Last edited:
Hello all, I ask so many questions on here and first just want to say thank you for all the support!
A little background: I am certainly not a genius, but when I apply myself I do very well. While an undergrad, I did very poorly my freshman year and worked my butt of to get into medical school. Since I was a child, i have always wanted to go "all out" in school and see how well I can do. Unfortunately, circumstances arose freshman year of college that prevented me from doing so. I still got into a medical school that I love and one that is truly devoted to making great physicians, rather than boosting their stats. That being said, I really really want to give it my all and go for top 5 in my class and land in a great residency program (I am a very hard worker and excellent at maintaining a social life, but I am not a gunner in the sense that I will screw people over). The school I am attending is definitely up and coming and well liked in my state, however, it is unranked. If I get above average board scores, couple of publications (have one 1st author from undergrad), good leadership roles, and of course have excellent LoR's and interviews, will I have a chance at getting into a highly competitive residency program (e.g. top 10 and in a competitive field). My family and I have always struggled and I am just so grateful to finally have a clean slate that of which I want to take full advantage. Thanks to all!
Hello all, I ask so many questions on here and first just want to say thank you for all the support!
A little background: I am certainly not a genius, but when I apply myself I do very well. While an undergrad, I did very poorly my freshman year and worked my butt of to get into medical school. Since I was a child, i have always wanted to go "all out" in school and see how well I can do. Unfortunately, circumstances arose freshman year of college that prevented me from doing so. I still got into a medical school that I love and one that is truly devoted to making great physicians, rather than boosting their stats. That being said, I really really want to give it my all and go for top 5 in my class and land in a great residency program (I am a very hard worker and excellent at maintaining a social life, but I am not a gunner in the sense that I will screw people over). The school I am attending is definitely up and coming and well liked in my state, however, it is unranked. If I get above average board scores, couple of publications (have one 1st author from undergrad), good leadership roles, and of course have excellent LoR's and interviews, will I have a chance at getting into a highly competitive residency program (e.g. top 10 and in a competitive field). My family and I have always struggled and I am just so grateful to finally have a clean slate that of which I want to take full advantage. Thanks to all!
It sounds like you just want a top 10 residency to feel less insecure, not for any real end goal.
Medical school rank has little to do with how far you'll go during residency applications. Its all up to you now.
In addition, we cannot ignore that especially for competitive residencies there are biases. It is well documented that most top tier surgical programs will not take DOs or FMGs. If you peruse the list of medical schools at those programs, you will see a high percentage are from other top tier programs. Thus, training at a well recognized medical school IS an advantage to the top programs especially when you are considering a competitive specialty. I know this is an unpopular sentiment but the fact is that pedigree does matter to some extent even with a stellar application. If a program holds such a bias, then it will be difficult if not impossible to overcome that.
So what?
Sorry, didn't realize I had to lay out all my life goals in order to post a question......
The pre-med track conditions pre-meds to be goal oriented. I agree that many of us probably don't know what constitutes a great residency, I for sure don't know and have been trying to figure it out since I got accepted. So in our ignorance, we cling to names and places we're familiar with. Like a lot of other things, 3rd and 4th year hopefully will produce a more thorough picture of what to look for in a residency.
Honestly, a lot of pre-meds including myself are bored and have just exited the rat race that was med school admissions. We're excited about med school and are trying to figure out what we can do in this 3 months of limbo between two very different phases of our lives.
So topics like this come up and we end up looking like gunners in the making. I think, to the contrary, we're just goal oriented individuals who want something to shoot for so we can hit the ground running. If, like someone suggested above, we become P=MD students - then so be it. I'm comfortable letting things unfold like they're going to. What I'm not comfortable with is going in and getting blindsided by the process, sitting there 4 years later wishing I had done more, studied more, researched more. I don't think anyone should knock anyone for aiming high. Residency is confusing for a lot of pre-meds. We're just trying to figure out the next rat race. What's that saying, "shoot for the stars, and you'll land on the moon." At least, that's how I'm looking at it. Hopefully, I won't be as miserable as you think I'll be.
