thermo and work

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

jmart

Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2006
Messages
211
Reaction score
0
I just took a kaplan thermo quiz and did pretty dismal. While trying to review and understand the problems, some of them I just don't quite get. I'm having problems understanding when work is done whether it is positive or negative. Also whether energy is entering of leaving.

Can someone please explain what I seem to be missing?

Thanks
 
That depends on what definition of "work" you are using. The most fundamental equation in thermodynamics is deltaU = q + w, where q is heat and w is work. However, some textbooks say q - w, where w is work done BY the gas (or system). You then have to switch all the sign conventions you use. So here's what I'll say...

When work is done ON a system, the energy of the system increases. When work is done BY the system, the energy of the system decreases. When heat flows into a system, its energy increases. When heat flows out, its energy decreases. How you define POSITIVE and NEGATIVE depends on how you're looking at the problem (i.e. from the system's point of view? work done by or on the system?). One obvious thing to keep it in mind is that positive and negative are the opposites of one another. For example, POSITIVE work done BY the system is the same thing as NEGATIVE work done ON the system. (double negative cancels out) Confused? I was too, but once you get this critical concept, thermodynamics on the MCAT is incredibly easy.
 
Top