I'm from CA and only have an idea of these schools from my interviews, SDN & US News. If anyone can help give me the pros and cons of each school, it'd help me out a lot. I saw a UWMad vs. Rush thread, but there wasn't that many comments on it. Thanks!
Before asking what people think of school A vs. school B, ask yourself some concrete questions:
a) What kind of grading system do you want? A/B/C/F, or H/P/F? Or do you not really believe that there is a difference? Are classes graded on a curve?
b) What kind of atmosphere do you want? College town, small town, big city?
c) What things do you think you'll want to specialize in? Do you want to do primary care or something very competitive?
d) What kind of weather do you want (or at least, are willing to tolerate).
e) What kind of facilities are in place to help students learn? Do they record lectures? Do they provide you with (free, pre-printed) lecture notes? Do they have a lot of resources online for students?
f) Where can you do rotations? Can you do all your rotations with minimal travel time, or are you forced to go very far for some rotations? Are rotations in a big city, a suburb, rural, or a mix?
g) what kind of teaching system is it? Is it block scheduling, all PBL, traditional? What do you think you'll like better?
Once you think about these questions, it makes it easier to compare schools.
I go to Jefferson, so if you have any specific questions, feel free to PM. Good luck with your decision!