SDN members see fewer ads and full resolution images. Join our non-profit community!

UCD or Trinity

Discussion in 'UK & Ireland' started by applepark, Apr 23, 2007.

  1. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    If you had the choice, which school would you attend???

    I've been offered to both schools and am in a dilemma on which school to reserve my spot in.

    All advice is greatly appreciated!! :p
     
  2. SDN Members don't see this ad. About the ads.
  3. zeyad

    zeyad Soon-to-be resident 10+ Year Member

    89
    4
    Apr 16, 2006
    First of, congratulations! I can't really help much.. I'll just say that from what I do know, TCD had a wonderful reputation. As with everything else Irish, there are many controversies. I'll be keeping my eye out for this one cause I might be facing a smiliar dilemma soon! Anyway, congrats again.
     
  4. Sage880

    Sage880 Senior Member 5+ Year Member

    838
    1
    Jun 7, 2004
    Canada
    Congrats! Both very good schools. Tough to say which one I'd pick. Trinity is right in the very middle of downtown while UCD is more on the edge of the city. So location of living would be an easy way for you to decide.

    Personally, I'd take Trinity just because it's the higher point's school (more competitive among Irish students) but we're talking a difference of 5-10 points every year (which is nothing). But it's a nice school and a good location. But UCD is just as good and if you're the type who hates living in the absolute city center you might be happier there!
     
  5. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    Thanks Great points!!

    I have so much reflecting to do still....:scared: I hope that I choose the right school for me, b/c that is what is most important right~!
     
  6. eirosome

    eirosome 5+ Year Member

    14
    0
    Oct 20, 2006
    You are in a great position and won't go wrong with either school. They both have good reputations for medicine. The "points" system doesn't rate the school, it is simply a measure of supply and demand. Trinity actually has less places than UCD so that pushes up the points.

    Everyone likes the architecture in Trinity but it is the facilities that matter, and I think UCD has better facilities. They have just opened a brand new medical building and library beside the biomed research labs. The sport facilities and accommodation on campus are pretty good too.
     
  7. Jocks

    Jocks Senior Member 10+ Year Member

    153
    0
    Feb 21, 2005
    Hey All,

    I wouldn't bother trying to make your decision based on reputation, because both will take you as far as you want them to. Also, trying to figure out which program is better is an exercise in futility.

    However, the schools are set up quite differently. Trinity is a fairly compact campus set in the heart of downtown with lots of hustle and bustle about it (think U of Toronto). UCD is a sprawling campus with lots of greenspace set in a posh area south of Downtown (think UWO). UCD is fairly self-contained; one could spend all year here and not leave campus (bad idea). Trinity is a part of the downtown core with tourists wandering through and shops surrounding it.

    The architecture is quite different as well. Trinity has more classical architecture (not surprising given it's age) which is quite beautiful. UCD has more modern architecture, which in my opinion isn't quite the same, but the Medical facilities are much more recent (Jan 2007) which makes up for it.

    I personally prefer the large self-contained campus however that's just a personal preference.

    Cheers,
    Jocks
     
  8. Arb

    Arb Senior Member 7+ Year Member

    556
    4
    Aug 30, 2004
    Living in City Centre would probably be more expensive but, there would probably be more choices and availability than around UCD. I'm planning living on campus for atleast another year. I'm not sure if Trinity students stay after first year. Also, when we say UCD is on the outskirts of Dublin, that means a 10 minute bus ride to Trinity so really not that big of a deal....unless you're out drinking until 3ish. UCD's facilities are newer and probably better. St. Vincents hospital is within walking distance from campus and it's one of the better hospitals in Dublin I think. I wouldn't want to go to St. James or Tal that's for sure.
     
  9. leorl

    leorl Physician Moderator Emeritus Lifetime Donor Classifieds Approved 10+ Year Member

    5,559
    11
    Jan 2, 2001
    Trinity is beautiful and it's nice to live somewhere with history. Anatomy classes are still given in lecture amphitheaters with wooden pews and designs. Ok, not the most comfortable but it is quaint and quite nice. It just depends what you like. UCD is further from the city centre, but you can cycle to town in like 10 minutes if you're a fast cyclist. Regarding hospitals, people keep ragging on St James's...I don't really understand why, unless it's because of the catchment area served. Architecturally, it's not as nice as some others and may be cramped, but it's got a great fun atmosphere. Tallaght hospital is farther out and 40 minutes by Luas from city centre, but it's a great hospital in terms of organization and nice staff. I was always an SJH fan until my surgery placement in Tallaght this year, it's really cool. So I'd be happy at either place. It's not really the architecture of the hospitals that matter...it's the teaching you get in them and the relationships you build with the staff.
     