And nobody is saying you shouldn't aim high. But if you don't even know what you're aiming at....
It's not like we weren't where you are just a few years ago. That's why we try to give advice based on our experiences.
And nobody is saying you shouldn't aim high. But if you don't even know what you're aiming at....
This--I went to a middle tier medical school, and we had students match to virtually every "big name" program in the country--hopkins, harvard, duke, stanford, etc. It's all about you.
2. Yes, you can match any specialty and any program from any med school, with very few exceptions. I went to an unranked med school and got surveys after match day from "top programs" that were lower on my match list than where I matched. They wanted to know why I didn't rank them higher. It happens every year.
Winged Scapula said:In addition, we cannot ignore that especially for competitive residencies there are biases. It is well documented that most top tier surgical programs will not take DOs or FMGs. If you peruse the list of medical schools at those programs, you will see a high percentage are from other top tier programs. Thus, training at a well recognized medical school IS an advantage to the top programs especially when you are considering a competitive specialty. I know this is an unpopular sentiment but the fact is that pedigree does matter to some extent even with a stellar application. If a program holds such a bias, then it will be difficult if not impossible to overcome that.
I agree with most of this, Dr. Cox. The only thing I would say is that while attending a top tier school may be an advantage, the OP asked if attending a lower tier/unranked school is a disadvantage. I would argue that it is not. Correlation is at play, not causation. There are statistically more competitive applicants from schools that are top tier. Yes, inbreeding occurs, but we cannot say how much of it is due to correlation from higher performing individuals already being at those institutions (I believe Chronicidal did an analysis of this, but I'm not sure it could account for this).
Bottom line is: if you work hard, it is certainly possible. Just look at one of the plastics interns at Hopkins. Graduated from a non-ranked Midwest MD school. Same for one at WashU.
Work as hard as you can, OP, and worry little about the things you cannot control.
If going to a top school is an advantage, then going to a lower tier/unranked school is, by definition, a disadvantage. It's all relative -- you can't have one thing be an advantage and the other not be a disadvantage. And while it's possible that top tier schools may statistically have more competitive applicants in terms of research or what not (though not likely that every single student at a top school has significantly more research than every single student at an average school), we can only judge by the only objective measure we have -- board scores -- which shows that top schools in fact have similar averages as any other school.
will I have a chance at getting into a highly competitive residency program (e.g. top 10 and in a competitive field).
I totally understand your feelings, OP. I feel like if I don't choose a specialty right now, I'm going to be at a serious disadvantage compared to everyone else if I want to go into something competitive (I want to do infectious disease now, but I hear everyone's choice changes).
For med school admissions, I was the mediocre applicant who struggled to get in. I'm not after something prestigious for the sake of its prestige, but I would like to have the chance to choose between options, including top tier places if I want, rather than being forced to accept whatever I can get. I love the school I got into, but it's not a good feeling to be limited by an average application. I want the opportunity to turn that around in med school.
Medical school rank has little to do with how far you'll go during residency applications. Its all up to you now.
I totally understand your feelings, OP. I feel like if I don't choose a specialty right now, I'm going to be at a serious disadvantage compared to everyone else if I want to go into something competitive (I want to do infectious disease now, but I hear everyone's choice changes).
For med school admissions, I was the mediocre applicant who struggled to get in. I'm not after something prestigious for the sake of its prestige, but I would like to have the chance to choose between options, including top tier places if I want, rather than being forced to accept whatever I can get. I love the school I got into, but it's not a good feeling to be limited by an average application. I want the opportunity to turn that around in med school.
I totally understand your feelings, OP. I feel like if I don't choose a specialty right now, I'm going to be at a serious disadvantage compared to everyone else if I want to go into something competitive (I want to do infectious disease now, but I hear everyone's choice changes).
For med school admissions, I was the mediocre applicant who struggled to get in. I'm not after something prestigious for the sake of its prestige, but I would like to have the chance to choose between options, including top tier places if I want, rather than being forced to accept whatever I can get. I love the school I got into, but it's not a good feeling to be limited by an average application. I want the opportunity to turn that around in med school.
