Originally posted by 2003doc
I stumbled on this thread because I am a MS-4 who is searching out Florida programs for residency and was interested to hear what students thought of it there. Both UF/Shands and U. Miami/Jackson M. have a respectable reputation; if I was a Florida resident when I applied to medical school or was interested in going to a private school, both would have been high on my list.
Just gotta throw my good word for state schools in here. Having completed all but the last 7 months of medical school, USMLE Step 1, 2, ERAS, and a few electives at other institutions, I have found that medical knowledge and experience is not profoundly different whether you come from Ivy League or Alabama (and proud of it!) At my small school, our classes annually average ~5 points above the mean on USMLE Step 1 and many of us achieved scores in the 230+ range. Although some people "settle" on state schools because they did not get into private/better-known ones, many of us actually only wanted to come here. That was my case; I really did have a MCAT score in the mid-30's and a 3.7 GPA, but I was 21 years old, didn't have much money, and the idea of being $300,000 in debt to a place like Harvard or Vandy scared me; so I looked for an accredited state program with good hands-on experience. I applied early decision back in the day, so this was my one-and-only application.
No doubt that places like Harvard will always carry esteem on name alone in the medical and outside world and that research opportunities and facilities may be more extensive. On the other hand, I have completed some rotations at "bigger-named" places over the last few months, and from working with PGY-1's who completed medical school in a variety of the prestigious (a.k.a Duke, Vandy) institutions, there really is no difference in the way they approach medicine, their clinical expertise, etc., than where I am from. That said, if you are interested in prestige, good-funding, research, private may be the way to go. However, you can match very well even if you are from less well-known places- you will find that if you take advantage of the resources given to you, you can obtain quite a fine education whether you are from Mobile, Florida, Cali., or Boston.
Cheers