- Joined
- Jan 7, 2009
- Messages
- 698
- Reaction score
- 1
Last edited:
I often help students try to figure out what they want. The way I pose it to them is "if you can sit under those hot lights, sweating your ass off, unable to move, back aching, barely able to see the surgery, you, replacing a simple tool without bathroom breaks, civility, or good humor, and you LOVE it? You're a surgeon. Period... If on the other hand you can't wait to stand up, walk around for 4 HOURS digressing on every single little factoid, dwelling on labs, and pouring your brain over an obvious diagnosis? You're medicine. Period. Anything else is just variations around the two. Except psych. Then you're doing it just to prove to yourself you ARENT crazy..."
If you dont fit in to the boys club, you'll be miserable the rest of your life.
In brief, I felt that becoming a surgeon would make ME the best doctor that I could be. General surgeons know a TON of medicine, and are very skilled with their hands. When I wanted to be a doctor, I didn't dream of a job where I'd work 40 hrs a week... I dreamed of a job where I can do a lot to help sick patients. Surgery does that. I even get excited about starting in lines, putting tubes, and all the other small procedures. Unfortunately, today's medicine doctors hardly do any of these bedside procedures (or maybe I should say fortunately for me).
Then you add to that what surgeons do in the OR. It is like no other. You take a person with a clear disease, and you cure them from that disease (fine, not always a cure, but it's often as definitive as it gets).
Just think of it this way, if you were stranded in a hospital (third world country, etc), with only 1 type of doctor who had access to information (ie a smart phone), who would you rather that doctor be? The truth is, surgeons CAN provide medical care, even if less efficient or with slightly more errors, if given sometime with a computer. The same can't be said about a non-surgeon.
Finally, what you are complaining about here seems to be residency, and not the life afterwards. If your going to let 5 years of training determine what you do for the next 30, then that's your call.
A surgeon that I shadowed said that having his hands inside of people is a good way to keep them warm in the morning and he hates cold hands.
Rotate with a private practice surgery group. The longest case I did was probably 4 hours, and most of the gall bladders were <45 minutes. An appy is a 20-30 minute case. The two longest cases I've ever done were a neurosurgery case and a gyn case (both 8 hours), and I'm almost done with my intern year.3. Cases in OR can range from 2 hours to 12 hours. My longest has been 11. Those are just plain miserable.
4. Operations are extremely tedious
5. Patients for the most part are ungrateful and don't care about you or what you are trying to do for them.
General surgeons haven't done CABGs or hip replacements in probably 40+ years. This isn't exactly a new change.The problem is general surgeons are becoming a rare breed, even "general surgeons" typically only do a select number of procedures, unless you are very rural.
To answer your question I'd say an ER doc, so I can be stabilized and flown home to specialists....bc honestly just because your a "general surgeon" doesn't mean you have the expertise to perform a triple bypass, a hip replacement or remove a brain tumor. You cannot be House, there is too much medicine too learn to do it all.
Rotate with a private practice surgery group. The longest case I did was probably 4 hours, and most of the gall bladders were <45 minutes. An appy is a 20-30 minute case. The two longest cases I've ever done were a neurosurgery case and a gyn case (both 8 hours), and I'm almost done with my intern year.
Seriously I don't understand why anyone would want to pursue a career in surgery (especially general). From what I've seen on my rotations:
1. you get to the hospital by 5 to round at 5:30. Sometimes you round at 5. Go home maybe by 7:30 and need to be asleep by 10 (a whole 2.5 hours to yourself!).
2. go to OR (if you aren't the intern taking care of floor patients) by 7:30
3. Cases in OR can range from 2 hours to 12 hours. My longest has been 11. Those are just plain miserable.
4. Operations are extremely tedious
5. Patients for the most part are ungrateful and don't care about you or what you are trying to do for them.
6. The atmosphere of the work environment is much harsher than, say, peds for example. Attendings generally are pleseant but as soon as something is not going the way they want they start to snap at everyone in the room.
I wanted to do surgery until I actually had my surgery rotation. Days were long and miserable. The operations were not the exciting.