  10. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    So if I have this right.
    Academically, I believe the two schools are pretty much par. One school is in the heart of downtown and is synonymous with U of Toronto and the other is 10 minutes away. Is there anything else that sets the two apart?

    I understand that UCD runs from September-May where as TCD runs from October-June. For those trying to do electives in the states or Canada, does the difference in start and finishing dates have its advantages and disadvantages?
     
  11. med2UCC

    med2UCC Relentlessly Optimistic 10+ Year Member

    UCC runs on the October to June schedule (until 3rd year when it switched to late-August to early June) and it has no impact on doing electives - most of the places I've looked into have been really flexible about dates, and you can always miss a week of clinics at the beginning of the year if you need to. It's nice with the late start in 1st and 2nd year because you get to enjoy more of the Canadian fall, which is much nicer than September in Cork, usually.OK, enough procrastination. Must study - OSCE tomorrow. Cheers,
    M
     
  12. docolive

    docolive DOColive 5+ Year Member

    832
    1
    Jun 23, 2005
    Even though I have yet to hear from the schools, I just wanted to say thank you to all of the TCD, UCC, UCD and RCSI students who have enlightened us with information and opinions regarding medical school and life in Ireland. :thumbup:
     
  13. Arb

    Arb Senior Member 7+ Year Member

    556
    4
    Aug 30, 2004
    Trinity would be more synonymous to Queen's University or McGill. UCD is bigger in terms of size and student population. Trinity is much older with more history (400ish years compared to 150ish years old) although both have plenty of history. Personally that doesn't affect my daily life and people back home won't know how old either school is. Student accommodations are right on campus in UCD and you can roll out of bed and walk to class in 10 minutes. Facilities are newer at UCD. Living in City Centre would be very convenient when you're out late. It's tough finding a cab at 3am to take you back home. Cab ride for 4 would be around 15 Euro or 4 Euro/person on the Nightlink.
     
  14. Arb

    Arb Senior Member 7+ Year Member

    556
    4
    Aug 30, 2004
    Also, if you like green, UCD's campus is full of fields, trees, flowers, and a few ponds. Trinity's not quite like that due to space limitations. Athletics-wise, there's a sports centre on the UCD campus with squash courts, climbing wall, courts, gym (you have to pay). There are like 8 soccer pitches/fields to play sports on, a running track with hurdles and sand pits if you're into track and field. You can see the sea/ocean on campus if you go to a 4 storey building. Talked to a few mature Irish students last night and they felt Trinity med program was outdated. Even met some Trinity students in other faculties and they're all very nice. No complaints from North Americans regarding Trinity so far (in terms of education), only from Irish students from UCD. No matter where you go, I think it'll be up to you to make it work.

    Edit: Oh yeah we have the ducks and swans that stay on campus all year in the large artifical pond. Sort of like mascots and they can be fun once in a while!
     
  15. Jocks

    Jocks Senior Member 10+ Year Member

    153
    0
    Feb 21, 2005
    Frank the Tank!
     
  16. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
     
  17. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    Hey Leorl,

    You mentioned that 1st years don't usually get accomodations on Campus. How do most people get to school then? Other than biking? Is public transportation in Dublin well set up, so that a student can go 5 years with out a vehicle?

    How do most people at UCD and Trinity get around? Do they buy/lease a car or depend solely on public transportation? I was looking on the map and the teaching hospitals are some distance away from the schools.

    Thanks
     
  18. ftcnt

    ftcnt Junior Member 10+ Year Member

    54
    1
    Oct 29, 2004
    can people comment on the climate compared to that in Canada. Just trying to get an idea
     
  19. Sage880

    Sage880 Senior Member 5+ Year Member

    838
    1
    Jun 7, 2004
    Canada
    More milder for the most part. In Cork it goes from min 5 degrees to max about 25. Although today it's almost 30 degrees....

    People always talk about the rain but it doesn't rain that much - more mists. Although some days it's just pissing rain and it's horrible - especially Jan-Feb. Besides those two months the rest of the year is really nice.

    Cork is hit by the gulf stream so it's a lot warmer then Dublin. Still doesn't snow there though often but gets down to around 0 degrees. Summers are about the same.
     
