D
deleted986658
Last edited by a moderator:
I think you need to try your psych clerkship before you declare that clinical psychiatry is garbage. You might still have the same stance afterward, but after going through the trouble of applying and getting into med school, completing your first 2 years and completing step 1, it seems silly to cut bait without actually doing your psych clerkship. If possible, you should also look into electives for some of the other fields that don't have direct patient contact (rads, path).Hello strangers. Long story short, I’m a rising ms3 and hate medical school and can’t see myself being a doctor. I’m debating whether dropping out or finish the MD and find a job. Are there careers for MDs without a residency?
Just a little background, I’m interested in biological/molecular psych, psychopharm, etc... i pretty much came to med school only interested in psych, really don’t have any interest in learning about anything else of medicine. However I see the current state of psych as a real crisis. It’s just a merry go round of crappy drugs that just chemically lobotomize people, and even if they do “work” For a short while you just eventually develop tolerance to it, leading to treatment resistance, horrid withdrawals, and iatrogenic problems. I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
I thought I wanted to be a psychiatrist, but turns out I don’t like interacting with people and all the treatments are garbage. I also have a lot of social anxiety issues myself, and I dread OSCEs, patient interviews, etc...
I’ve always thought it’d be really cool to try and research discover new psychiatric therapeutics.Hence, I guess I could drop out to pursue a PhD? Either that or stick it out and finish the MD then somehow get into the research side of things from there?
thanks
Suggest taking an LOA and fix what's broken.Hello strangers. Long story short, I’m a rising ms3 and hate medical school and can’t see myself being a doctor. I’m debating whether dropping out or finish the MD and find a job. Are there careers for MDs without a residency?
Just a little background, I’m interested in biological/molecular psych, psychopharm, etc... i pretty much came to med school only interested in psych, really don’t have any interest in learning about anything else of medicine. However I see the current state of psych as a real crisis. It’s just a merry go round of crappy drugs that just chemically lobotomize people, and even if they do “work” For a short while you just eventually develop tolerance to it, leading to treatment resistance, horrid withdrawals, and iatrogenic problems. I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
I thought I wanted to be a psychiatrist, but turns out I don’t like interacting with people and all the treatments are garbage. I also have a lot of social anxiety issues myself, and I dread OSCEs, patient interviews, etc...
I’ve always thought it’d be really cool to try and research discover new psychiatric therapeutics.Hence, I guess I could drop out to pursue a PhD? Either that or stick it out and finish the MD then somehow get into the research side of things from there?
thanks
I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
Hello strangers. Long story short, I’m a rising ms3 and hate medical school and can’t see myself being a doctor. I’m debating whether dropping out or finish the MD and find a job. Are there careers for MDs without a residency?
Just a little background, I’m interested in biological/molecular psych, psychopharm, etc... i pretty much came to med school only interested in psych, really don’t have any interest in learning about anything else of medicine. However I see the current state of psych as a real crisis. It’s just a merry go round of crappy drugs that just chemically lobotomize people, and even if they do “work” For a short while you just eventually develop tolerance to it, leading to treatment resistance, horrid withdrawals, and iatrogenic problems. I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
I thought I wanted to be a psychiatrist, but turns out I don’t like interacting with people and all the treatments are garbage. I also have a lot of social anxiety issues myself, and I dread OSCEs, patient interviews, etc...
I’ve always thought it’d be really cool to try and research discover new psychiatric therapeutics.Hence, I guess I could drop out to pursue a PhD? Either that or stick it out and finish the MD then somehow get into the research side of things from there?
thanks
I worked as a psych tech at a psych hospital during my gap year, and I’ve been a patient of psych since I was 15. I think I know a little something about it thank you very much. And I don’t mean to say the entire field is bull****. Everyone makes a great point that there’s value in just being there for people, providing support and hope. I’m saying a lot of the current pharmacological options are just crap and there needs to be some serious innovation.
I think your condescending tone is very unprecedented. You have no idea my background or what I’ve gone through. Just because I didn’t suffer through the same steps you did doesn’t mean I don’t know as much as you. Get off your high horse and be respectful of others experience.
Hello strangers. Long story short, I’m a rising ms3 and hate medical school and can’t see myself being a doctor. I’m debating whether dropping out or finish the MD and find a job. Are there careers for MDs without a residency?
