Was it worth it threads?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

t510

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
47
Reaction score
2
Sorry to write again, I was just wondering if anyone could help me out finding information from past non-traditional students discussing if all the training was worth it at their age? I am going to be 30 soon and probably not 33 if I were to get into medical school. I current have a good paying, high stress, low job security job 😉
I was thinking of working until I got into medical school. Seems like a decent calculated risk.
 
Don't go into this if it's a "calculated" risk or if you need to evaluate "worth" in terms of financial benefits. It's really way too hard a journey for it to be valuable if it's primarily about the Benjamins. This has to be something you want to do because you enjoy the role, the job function. you'll be killing yourself, isolating yourself and depriving yourself of sleep and family events, through at least a decade of school and low paying training, and if you aren't enjoying it for reasons other than what your financial future may bring (which isn't even so certain in this era of bad job markets in certain specialties and with capitations and reimbursement cuts still looming for some fields) you'll end up hating life and probably never make it through. I know tons of people whose heart wasn't in it, quit, figured out another way to get that sport car, and are more happy for it.

If, however, you are like some of us and get some kind of sick pleasure out of running around a hospital all night trying to keep patients alive, or getting your hands dirty in the OR, or sticking lines, tubes, scopes, needles, scalpels into people, or just enjoy talking to sick, scared, crazy and/or often noncompliant people, then you'll have no problem. So get out there and shadow and volunteer and see what doctors actually do. Because that's what you'll be bargaining for, not the income. Thts th inly useul measure of worth, not a calculation. only if you come away thinking "this is way cool, I could totally see myself doing that kind of work for the next thirty years" should you proceed.
 
That's very well put L2D.

To paraphrase the key question as I see it: it's a very individual question and worth it will not likely hinge on the financial for most people.

I don't think any of us, including myself, can give even our best individual answer until we've been seasoned attendings--maybe 5 or more years in. And what makes those answers even more strange and remote from considering it as a premed is the sheer, incalculable volume of experience under the bridge at that point.

Entire eras pass. Multiple presidential administrations. Fashions revolve. Big glasses are back in. (What!?). The old salty balls attending might think of the downslide from the great golden age of doctoring and say it ain't worth it anymore kid. And what does that even mean to a premed in an economy where if you're not selling hot air on Wall Street or serving the customer for his consumer credit then you don't have a job. While entire college departments are selling fake dreams that amount to museum tickets to look at the aging baby boomer golfing in Florida exhibit.

It's a impossible situation. The is is it worth it thing.

I have vague nostalgic notions of being a premed. Being an intern is hot and fresh and in my face. I have no idea what Nasrudin the psychiatrist on his 2nd to 3rd job with a proper contract, lessening hours, and a huge say in my own working conditions will be thinking about all of this.
 
Last edited:
Agree with the above. In terms of finances alone, going through medical training is almost certainly not worth it. It has to be significantly more than a financial proposition to you, or you're better off doing something else.

And Nas, being an attending is better than being an intern like being in a romantic relationship is better than taking a sex ed class. Yes, the class helps you learn the basics, but it's still not the same as actually "practicing." 😉
 
Agree with the above. In terms of finances alone, going through medical training is almost certainly not worth it. It has to be significantly more than a financial proposition to you, or you're better off doing something else.

And Nas, being an attending is better than being an intern like being in a romantic relationship is better than taking a sex ed class. Yes, the class helps you learn the basics, but it's still not the same as actually "practicing." 😉

Well that's some good news then.

Oh god...sex ed class. Is it still that bad these days. It seems like it would be different in the internet era. Not like me looking at the women's underwear advertisement in the newspaper and wondering what was happening to me.

Only to listen to some jock in polyester coaching shorts and a polo saying the word penis too much in a class and expecting us not to laugh.
 
The other part of the strangeness of the question is that it can be directed only half-hazardly at one's own former self... who no longer exists anyway. Or if who does exist....exists in one of an infinite number of possible selves. Which effectively makes the asker the answerer in any case.

What does the fully committed physician really know about what she would do differently. How she might have been a pastry chef instead. Or a punk rocker.

There are just no answers to these things. Only stories. And more questions.

Each premed is truly on their own. It's folly or worse to imagine otherwise.
 
Only to listen to some jock in polyester coaching shorts and a polo

Tucked in Polo? That's how I like to remember them, tucking all manner of shirts into their silly shorts with "coaching" shoes. Ready at a moments notice to tell us how to do something they used to be able to do but still want to look like they could do.
 
Tucked in Polo? That's how I like to remember them, tucking all manner of shirts into their silly shorts with "coaching" shoes. Ready at a moments notice to tell us how to do something they used to be able to do but still want to look like they could do.
:laugh:.

Is there any other way to wear your polo with your Bike coaching shorts.

Now, that I'm grown, I think of some of the people in charge of me when I was young and it's no wonder I've never had confidence in authority. Most of my coaches were nice though. If somewhat stereotypical with regards to fashion choices. haha. Coaching fashion. haha.
 
Top