+1
I have no idea what I want to do. But it seems like if I don't line up (possibly specialty-specific) research and start getting to know physicians in whichever specialty shortly after stepping foot on campus I will be at a disadvantage.
Thanks for the understanding and feedback from all the posts. It's not that I'm 100% dead set on going for a highly competitive residency, but I also don't want to shut those doors if I do end up liking some of the competitive fields and/or end up doing well in school
Aren't some schools unranked simply because they choose not to send their info? Mayo is unranked, and I don't think that top residency programs would turn down a Mayo grad because his/her school isn't ranked. But obviously there is a distinction between unranked schools that would be considered top tier and those that would have a lesser rank.
+1
I have no idea what I want to do. But it seems like if I don't line up (possibly specialty-specific) research and start getting to know physicians in whichever specialty shortly after stepping foot on campus I will be at a disadvantage.
Seriously, stop it. Focus on doing well in school rather than the possibility of not having options. I didn't decide to do plastics until over halfway through my third year, and I was more than fine. My research I had done was in ENT (which wasn't even what I wanted to do before plastics. It was just interesting research, which is all that really matters).
Research is the least of your worries if you get a 203 on step 1.
You guys need to calm the hell down, honestly. I'm not saying that to be a jerk, but to be realistic. Trying to have a pre-conceived 100% (or any idea) about what you want to do is just not how you should do things. Or even worry. Med School is there to help you get an idea of what you'd like to do. That's what 3rd/4th year is for. Am I saying don't think of anything? No. I'm saying focus on classes. Do some research about fields if you're interested. If you have free time/if the school offers it - shadow or follow a doctor in a field you're interested in.
I'm done with 1st/2nd year and my experiences in class/hospitals, has definitely helped me rule out specialties I wouldn't enjoy. Am I 100% sure? No. But it's helped. It's also helped alleviate my hesitations about doing things I think I want to do like hem/onc or EM+Tox. Will things possibly change? Maybe. That's what the next two years are for.
To answer the original question - No, it doesn't. I've never heard of anyone with a stellar/good step 1 in a med school with good LOR getting shafted. People here/real life seem to think that being in a "lower ranked" school will screw them over. It won't. My friend who's probably going to get a 265 on step 1 will not have any issues if he does commit to rad/onc. He's brilliant. That step 1 (or even lesser important - grades in 1st/2nd year) will definitely play to his advantage.
You're in med school? You're already ahead of the game. Focus on what's important now - understanding/learning what's important. Study hard and get that awesome step 1 score. No one (except idiot admissions) will think twice if you have that step 1 and great LOR. My school is ranked 30th in the nation. If I was like you, I'd freak and think my chances weren't great. But it's not the case. If you do well in step 1 and get that LOR, you have a significant advantage in getting a residency you want in YOUR state and possible outside.
I'm not saying this based on my own experiences but from what I've read on here/seen in person/and people I've talked to.
Relax. If you feel comfortable w/ the material and you're doing well on Uworld, you won't be in any trouble.
I'm not even aiming high for residencies (like I said) but I still am studying hard for step 1. Not to get the highest score imaginable (my current score is more than fine) but because I want to understand these things for 3rd/4th year. Why? Because I want to be more comfortable with 3rd/4th year so I can try to at least give 10% of my attention to fields I'm interested in....
In the end - the only issue I've seen are people going Caribbean. Or... low ranked DO schools. By low ranked I mean places where they have to try to get rotations in any hospital and get shafted. DO's are not idiots/incompetent. But I think they do have a disadvantage at certain schools in getting those LOR in 3rd/4th year... but correct me if I'm wrong.
Honestly, this has been my mindset from the beginning. Indeed, these are some of the reasons why I chose the school that I did. According to rankings, it's not as good a school as others I was accepted to, but I feel that it's a solid school that I will ultimately be happier at. I guess I just have to keep reminding myself of this after reading some of the posts on here.![]()