Just a little background, I’m interested in biological/molecular psych, psychopharm, etc... i pretty much came to med school only interested in psych, really don’t have any interest in learning about anything else of medicine. However I see the current state of psych as a real crisis. It’s just a merry go round of crappy drugs that just chemically lobotomize people, and even if they do “work” For a short while you just eventually develop tolerance to it, leading to treatment resistance, horrid withdrawals, and iatrogenic problems. I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
I thought I wanted to be a psychiatrist, but turns out I don’t like interacting with people and all the treatments are garbage. I also have a lot of social anxiety issues myself, and I dread OSCEs, patient interviews, etc...
I’ve always thought it’d be really cool to try and research discover new psychiatric therapeutics.Hence, I guess I could drop out to pursue a PhD? Either that or stick it out and finish the MD then somehow get into the research side of things from there?
thanks
Just to reiterate what I've said before, I think trying to jump straight from med school to pharma is a terrible idea. I have no doubt you could find some tiny start-up that would be willing to hire you, but then you're totally at the mercy of whether their one asset pans out or not, and nobody will be around to teach you what you're doing. Starting at a bigger, more established company is much safer because they have experience training physicians who want to enter industry and they're not dependent on any one asset working out--you'll need residency training, but again it's much safer.Finishing your degree will give you opportunities in the pharma industry that you would not have without the MD. And they will hire you without a residency.
I'm trying to say this as respectfully as I can--while you have experience that a random person who hasn't been a psych patient or tech might have, that's not the same as being a psychiatrist. Based on what you've said thus far, I get the sense that you don't know what you don't know, and that's a very dangerous place to be giving people medical advice.Thank you for all the very insightful responses. I did work as a psych tech during my gap year and I actually did enjoy it, and found it pretty fulfilling. Granted it was insanely stressful and challenging given my anxiety issues. It was sort of a foreshadow to come- it revealed my weaknesses interacting with people.
with regards to the PhD, I did bench research in college and honestly hated that too LOL, but it wasn’t in a field I was particularly interested in whatsoever. So idk.
I’m on a leave of absence until April, so I have a little while to figure things out.
People always seem to respect my knowledge and even come to me for advice regarding their medications and I must say it does feel very fulfilling being of use to them... and idk I could probably see myself in a low key psych practice out of my home managing their meds. The process to get to that point is just horrible and particularly so if you’re not interested in general medicine!
What is the overall mortality rate for cancer patients undergoing chemo or radiation? Are oncology treatments "garbage"?
I find it interesting that people like to love to talk about the ineffectiveness of psychiatric meds but don't realize most patients on other common "non-psych" meds (i.e., statins) will not receive any benefit. The number needed to treat for a lot of "medical" drugs is quite higher than many "psychiatric" drugs. Even a single lowly SSRI without talk therapy will have a 2/3 response rate against depression.
Psych meds are pretty damn effective. Antipsychotics, ECT, mood stabilizers. Lithium is literally just a salt that will change a patient from running in the street tazed by police, naked and manic, to normal and productive. How can you have worked as a psych tech without seeing some of the amazing turnaround in manic and psychotic patients?
I worked as a psych tech at a psych hospital during my gap year, and I’ve been a patient of psych since I was 15. I think I know a little something about it thank you very much. And I don’t mean to say the entire field is bull****. Everyone makes a great point that there’s value in just being there for people, providing support and hope. I’m saying a lot of the current pharmacological options are just crap and there needs to be some serious innovation.
Just wanted to give you the perspective of a new psych PGY1...the need for innovation and some of the innovative research happening in the field is why I was drawn to psych. The potential to be a part of a field that is still developing where everything isn’t already a cut and dry perfect algorithm was part of what excited me. Look at the history of improvements in medicine. Radical change starts with “this is just crap”, but it dies with “so I’ll just quit”.I’m saying a lot of the current pharmacological options are just crap and there needs to be some serious innovation.
