Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Well, it's a 50/50 chance. So I say if we don't have proof of another wolf, we keep lynching WTF until she dies. At least we won't lynch a villager that way.
-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
Star Wars WW Official Game Thread
Started by Katie8
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
If anyone has a killing weapon, can we please lop off WTF's head overnight. Then we don't have to lynch her tomorrow.
Someone must have a light saber?
Someone must have a light saber?
Yes to this - hopefully there is an light saber or something like that out there! For f#cks sake she took my thumb - kill her! 😡
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Er yes. I am living in SoCal time so I thought 4 pm already past.
Hmm, good point. I guess the wolves have more to gain from that item than others.
I have to say, I'm pretty suspicious of the fact that devyn or devyn's "source" just happened to investigate and out the (hopefully!) one wolf who has a chance of evasion first thing in the game. Seems like a pretty decent gamble for wolves to take to try to make one of them look less suspicious.
Just getting that one out there too.
Just getting that one out there too.
Wait, we didn't lynch her?
So confused!?!
So confused!?!
The good news is a light saber was mentioned earlier. The bad news is WTF is the one who said she had it. 😡
This does seem like the best option. We still got quite lucky to find a wolf so soon, and we didn't kill a villager by mistake either.
Ooh I didn't even think of that...interesting! Maybe someone should investigate devyn tonight to be sure? And TW is right this is going to be one looong night!
I can see where you are coming from, but I had no idea that WTF was 50% invincible. Just going by the information that I was given. It really does suck that that was the case, but I am hoping that there is some way to kill her. 🙁
wonderful. figures.
Anyone have a "thieving" ability. Maybe we can steal one (or four) of her light sabers in case she survives another lynch.
Or maybe someone has a blaster, a primitive but effective weapon?
I am in agreement. I just don't want it to go TOO fast.
Discuss amongst yourselves! I'm guessing day 3 will be just a quick, so I want everyone to be caught up (including myself).
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Sounds like someone does have a thieving ability because Nyanko said her cloak got stolen from her last night...but who knows if that thief is a bad guy or good guy (hopefully good so they can steal WTF's lightsaber...maybe she is more able to evade when she possesses the lightsaber since General Greivous is so well trained in lightsaber combat.)
It's supposed to kill people right? If she's a wolf, you'd think she'd have used it. Maybe it's not a sure fire thing like the revolver in Clue. Or someone evaded her. Let's hope she doesn't still have it.
I'm going to go ahead and doubt that anyone who can steal can steal an item that is part of someone's character description rather than an actual item.
Do you have any concrete reason to trust your source?
Well there is a good chance I will be wolf meat tonight since I revealed WTF and she is still alive, so if someone has a protective role or item. Please protect me.
Didn't you say you had a source who had a "seeker droid" item for investigating?
Perhaps we should look at the source of devyn's info rather than devyn, I for one believe she told us all she knew.
I'm inclined to agree with you right now, but wouldn't say that I totally trust her.
Yes I trust the source completely.
I was just thinking this. I wonder if it is really an item or just part of her role?
I think thieves are usually wolves are they not? This makes me think that a wolf might be in Nyanko's room if she is not one herself.
I am inclined to trust Devyn- just a gut. I also don't think we should make her reveal her source so that they can stay protected. I am not reading as much into the fact that "source" found this particular wolf (capable of avoiding lynch), but I suppose it's not impossible.
Would your source object to being named once she/he no longer has the seeker droid? At that point they wouldn't be more of a target than anyone else and I'd be more inclined to trust them.
I didn't ask if you trusted the source. I asked if you had a concrete reason to. But I think I get it.
The thing that worries me is if there is a situation as in the LOTR game where certain good characters can talk without being in the same group. If Devyn names this person and they are not a wolf, then they might be wolf bait, and they might have an important role. Just a thought, though mine are often incorrect in these games.
