never do procedures.
So just be careful when making checklists, since choosing a career in medicine is never as black and white as perhaps it was in the past.
cheers
munchi
I had a lot of anguish before I realized this.
Also realize that there are a lot of variations in personalities within larger fields, For example Surgical Oncologists or Transplant surgeons are more inclined toward complex problems and "IM type" issues than your classical general surgeon.
Interventional radiologists are completely different from mammographers and body radiologists. Even within GI, there are hepatologists who may never do procedures.
So just be careful when making checklists, since choosing a career in medicine is never as black and white as perhaps it was in the past.
cheers
munchi
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2002
- Messages
- 1,585
- Reaction score
- 12
- Points
- 4,601
Usually these quizzes are put together by first giving the test to a bunch of people already practicing in that field, recording their responses, and then seeing how closely your responses match theirs.
Since I strive NOT to be anything like most general surgeons I've met, the test becomes meaningless. Unfortunately, I scored pretty much like a general surgeon anyway
.
Since I strive NOT to be anything like most general surgeons I've met, the test becomes meaningless. Unfortunately, I scored pretty much like a general surgeon anyway
.I guess I chose the right field after all:
Rank Specialty Score
1 radiology 49
2 nuclear med 49
3 thoracic surgery 47
4 plastic surgery 45
5 anesthesiology 45
6 emergency med 44
7 dermatology 44
8 infectious disease 43
9 neurosurgery 42
10 pathology 42
11 urology 42
12 ophthalmology 41
13 nephrology 41
14 colon & rectal surgery 41
15 allergy & immunology 40
16 gastroenterology 40
17 pulmonology 40
18 occupational med 40
19 aerospace med 39
20 otolaryngology 39
Rank Specialty Score
1 radiology 49
2 nuclear med 49
3 thoracic surgery 47
4 plastic surgery 45
5 anesthesiology 45
6 emergency med 44
7 dermatology 44
8 infectious disease 43
9 neurosurgery 42
10 pathology 42
11 urology 42
12 ophthalmology 41
13 nephrology 41
14 colon & rectal surgery 41
15 allergy & immunology 40
16 gastroenterology 40
17 pulmonology 40
18 occupational med 40
19 aerospace med 39
20 otolaryngology 39
It's for reliability - if you have the question "Do you like people?", and you put 1 once, then 5, then 3, then 4, then it's not reliable; this is to help make sure it's not totally BS.
Well according to this test I'm supposed to be 1) park ranger 2) dog walker 3) newstand attended. I like the test that picks you ideal celebrity match.....i got britney spears....hell yeah!
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2002
- Messages
- 715
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 4,591
- Resident [Any Field]
Here's mine:
1 thoracic surgery 46
2 emergency med 45
3 general surgery 44
4 urology 44
5 occupational med 44
6 otolaryngology 44
7 orthopaedic surgery 44
8 obstetrics/gynecology 43
9 nuclear med 42
10 neurosurgery 42
11 plastic surgery 42
.
.
.
31 psychiatry 34
32 general internal med 34
33 family practice 34
Noticw the abscence of colon and rectal surgery in/near my top 10? There go my dreams of being like Santos L. Halper, Butt Doctor. Oh well....
1 thoracic surgery 46
2 emergency med 45
3 general surgery 44
4 urology 44
5 occupational med 44
6 otolaryngology 44
7 orthopaedic surgery 44
8 obstetrics/gynecology 43
9 nuclear med 42
10 neurosurgery 42
11 plastic surgery 42
.
.
.
31 psychiatry 34
32 general internal med 34
33 family practice 34
Noticw the abscence of colon and rectal surgery in/near my top 10? There go my dreams of being like Santos L. Halper, Butt Doctor. Oh well....
Similar threads