So sorry that you feel that way, but I do want to encourage you to think outside the box when it comes to practicing medicine. Yes the conventional approach to psych (and honestly all of medicine) is through meds and often not actually improving any chronic conditions. Before going into med school I new this and I HATED this. But that is precicsly why I went into this field. There is a huge rise in preventative and holistic medicine and the amazing thing with being a physician is that you really have a lot of freedom within your practice in terms of how you treat patients, what types of patients you see, etc. So you may need to do a bit of additional education on things like mindfulness (if you are looking into psych) or other more sustainable healthcare practices, but you can also utilize them and help change the industry of medicine. You can help change medical school curriculums, you can help educate the community, you can help contribute to research, etc. Try to find physicians that aren't doing the conventional thing and shadow them. Yes, it may require sitting through a lot of things you don't like during med school/residency (I was well aware of this before entering but I also made sure to focus on the things I could do and the impacts I could have), but in the end it will be even more fulfilling because you will be making a HUGE difference, and one that wouldn't happen without the few pioneers that are turning in this direction now. Feel free to DM me if you want more advice but don't let go so soon! Even if you don't want to practice you can still teach or go towards public health, etc, and really help change things instead of running away from the field because its such a mess.Hello strangers. Long story short, I’m a rising ms3 and hate medical school and can’t see myself being a doctor. I’m debating whether dropping out or finish the MD and find a job. Are there careers for MDs without a residency?
Just a little background, I’m interested in biological/molecular psych, psychopharm, etc... i pretty much came to med school only interested in psych, really don’t have any interest in learning about anything else of medicine. However I see the current state of psych as a real crisis. It’s just a merry go round of crappy drugs that just chemically lobotomize people, and even if they do “work” For a short while you just eventually develop tolerance to it, leading to treatment resistance, horrid withdrawals, and iatrogenic problems. I firmly support Whitaker and his stance that psych meds are turning short term issues into long term chronic intractable problems.
I thought I wanted to be a psychiatrist, but turns out I don’t like interacting with people and all the treatments are garbage. I also have a lot of social anxiety issues myself, and I dread OSCEs, patient interviews, etc...
I’ve always thought it’d be really cool to try and research discover new psychiatric therapeutics.Hence, I guess I could drop out to pursue a PhD? Either that or stick it out and finish the MD then somehow get into the research side of things from there?
thanks
Just a rising OMS-I here so I don't have any personal wisdom to give you, but what from what I understood from your post, it's shockingly similar to one of the ER docs I got to know the past year. He did a lot of psych research in undergrad, really only went to medical school because he wanted to become a psychiatrist. After he finished his third year, he had no desire to go into residency and just wanted to finish out his last year for the MD to hopefully find some kind of job. He figured an MD would be better than without one.
One of his closer friends really just pushed him to try out other specialties even though he really only wanted to do psych. Ended up trying out emergency medicine and he liked it. Granted, he wasn't thrilled about it like he was with psych before he started med school, but it gave him what he wanted in life. It was a nice job, he ended up becoming a travel doc, and he lives up pretty much every day he's off from work. He seems to believe that should he have not gone into EM residency and graduated, his life would have been way worse. YMMV.
I worked as a psych tech at a psych hospital during my gap year, and I’ve been a patient of psych since I was 15. I think I know a little something about it thank you very much
And that makes complete sense. You have to 'know thyself' and all that jazz.And this conversation is so irrelevant because it’s not even the debate about psych meds that’s making me question whether or not I want to continue (sorry again, I guess I was unclear in the original post). I guess it’s more having to go through all of medicine first before becoming a psychiatrist is bumming me out, because it just doesn’t interest me! And that coupled with all the social anxiety and other psychiatric issues I Deal with make me question my capacity to even be a psychiatrist anyway. I actually loved working as a psych tech, I felt at home, it was just so challenging for me and anxiety provoking. Like idk what to say to people when they’re coming at me with all their issues, or if they’re in a frenzy throwing **** and punching walls like idk how to talk to people. I can be in the corner prescribing their Thorazine and adjusting their antipsychotic regimen but I just don’t know how to talk to people and it makes me very uncomfortable. Looks like this turned into a therapy session for me LOL.
Considering you're on a LOA already I'll leave the advice to those more educated. But remember, there is no shame in choosing your health. You matter.yes I’m on a LOA right now. I don’t really mind sharing any of this since it’s all anonymous but ive had severe anxiety issues since my early teens. Got dependent on benzos, developed other addictions, went to rehab and inpatient. Sober in recovery ever since. Have been on multiple antidepressants anxiolytics over the years but none of them work anymore. So yes I’m experiencing a pretty deep depression and anxiety and all that. I’ve already been on the medication merry go round so I don’t know what other options are left. My current plan is to get off all the garbage I’m on and try Nardil and hope that can renew my spark and get me back on track. Either that or just accept this path isn’t for me and find some menial low stress job I can hack. Idk.