This concept is very frustrating for me. How are people in their late teens or early 20s supposed to be able to a) get amazing grades; b) get an amazing MCAT score; c) get clinical experience; d) do non-clinical volunteering; e) do research at a meaningful level; f) be a leader; g) be super unique at a deep, committed level; and h) still be personable and friendly and outgoing and have a social life?? It's expecting too much. Plus, if you have a very strong, deep passion for something (I'll use the horseback riding example from earlier), isn't medicine not the best field for you to be able to foster both passions? It's not like you can be a competing equestrian who spends hours with your horses every week while in a general surgery residency. So aren't very intense, can't-live-without-it passions actually a detriment when pursuing medicine, as having to give up that hobby might make you a miserable student/resident/physician?
The logic just escapes me, I guess. It is also very discouraging. I know that there has to be some method to discern the thousands of applicants who all seem exactly the same... But an undergrad pulling in large grants and publishing multiple papers? Or founding their own clinic? That seems way too crazy. I really hope that those kinds of activities aren't becoming the norm.