University of Virginia

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Eye_c_u

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2006
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
I'm trying to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of this program. While there is a lot to like about Charlottesville, I have a few concerns regarding the relatively small faculty. Also, I am curious about the fellowship opportunities that are available to alumni (retina in particular). Any input would be welcome!
 
I'm trying to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of this program. While there is a lot to like about Charlottesville, I have a few concerns regarding the relatively small faculty. Also, I am curious about the fellowship opportunities that are available to alumni (retina in particular). Any input would be welcome!

UVA

RESIDENTS HAPPY?
absolutely... its warm, the attendings are nice, theres a lot of culture in the city... patients are friendly. All the residents seemed to like the atmosphere and were very approachable... very balanced and happy ppl! (one note: all the current residents are married, white and male, but apparently next yr they have two girls that aren't married...... just thank the match for randomness 😉

DECENT FELLOWSHIPS?
definitely... UVA has a great reputation in the south; can't remember specifics but they send people off for retina and cornea regularly w/o any problem. They have a 1 yr retina fellowship there also. I think their only weakness may be plastics (not in terms of exposure, but in terms of getting a fellowship)

PROBATION?
NO! (they were on probation but it had nothing to do w/their ophtho training... the probation was removed in ~Nov.) This is not something I would worry about...

DIDACTICS?
Dr. Conway, retina, is an excellent teacher and very friendly. Dr. Ghazi their new attending is awesome, he turned down a spot at Wilmer to stay at UVA. He is amazing, in fund of knowledge, teaching skills, and is really kind and warm!! you have to meet him in person to know this. Dr. Newman is a world class neuro op guy who writes the BCS series; he does all sorts of surgeries too like ONSF. The people in the south are in general very friendly too!

LIKELIHOOD OF HAVING FUN:
If you have a family C'ville is an amazing place to live... the downtown mall is ultra cultured and it is a wonderful place to raise a family. You can buy a home/condo in Cville for the 200k range. Cville is also voted one of the best places to go trail running and the city was voted the best place to live back in 2001 (maybe it was 2000). Anyhow it is the ultimate place to raise kids - clean/safe/great schools. It is a 2 hour drive to northern virginia/DC area.

If you want to meet other young ppl the business school and lawschool are top notch, but you aren't going to meet I bankers, lawyers, and ad execs like you would in NYC/Boston/Philly.


NAME/REPUTATION?
Strong reputation. UVA is well regarded by most ophthalmologists I have spoken with as a lower top tier program (if there was a ranking system then like 20-25th in the country). If you do well there you can do whatever you want.
 
I know this sounds dumb, but I like University of Virginia also b/c I am a Thomas Jefferson fan. He is my favorite president! Its just a classy school!
 
I'm trying to weigh the strengths and weaknesses of this program. While there is a lot to like about Charlottesville, I have a few concerns regarding the relatively small faculty. Also, I am curious about the fellowship opportunities that are available to alumni (retina in particular). Any input would be welcome!

I'm not an optho person at all, in fact, I'm MS2 in Texas.

I however did spend 6 years in charlottesville working in health care while getting my masters at UVA.

I think overall there is one thing at UVA that is quite apparent whatever field you do, little autonomy. I mean, some med students here have more autonomy here then I ever saw a resident have at UVA.

The UVA mentality seems to be based on close scrutinization of everything.

In addition, there are so many good options for healthcare in Virginia I think they are really limited in the pathology they see. I knew one resident in particular who left UVA because of this ... she just wasn't seeing anything. VCU, all the northern Virginia hospitals, and Hopkins suck up quite a lot of the interesting cases.

My sister is optho resident now and she did an audition rotation at UVA. I think overall her opinion was the surgery done at UVA was quite limited in comparison to other places she interviewed.

Ok, now keep in mind .... I'm not a very reliable resource about the specifics of the optho program.
 
Sorry. But, I beg to differ. Unless things have changed recently, UVA is not even close to a top 25 program. I would place it in the mid-lower to lower tier of programs. I spoke to several of my co-residents, and they agreed with this assessment. They do not have enough full time faculty coverage (as least when I interviewed). Facilities were beat down. Residents were happy enough, but I got the impression that it was not their top choice(s).

Please, please talk to people who have interviewed there recently. I ranked it in the bottom 15%.

Beware of comments that praise programs 100%.
 
Sorry. But, I beg to differ. Unless things have changed recently, UVA is not even close to a top 25 program. I would place it in the mid-lower to lower tier of programs. I spoke to several of my co-residents, and they agreed with this assessment. They do not have enough full time faculty coverage (as least when I interviewed). Facilities were beat down. Residents were happy enough, but I got the impression that it was not their top choice(s).

Please, please talk to people who have interviewed there recently. I ranked it in the bottom 15%.

Beware of comments that praise programs 100%.

Bottom 15%? How did you determine this?
 
Bottom 15%? How did you determine this?

I ranked it in the bottom 15% of my rank list. I interviewed at many programs (over 18). If not else, it allowed me more insight into the relative strengths/weaknesses of most programs. You definitely hear the gossip on the interview trail. Most applicants tend to be isolated to one part of the county, so you don't hear the nitty-gritty about programs outside your area.

To the original poster,
Like most applicants, I ranked based on many factors including surgical variety and numbers, pathology, faculty support, fellowship placement, resident happiness, atmosphere, location, etc. I ranked some well known programs below lesser known programs due to atmosphere and resident happiness. Name is not everything.

