Step 3 versus FM Board Exam

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

wannabmed

Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2004
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
Please pardon my ignorance, but are these 2 exams different?

I know that most people take Step 3 during their intern year, but when do residents take the FM Board exam? Is it required to get a license or does it just 'look better' to have passed it?
 
Please pardon my ignorance, but are these 2 exams different?

Yes.

I know that most people take Step 3 during their intern year, but when do residents take the FM Board exam?

At the end of residency.

Is it required to get a license or does it just 'look better' to have passed it?

It is not required to get a license. Some places, however, are only looking to hire board certified (although many will also say "board eligible") FM physicians.
 
...It is not required to get a license. Some places, however, are only looking to hire board certified (although many will also say "board eligible") FM physicians.
As stated....

USMLE, i.e. "step exams" are US Medical Licensing Examination. These are required for licensure to practice medicine.

Board certification differs by specialty. However, almost all require completion of residency to take examination (I heard radiology can take part of exam during last year of residency?). Board cert is not required for license.

However, board cert is far less "optional" then it may have been 20 years ago. Many hospitals and medical facilities will not hire or give privileges to practice without board certification (or board eligible). If granted privileges to practice under "board eligible", most require you complete board certification within a set period of time, i.e. 2-3yrs. Further, there may be some payment differences as well. Insurance companies are restricting to board certified as well and if they pay someone that is not board certified, they may pay less.
 
There's a huge difference in content-wise between the 2 tests also. It's not just a matter of cosmetics.

For example, Step 3 is designed to see if you are ready to work independently which means do you know enough medicine to be safe, can you spot critical scenarios, do you understand what is going on with this patient. It's written by NBME and after you've survived 3rd year medical school and your 1st 2 Steps, you'll start to realize that Step 3 has the same question format as all your other tests. By my count, most of the questions are asked in only 5 ways; which makes it easy to study for. Most of the questions are case-based scenarios, which can be helpful if you're in need to visualize a patient you may have seen.

FM boards is a different beast altogether. It's asking whether or not you are capable of practicing medicine at the level of a residency trained physician. Let it be known that the test that you take as a new grad is the same as the test that old fogies practicing for last 100 years will take. More than that, the question formats are different. Some care case based, some are not. Some are pure facts/trivia... either you know it or you don't, and there's no clinical background to clue you in. It's written by the ABFM which makes their questions random and unpredictable. It's more like your in-training exam format. For example, they'll show you a picture of the rash and ask you the treatment, no history, no description of the physical exam, no buzzwords (which the USMLE would have done). Or the ABFM boards will ask you a question and it will list 5 different beta-blockers or 5 different SSRI's, and you need to know the differences/nuances (USMLE doesn't do this).
 
bump

Great post "low" but a more specific question. I took step 3 and like all the steps (to me) they seemed tricky. I could spend 1-2 min just trying to figure out what they were asking. I do have to say as the step number increased the questions were more straight forward. It was only step 3 when I left on my second day I really felt "o yea I am sure I passed" (maybe bc it ended with the straight forward computer simulations) So, I am waiting to start my first year in July and picked up Swanson's Family Medicine Review (mostly questions) and they seem sooo straight forward. Please tell me our FM boards are like this? Preferably someone who took them already. Thanks,

disco
 
Top