TBR Millikan oil experiment

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

dahmsom

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2014
Messages
132
Reaction score
18
Points
4,651
  1. Pre-Medical
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
ImageUploadedBySDN Mobile1438652570.837485.jpg
so I'm still not clear about question 1 and 2 . Since the charge is negative and normally the force on a positive charge has a force mg down and an electric field charge up f = qe . Since this is an electron everything is switched .. Meaning electric field charge is down and force of gravity is up?? I'm not sure where they got 3mg from... And I know that 4pir^3 is from density time volume.


Also for number 2 why does both gravity and electric field point downward ??


Please help me out I don't understand this concept . Any response be appreciated
 
For question 1:
First let's start with the direction of the field. It is important to know that field lines point the way a (+) charge would migrate (see the top of page 121 for the details). In order to suspend a negatively charged oil drop, you need to have the electric force on the electron-rich oil drop pointing up to offset the force of gravity pointing down. So the electric force on the negative charge is up, which would mean that that same force would point downward if it were a (+) charge. Because field lines point the way the force would point on a (+) charge, the field lines must be pointing downward. This eliminates choices C and D.

As for the magnitude, you know that qE = mg, which tells us that E = mg/q. The mg term must be in the numerator, so choice A is the only choice still standing. Just to be complete, rho is charge density in this question, so charge density x volume gives charge. The total charge is 4/3πr^3 x (rho), so the answer is mg/[4/3πr^3(rho)] = 3mg/4πr^3(rho).
 
Last edited:
For question 2:
The force of gravity will always point downward. As for the electric force, it is pointing upward on the electron-rich oil drop in Figure 1, so if the field is reversed then that force will point downward. If that were the case, then both forces acting on the oil drop would be pointing downward, resulting in a net force downward. This would accelerate the oil drop downward.
 
@BerkReviewTeach , THANKS so much!! this made so much sense. I had to review electric field line to understand what you were saying but now it make sense 😀. cant believe i forgot this ><. thank you so much!!!!
 
Top Bottom