UVA School of Medicine overall has a good reputation. Most of your classmates will likely be impressed if you matched there. They would just as likely be clueless about the Univ of Iowa being a top 5-10 program. But, within ophthalmology, I think most would consider it a weaker program. But, if it fits what you need/want, more power to you.
 
I ranked it in the bottom 15% of my rank list. I interviewed at many programs (over 18). If not else, it allowed me more insight into the relative strengths/weaknesses of most programs. You definitely hear the gossip on the interview trail. Most applicants tend to be isolated to one part of the county, so you don't hear the nitty-gritty about programs outside your area.

To the original poster,
Like most applicants, I ranked based on many factors including surgical variety and numbers, pathology, faculty support, fellowship placement, resident happiness, atmosphere, location, etc. I ranked some well known programs below lesser known programs due to atmosphere and resident happiness. Name is not everything.

UVA School of Medicine overall has a good reputation. Most of your classmates will likely be impressed if you matched there. They would just as likely be clueless about the Univ of Iowa being a top 5-10 program. But, within ophthalmology, I think most would consider it a weaker program. But, if it fits what you need/want, more power to you.

If it was in the bottom 15% of your match list and you were interviewing at Bascom Palmer/Wills/Etc... well... hrm I think that puts it exactly where I would imagine the program (lower top tier assuming each tier is 35 programs and there is a top, middle, and bottom tier)

SDN'ers are just a stellar cohort.

For me its in the lower half of my ranklist b/c I have a good mix of top tier columbia/nyeei/tufts
to lower top tier/middler tier: cornell/uva/boston univ and some lower tier programs (which I actually ranked higher than many middle tier) ie: St. Lukes/St. Vincents
 
I'm hoping to revive this thread. Can anyone add some information regarding the UVA ophtho residency? I'm trying to decide if it's worth the $$$ to head out there for an interview.

Concerns: Small full-time faculty (only 7). Only 1 fellowship- retina. What are the surgical numbers? Call-schedule? There is very little info on their website.
 
UVA is a smaller program, but also very solid both clinically and surgically. Previous posts that comment on the variety of pathology are not true. UVA covers all of central and western Virginia, and gets a plethora of interesting and diverse pathology (diverse indigent population, large area for recent refugees, trauma, etc.)
Call: There are 3 residents per year, and call is front loaded, like many other smaller programs out there. However, 2nd and 3rd year is much better. Open globes are frequent.
Happiness: Residents are all very happy, as this is a very close knit program, both between residents and faculty. Unlike many bigger programs where you may go through your residency with many faculty not knowing your name, you develop a close relationship with all faculty members at UVA.
Curriculum: 1st year is spent in your own resident continuity clinic, with 3rd years and faculty available for backup. At first, you run patients by upper levels or attendings, but as you get more comfortable, you have excellent autonomy. 2nd year is spent in sub-specialty clinics (neuro-op, cornea, retina, glaucoma, peds). 3rd year is spent doing an insane amount of surgery. Last year, residents were in the 250-300 range for cataracts, while also getting a great variety of other cases. Residents spend some time during 3rd year at the Salem VA (~2 hrs away), but you are set up with an apartment. You have great autonomy here, and get a large amount of cataracts.
Faculty: The faculty at UVA are excellent and very eager to teach! Dr. Conway is well-known for retina. Dr. Newman is a world-class neuro-op who sees an abundance of pathology, and is an excellent teacher. Dr. Ghazi is also in retina and is an amazing teacher. They just brought in a new glaucome physician. Overall, great faculty who take a vested interest in each resident.
Fellowships: 1 or 2 residents each year decide to pursue a fellowship. They have sent residents in the past years into cornea (Devers EI with Dr. Terry, and Colorado), retina (boston area program).
Facilities: I have heard concerns from other applicants that the facilities at UVA are dismal. The facilities do not compare to the likes of some other large programs, but they utilize the space they have very well. The main clinic has 15-16 exam rooms, and residents get there own exam room. There is a photography suite, Humphreys, OCT, etc. with excellent ancillary staff. There is also a minor procedure rooms for TA biopsies, chalazion removal, etc. There is an eye OR in the main OR, and also several rooms at the outpatient surgery center where most of the cases are performed. There is also a more modern facility where many of the subspecialty clinics are held. These facilities are extremely nice and only a 5 minute drive away.
Charlottesville: A wonderful mid-sized city of ~150,000 people that is beautiful and includes the historic UVA and home of Thomas Jefferson. There is a wide array of outdoor life to enjoy including hiking in the Blue Ridge Mountains, beautiful road biking, great single-trac mountain biking. There is an abundance of cultural life, including arts, music, and plenty of places to eat (you name it, Cville probably has it). The music scene here rivals that of many bigger cities. There is a newly built venue that brings in big names all the time. As previous post pointed out, named best place to live in Frommers previously. Tons of great places to live that are very affordable, and many residents purchase homes. Large population of young professionals for those who are single. Plus, it is 2 hours from DC and an hour from Richmond. Although shopping is weak, they are building a brand new mall with some high-end stores which will be completed in 2010.

Overall: Solid clinical experience with some of the higher surgical numbers around. Excellent autonomy with back-up as needed.
 
Top