I also kind of wonder about the source the more I think about it...because during the day cycle, WTF was very sneaky and came out and said she had the light saber but didn't want to use it (admittedly a smart move for a wolf, bc it makes them look good) so why would anyone bother investigating her of all people? That person is either 1) way smarter than me and suspected that she was being sneaky, and of that's the case then kudos! Or 2) a wolf trying to confuse us by revealing to us a wolf that can evade lynching
If it were me and I had been the investigator I would not have gone after someone who admitted they had a death weapon but didn't use it, but maybe I am too trusting of people. Like Devyn and her source, I trusted them 100% when she revealed her info, until Nyanko brought up the possibility of a set up lynching.
If it were me and I had been the investigator I would not have gone after someone who admitted they had a death weapon but didn't use it, but maybe I am too trusting of people. Like Devyn and her source, I trusted them 100% when she revealed her info, until Nyanko brought up the possibility of a set up lynching.
I don't see any reason to suspect Devyn. Any investigator would release the results Devyn did, and information about escaping a lynch would almost never be available to them.
And a 50% chance to escape is no sure thing. Why would any wolf want to take a 50% chance of dying. Nah doesn't sound suspicious AT ALL.
On the hand, trying to implicate Devyn sounds wolfish to me. (yeah you Nyanko).
As for why investigate WTF, makes sense to me. The veterans don't usually last long and are always suspected. A good idea to check them out early. And WTF has caused mayhem in other games. Doesn't seem particularly suspect either.
There's a wolf in my group I'm almost 100% sure, but it ain't me. If anyone investigates someone tonight with ambiguous results, I'd be real suspicious of them having the cloak that was stolen from me. Just sayin.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Besides that, I agree that devyn herself is most likely innocent. Even if the wolves were bussing someone (which DOES happen SOV, even in games where wolves don't have evasive abilities), they could be setting her up too.
I suggested investigating WTF as she was not playing like she normally does. If you play long enough you recognize people's normal patterns of play and you can sense when they are off. Lurking on the thread from the very beginning and posting a ton in other places is very unlike WTF. And then posting that she has a killer item and is not going to use it. I call BS. Just a hunch that paid off.
I am confused as to why you are pushing the issue so much Nyanko - seems a bit off. I was inclined to believe that there was a wolf in your group based on the fact you had an item in your possession that was stolen (and in the past wolves have been able to steal), but not sure why you are all up on me over some investigation results that revealed a wolf. From what I was told the results only came back with the name of the character - which makes sense to me as you never get the full details of their role.
It's true that an investigative item usually only gives role + allegiance, not information about powers. Obviously we can't count on this always being true, but that part of devyn's explanation rings true to me.
And SOV is right about WW veterans, from everything I've seen and what cuit shared with me before I joined SDN. It's sort of along the same lines as Alaskandream having a reputation for pretty accurate feelings in wolf-hunting since an earlier game (vet school, maybe?) and him being the first to die in Clue. If you have a reputation, things happen to you.
I'm really not "pushing" it. I wanted to get it out there in case I'm killed at night and wanted to offer up a possibility.
But the fact that the investigation wouldn't reveal the 50% evasion rate doesn't mean anything to me one way or the other - if it were a fake investigation (which may be a stupid theory but I don't hear anyone else doing anything worthwhile) the wolves would already know this fact most likely so that entire point is moot and doesn't prove anything.
Ugh, my internet is being all slow and annoying. 😡
So you think it's possible the seeker droid doesn't exist and devyn's source is a wolf feeding her fake investigations? Or you think devyn made it up?
Your video doesn't want to play embedded. 🙁
Omg that was too funny. Here I am, writing the word moo on my Pwpt.
It's plausible especially since it was the first night. We all have no idea what all the items are. So we could in theory make up whatever we wanted to for a bit until the real ones surface.
But it's a moot point. Devyn suggested seering WTF and are right 🙂highfive🙂 so it's super unlikely that a wolfy source just happened to be planning to reveal WTF's identity as well. My speculation is that the person with the investigate item asked devyn if she had ideas for who to seer. And they got lucky and found us a wolf.
WOW!!!
I missed a lot while I was gone this morning getting some stuffs done.
Sucks that we lost sheepie and that we could not lynch WTF. If anyone does have an item that might be able to kill/silence WTF use it that way we don't have to waste time trying to lynch her repeatedly.
