honestpredent said:
Okay, you sound like someone who isn't in touch with the reality of being a dentist. Here are some harsh realities of becoming a dentist. With all of the positives (great income, great lifestyle, low malpractice insurance, never being sued, never dealing with paperwork) comes the bad
1. You will work in a strip mall- accept it. Nearly every dentist works in a strip mall. You won't be able to afford working in a nice office complex when you first start your practice. It will be too expensive and you will have a tough time attracting patients.
2. You are not a physician and will never be thought of or treated like on by the public. Despite doing the same basic sciences and learning pretty much everything a phyician learns, we still don't receive anywhere near the same level of respect. Even if you net 500K a year and live in a huge house and drive a Porsche, you still won't get the same respect as a physician.
3. People view going to the dentist as a chore. Seeing a dentist is like getting your oil changed. It's a nuisance that people hate dealing with. They don't want to talk to you. They want you to do your business and let them leave. There is very little patient interaction. You will not have a lengthy 20 minute consultation with your patients and receive great adulation
4. As a general dentist, your work will come down to three procedures, crowns, bridges and extractions. That will be your bread and butter. Thus you better like it. Your work can be mundane
The happiest and most successful dentists are the ones who can accept that they aren't physicians. They just want to do their job; make tons of money and have a great lifestyle. The miserable dentists are the ones who thought they would be physicians who subspecialize in the mouth.
I'm all about the strip mall. Lower rent and high production = $$$
honestpredent,
You've brought up some interesting points and a few generalizations.
1. You will have more of choice then you think. If you wish to pursue gp when you graduate, typically you'll associate and later buy into a practice. Although the choices aren't limitless, it's your choice what type of practice with which you decide to associate. Few grads choose to start up a practice from scratch.
2. Comparing a dentist to a physician in terms of respect - that question was never asked or discussed before you brought it up which leads me to think that it's weighing heavily on your mind. The only thing I can say is that this question of respect is really a moot point that only concerns predents, premeds, and the occasional but rare arrogant med student. Dentistry and Medicine are hard jobs, and at the end of the day no practitioner really considers or cares what their level of respect is in the community.
3. I agree, most pts don't like going to the dentist (nor the doctor or lawyer etc if that matters to you). However, whether you interact with your pt is up to you. My experience has been (including personal experience as a student clinician) talking with your pt helps comfort them. Most like talking back too. I'm sure they would rather be elsewhere, but it is not as cold an environment you may think or may have shadowed.
4. I agree that your work is often repetitive. Show me a job anywhere in the health care field that isn't. Nevertheless, as a gp you do a lot more than fixed prosth and extractions. Pedo, endo, operative, removable, and perio off the top of my head. Certainly crowns/bridges are the big money makers but they aren't (or shouldn't be unless you're a shady dentist) the only procedures you will do by a long shot.
Lastly, the happiest dentists are those that love their job and lifestyle period. There's no qualification or distinction of how you compare to a physician in the real world. You have your responsibilities as a dentist to your patient (cosmetic & disease, surgical & medical, etc), which you will learn when you start going through dental school. That is what you'll care about. To accept or not to accept the fact that you're not a physician is what makes predents happy or unhappy, not dentists. Dentists and dental students don't even consider the question.