theoretically speaking...

Started by OphthoBean
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

OphthoBean

Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Suppose you were an ophthalmologist and you discovered another ophthalmologist was performing cataract surgery and was consistently getting post-op refractions between -2.00D and -6.00D...would you say something to this doc about it? What if you then discovered it was because they were getting messed up IOL calculations due to using a broken A-scan...which they know is broken, and which has been brought to that person's attention, and which they don't care to replace or repair because they can't be bothered to spend the $$...how would you approach something like this? Theoretically speaking of course.

To me it seems like substandard care, and if I was a patient of a surgeon like that I would be furious. I am not sure, however, if post-op myopia is an actual injury since medicine is an inexact science. This whole scenario seems careless and wrong to me, but maybe I am overreacting?

I personally think someone like that, despite being board certified, fellowship trained, yadda yadda, should NOT be doing surgery and does not give a flying fig about patients.

If MY A scan began to give me crap results, I would immediately reschedule my surgeries, stop using it and replace it asap. I don't know WTH is wrong with some people!
 
Yes, if that's true, something should be done. If you know him well, maybe you could say something in a diplomatic manner. Maybe you could talk to someone else at his practice? write him a letter? maybe an anonymous letter?
Something....
 
We know there are bad physicians out there, but it's always frustrating to hear about them. Hopefully this guy is just in denial about what he's doing and will be responsible once the problem is brought to his attention. Regardless though, I think beating this guy with a baseball bat is another viable option.
 
Andrew_Doan said:
This is why I love the internet. In the past, it would have been difficult to discuss these issues openly. With an anonymous forum like this, we're able to discuss ethics issues so that everyone can learn.
As someone who's considering corrective surgery myself, if I discovered that the procedure failed because the ophtho knowingly operated using broken equipment, my next stop might well be an attorney's office.