I don't have much else to add in otherwise. I am inclined to trust devyn at this point since she would not know about the 50% chance of survival. I also think it is risky for a wolf to throw another wolf under the bus this early in the game just to get clearance even if that wolf did have a 50% chance of surviving. It just doesn't seem to make sense to take that chance on the first lynching. It would be better to clear your name that way later on but it doesn't make sense to do so in the beginning. That is just my opinion.
I will check in on and off today and mention if I notice anything else that seems weird..
I missed a lot while I was gone this morning getting some stuffs done.
Sucks that we lost sheepie and that we could not lynch WTF. If anyone does have an item that might be able to kill/silence WTF use it that way we don't have to waste time trying to lynch her repeatedly.
I don't have much else to add in otherwise. I am inclined to trust devyn at this point since she would not know about the 50% chance of survival. I also think it is risky for a wolf to throw another wolf under the bus this early in the game just to get clearance even if that wolf did have a 50% chance of surviving. It just doesn't seem to make sense to take that chance on the first lynching. It would be better to clear your name that way later on but it doesn't make sense to do so in the beginning. That is just my opinion.
I will check in on and off today and mention if I notice anything else that seems weird..
This not being able to edit my typos thing is killer...
Just catching up on the thread. Can't believe that sneaky wolf! I guess we need to try and lynch her again tomorrow (which seems like it could be a long process if she keeps evading).
So it sounds like we know of 3 items so far.
Droid--may or may not be real, if we trust Devyn's source. I trust Devyn for coming out with this info (I think it's a bit early for a wolf to be suggesting another wolf to lynch, even if it appears she has a 50% chance of evasion), though I'm not sure if I trust the source. It's possible the source made up the item to cover up an investigatory role. Either way, we know the identity of a wolf, so that's good news.
Obi-Wan's Cloak--Nyanko did send us a PM telling our group that she had this item. Which may point to a wolf in our group. But it's not me.
Lightsaber--I'm sure this has to be an item because it wouldn't be Star Wars without it, though I'm not sure if we can trust that WTF didn't really know what it would do. It was super smart of her not to use it, because it makes her look innocent. Does anyone want to fess up to having it now?
Does anyone know of any other items I've missed?
So it sounds like we know of 3 items so far.
Droid--may or may not be real, if we trust Devyn's source. I trust Devyn for coming out with this info (I think it's a bit early for a wolf to be suggesting another wolf to lynch, even if it appears she has a 50% chance of evasion), though I'm not sure if I trust the source. It's possible the source made up the item to cover up an investigatory role. Either way, we know the identity of a wolf, so that's good news.
Obi-Wan's Cloak--Nyanko did send us a PM telling our group that she had this item. Which may point to a wolf in our group. But it's not me.
Lightsaber--I'm sure this has to be an item because it wouldn't be Star Wars without it, though I'm not sure if we can trust that WTF didn't really know what it would do. It was super smart of her not to use it, because it makes her look innocent. Does anyone want to fess up to having it now?
Does anyone know of any other items I've missed?
At this point, I tentatively trust that devyn and her source are legit. Like SOV and DVMDream said, it's not sound strategy for the wolves to reveal one of themselves for villager cred this early. I don't think nyanko's suggestion is likely, but I wanted to clarify it.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I am going to disappear for awhile to study for my 2 finals (one tomorrow & one thursday). I will pop back in later. Ugh - I hate finals. 🙁
Come on, maybe I can be re-programmed good, huh? Give a bot a shot.
I think we'd rather force-crush your chest Obi-wan style.
Wow, leave for a few hours and miss a ton.
I think someone should protect devyn tonight. I also don't think she should reveal her source. If it is someone she trusts out right from the start it means that the person probably has a role or can communicate with her (I think someone mentioned something like in LOTR game). So I don't think it is a good idea if the wolves have that info.
I think someone should protect devyn tonight. I also don't think she should reveal her source. If it is someone she trusts out right from the start it means that the person probably has a role or can communicate with her (I think someone mentioned something like in LOTR game). So I don't think it is a good idea if the wolves have that info.