  20. ftcnt

    ftcnt Junior Member 10+ Year Member

    54
    1
    Oct 29, 2004
    doesnt seem that. not too much snow and lows around 0. not too shabby. one quick question and dont mean to hijack the thread but where are the Irish Med interviews done for Canadian prospective students
     
  21. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
  22. Blitz2006

    Blitz2006 10+ Year Member

    1,444
    333
    Nov 20, 2006
    Hey applepark,

    cool weather.com link, thanks.

    Apparently Birmingham UK gets less rain than Kingston, Ontario. Sweet.

    Ok, back to applepark's transportation issue.
     
  23. Arb

    Arb Senior Member 7+ Year Member

    556
    4
    Aug 30, 2004
    I don't think many people buy cars. They're very expensive here plus I think you need an international license I think.

    Bus is fine. A bike is handy but that's expensive as well. I don't really see why you would need a car especially if you live in City Centre.

    Weather here is great actually. In dublin you don't get much rain (certainly not what you hear about anyways). Winters here are mild for sure. I didn't even wear my full winter coat this year. It rarely gets below 0 even at night. But everyone's different of course. I'm from Ontario and it wasn't bad. Those from Alberta were handling it even better.
     
  24. ftcnt

    ftcnt Junior Member 10+ Year Member

    54
    1
    Oct 29, 2004
  25. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    So I'm assuming that most people bus it to the hospitals then when they begin their clinical. Because the hospitals on google seem to be some distance from the actual school.
     
  26. Jocks

    Jocks Senior Member 10+ Year Member

    153
    0
    Feb 21, 2005
    Vincent's is only a very short walk away from UCD's campus.
     
  27. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    yes, but Vincent isn't the only hospital that students go to.
     
  28. eg77

    eg77 Member 5+ Year Member

    198
    0
    Jul 26, 2005
    So apple, which school did you decide to attend? I have a gut feeling you choose TCD...am I right? :)
     
  29. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    OMG eg77

    are you stalking me? I've decided as of today that I will be giving my money to TCD. Of course until I send in my money nothing is final and I might have a sudden change of heart (I've been having them frequently as of late) right at the bank, but for now I believe I'm a TCDer :p .

    Cheers
     
  30. eg77

    eg77 Member 5+ Year Member

    198
    0
    Jul 26, 2005
    Muhahah...Muhahah...Muhahahh !!!! Ok that was really creepy :)

    That's awesome...TCD sounds exciting. So what were the factors that attracted you to it as opposed to UCD?!?

    Also, are you on the Canadian pre-med forum, with the name "apple" ? There's someone by the name of apple on that forum that's been accepted to Ireland and is waiting for UBC...Anyways, that's the same scnario I'm in so I thought I'd ask :oops:
     
  31. applepark

    applepark 2+ Year Member

    54
    0
    Apr 21, 2007
    Canada
    Apples is me ^_^ Who are you on the other forum? Or are u just a "Guest" kekekekeke.

    BTW your "Muhahahah"'s don't scare me :D
     
  32. bawds

    bawds

    9
    0
    May 7, 2007
    Can someone please help!! I have been accepted into both Trinity and Galway and can't decide. Anyone know anything to help me choose? Thanks
     
  33. leorl

    leorl Physician Moderator Emeritus Lifetime Donor Classifieds Approved 10+ Year Member

    5,559
    11
    Jan 2, 2001
    for tcd, most take the luas or bus to the tallaght hospital, but for sjh many walk or cycle. can also bus or luas. SJH isnt that far away.
     
  34. roo

    roo Voice From The Wilderness 10+ Year Member

    199
    1
    Nov 16, 2000
    For Trinity or UCD:

    Both are fine colleges. An education will do fine for both.

    More people on the street in North America will have heard of Trinity but it is more to do with the arts than medicine. Residency choice will be about the same from my experience in Ireland.

    I can't comment on the finer points of Trinity since I didn't go there. I used to walk through the campus sometimes though, and I liked the old ivy-league type of buildings better than the soviet style of UCD's Belfield campus. That's all that I can really say about Trinity.

    For UCD , I like having 60+ acres with greenspace, despite the marring of it by soviet-style buildings. I came from a rural area, and Belfield and St. Stephen's Green were certainly therapeutic to get a break from concrete and asphalt.

    If Trinity vs. UCD nowadays, I would take UCD but that is my bias since I went to UCD and it was fine.

    If I hadn't gone to either, I think I would slightly tip toward UCD, on the benefit that the president of the UCD university is now medical and has US medical training (Professor Brady). With him at the helm, all the remaining lingering things that should get have been done years ago are moving forward quicker to getting done (such as moving Earlsford Terrace to Belfield, tighten up branding and internet presence, more Belfield residences, etc).
     

Share This Page