jjmack said:
I think the PhD-MSTP is very hard at almost all schools. The only school I know that seems to be open to it is sinai. I wonder why it's so difficult to do.
I think it's a combination of a lot of reasons, in no particular order.
-Usually (and obviously there are many exceptions) straight-PhD candidates do not have the same stellar records that MSTP applicants do. Thus this would be seen as the backdoor way of getting both degrees
-Med schools are large, and they don't mind if 1 or 2 students per class leave. Most graduate departments have a single-digit number of students per year, so the loss of one student hurts a department a lot more.
-By the time they transferred, grad students would be done with at least 1 or 2 years of their PhD. What order should they do it? Should they finish the PhD and then go to medical school? That doesn't really make any sense because then they don't need an MSTP program. If they quit for a while and go to med school, then who takes care of their PhD project while they are gone? What if they return to the lab and they are 3 years behind? etc.
-funding. Who pays for what? Does the faculty member pay for the rest of the PhD, then the MSTP pay for the med school? What if the potential transfer goes to med school in between? My guess is that the NIH grants to the MSTP programs are pretty strict about this.
-and of course just general institutional bureaucracy i.e. course requirements, PhD degree requirements, etc.
These are just a few of my random thoughts. I'm sure some of them may be wrong. It seems that it would be FEASIBLE to transfer from a PhD to an MSTP, but it would be such a headache that programs just say no. Alternatively, perhaps the NIH grants do not cover transfers from PhD programs at all?