Trolling in the FM forums

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

MedicineDoc

Full Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2008
Messages
545
Reaction score
9
I was reading back over the closed thread and I think Dr Awesome posted under 3 separate accounts one claiming to be "from a derm background" username med something, one username dermpath that claimed no longer to be in derm, and awesome doc who showed u up after dermpath was warned about trolling and initially claimed to be a neurosurgery resident and then forgot this earlier claim and stated she switched from derm to radiation oncology with claiming to be a radiation oncology resident.
 
Pretty sure she's not real.

Thing is, I wasn't done having MOHS teach me about the foundations of Logic and Reasoning 101, when he himself uses fallacies in his own arguments.
 
"Foundational role? Yes. Single-most-important-thing-under-the-God-given-sun-above? Is the foundation truly more important than anything and everything that rests upon it? That is where this line of reasoning falls apart, the ipso facto assignment of importance to the nebulous prime imperative that is the current primary care initiative."

lol I guess this games ok to play but don't mess with that darn straw man. "Ipso facto assignment of importance to the nebulous prime imperative" again, this is a little cringe worthy, I get it man, you really enjoy impressing everyone with your vocabulary, because typically even really smart people actually talk like this (just a hint of sarcasm). Primary Care is the foundation for medicine, we can argue all day about how when a MOHS procedure is done that saves a life. However, it is the primary care physician that screens and consults the specialist, and not just for one specialty but for all, and they also don't just manage one organ system they manage many. So to say "we all contribute" is a bit of a misnomer, and I feel that people attach importance to their job and justify it based on the pay they receive. Who's really going to say, "I make half a million a year, I don't work hard for it and don't deserve it."? therefore, you get every single specialist justifying what they earn and how hard their job is, when in reality some of the lowest paying jobs in medicine are perhaps the most demanding, and no this not an absolute just a generalization.
 
Agreed brother, I actually think MOHS is a very intelligent person I just severely disagree with his stance on primary care and have had a fun time arguing with him.
 
Public callouts, like this thread, are prohibited on SDN by the Terms of Service. If you have questions about whether or not someone may be sockpuppeting or using duplicate accounts, please either PM a moderator or report one of the posts (using the Report Post function).

Closing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top