Transferring Med Schools w/out "good" reason

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

SBlanc

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2005
Messages
40
Reaction score
1
Hey guys, looking for some input since I don't know much about transfers... I am currently a student at Baylor College of Medicine, and I have a friend who just finished his first year at a state med school also in TX. He has his mind set on trying to transfer to Baylor into the 3rd year class for fall of 2007. However, he lacks any truly compelling reason for the transfer. His whole impetus for transferring, from what I can tell, is basically that he wishes he were at a "better" (more highly ranked, for what that's worth) school. He is basically just a really driven person who came from a prestigous undergrad but whose options were limited by his numbers, and who feels an obligation to at least try one last time to get in to a "better" school.

The only successful transfers I have ever heard of personally, at Baylor or anywhere else, have been fiancees of current students who wanted to transfer to be closer to their loved ones, so I'm having difficulty advising him. Personally I wish he would find happiness knowing that many people would kill to be in his spot and that, in the long run, the difference between graduating from his school and from BCM is not very giant. It's important to note that he did apply to almost all the TX schools the first go around and did not even receive interviews at any schools other than the one he currently attends.

Currently he is in the process of writing a letter to request a transfer application. I think his plan is just to write glowing things about BCM/ the texas med center and talk about how much he could benefit from the "enthusiastic environment" at Baylor (basically the same stuff you put in your secondaries the first time around).

I'd appreciate any comments or suggestions. I'd especially be interested in anecdotes of other known previous transfer applicants, successful and unsuccessful. Thanks!
 
Get engaged to a Houstonite?
 
neutropenic said:
Get engaged to a Houstonite?

Yeah man. Tell him to find a desperate mexican girl who wants US citizenship and who happens to live in Houston. All he needs to do is marry her, and BAM. Win-win.

Win, win.
 
Well, it seems to me that this is one of those opportunities where you can show that you are a true friend. If your friendship truly runs deep (go ahead and insert a nasty joke here), then I think that you're going to have to marry him.
 
A "better" school won't necessarily make your friend into a "better" doctor
 
SBlanc said:
Hey guys, looking for some input since I don't know much about transfers... I am currently a student at Baylor College of Medicine, and I have a friend who just finished his first year at a state med school also in TX. He has his mind set on trying to transfer to Baylor into the 3rd year class for fall of 2007. However, he lacks any truly compelling reason for the transfer. His whole impetus for transferring, from what I can tell, is basically that he wishes he were at a "better" (more highly ranked, for what that's worth) school. He is basically just a really driven person who came from a prestigous undergrad but whose options were limited by his numbers, and who feels an obligation to at least try one last time to get in to a "better" school.

The only successful transfers I have ever heard of personally, at Baylor or anywhere else, have been fiancees of current students who wanted to transfer to be closer to their loved ones, so I'm having difficulty advising him. Personally I wish he would find happiness knowing that many people would kill to be in his spot and that, in the long run, the difference between graduating from his school and from BCM is not very giant. It's important to note that he did apply to almost all the TX schools the first go around and did not even receive interviews at any schools other than the one he currently attends.

Currently he is in the process of writing a letter to request a transfer application. I think his plan is just to write glowing things about BCM/ the texas med center and talk about how much he could benefit from the "enthusiastic environment" at Baylor (basically the same stuff you put in your secondaries the first time around).

I'd appreciate any comments or suggestions. I'd especially be interested in anecdotes of other known previous transfer applicants, successful and unsuccessful. Thanks!

Please let us know if such a kiss *## letter works for him. This will definitely be more amazing than knowing someone who enters MD school with <3.0 GPA AND <21 MCAT without having other advantages.
 
Or maybe you two should get engaged....am I right?
 
silas2642 said:
Well, it seems to me that this is one of those opportunities where you can show that you are a true friend. If your friendship truly runs deep (go ahead and insert a nasty joke here), then I think that you're going to have to marry him.


Hehe 🙂
 
silas2642 said:
Well, it seems to me that this is one of those opportunities where you can show that you are a true friend. If your friendship truly runs deep (go ahead and insert a nasty joke here), then I think that you're going to have to marry him.

yep marriage really seems key here. Not sure what baylor's standards are but for Stanford ..."Must be married to, or be the domestic partner of, a Stanford medical student or graduate student, a Stanford housestaff officer, or a Stanford faculty member, in the School of Medicine"...well i guess you could marry him off to your professor

more seriously though, your friend is probably going to need recommendation letters from his professors, be sure to warn him not to tick off his professors when he explains what the letters are for.
 
Top