I would just like to know, how as a medical student could you decide you want to do general surgery? What about it is appealing? Holding retrators? Surturing a 2 cm incision and then getting told it wasn't very good (and it prob wasn't)? Cutting sutures? or just standing there and watching for hours on end??
yeah I am complaining a little but I really do want to know why a student would choose surgery as a field. Again, I thought I wanted to do it until my rotation.
What you've just encountered is the realism behind specialty selection. No matter what you've set yourself up for, you really do feel a specialty.
The problem is general surgeons are becoming a rare breed, even "general surgeons" typically only do a select number of procedures, unless you are very rural.
To answer your question I'd say an ER doc, so I can be stabilized and flown home to specialists....bc honestly just because your a "general surgeon" doesn't mean you have the expertise to perform a triple bypass, a hip replacement or remove a brain tumor. You cannot be House, there is too much medicine too learn to do it all.
I think this statement is true for the most part, at least for those of us who chose to go into a specialty with longer hours and sicker patients. I remember liking the OR, the SICU, and those quick decisions like, "Do we take him to the OR NOW?" Though at some point I didn't care for what I perceived to be the "culture" or surgery - and as some have pointed out a lot of that was really a product of busy surgery dept. in a large surgery residency at a university teaching hospital. And based on my friends who went into surgery and my surgery resident colleagues it seems to be all about the OR. If none of the other nonsense (which they don't like much either) can outshine that OR experience - if it's all worth those few few hours where you're cutting and tying - then you're probably a surgeon. (I'd add if you like the smell of your own farts and are secretly suspicious [you'd need a placebo controlled RCT, of course, to make sure] they might cure AIDS, you're probably also a surgeon)
And I don't think putting on of today's modern surgeons into a third world country would be good for the surgeon or the patient's there necessarily . . . we've all grown accustomed to all of the technology, bells and whistles, and expert consultation that most of us would be pretty hard pressed working in a third world hut. A lot of "possible" diagnosis without much ability to be able to do anything about it, even a basic open appy in that kind of setting wouldn't be near as "basic" as we've grown accustomed.
tl;dr: You know if you know
Sadly, this is true. I'm hoping to spend some of my vacation time/lab time (if I go into the lab) as a resident going on medical trips with older surgeons who've learned how to work in third world countries where many of our luxuries are missing. Once I'm out in practice, I'll still try to go along with more experienced doctors until I become experienced myself.
Though it would be interesting to hear what could be done and what the minimal amount of support a surgeon needs to do say, appy's, chole's, and hernias in the field.
Apparently can do an appendectomy on yourself in the antarctic:
http://www.bmj.com/content/339/bmj.b4965.full
And I don't think putting on of today's modern surgeons into a third world country would be good for the surgeon or the patient's there necessarily . . . we've all grown accustomed to all of the technology, bells and whistles, and expert consultation that most of us would be pretty hard pressed working in a third world hut. A lot of "possible" diagnosis without much ability to be able to do anything about it, even a basic open appy in that kind of setting wouldn't be near as "basic" as we've grown accustomed.
Well, it's not "as chill as you want it to be," especially because the larger surgery practices aren't that common, so you're on call more, but yes, of course it's usually better than residency in many/most ways.Lifestyle of an attending general surgeon in private practice is as chill or as hard as you want it to be.
PS: to The Prowler, we are probably talking about the same group, CSM hospital?
I enjoy the OR, of course, but I like a lot of other aspects of surgery. I like the types of disease we deal with, the people we interact with, the hospital-based nature of a lot of the work (rather than a strictly clinic-based specialty or a specialty where you're often completely by yourself), the to-the-point nature of surgery with a brief but nuanced physical exam, and I like the people I work with. I like most of the personalities with me in surgery.And based on my friends who went into surgery and my surgery resident colleagues it seems to be all about the OR. If none of the other nonsense (which they don't like much either) can outshine that OR experience - if it's all worth those few few hours where you're cutting and tying - then you're probably a surgeon.
Well, it's not "as chill as you want it to be," especially because the larger surgery practices aren't that common, so you're on call more, but yes, of course it's usually better than residency in many/most ways.
I didn't rotate at CSM, I'm talking about the one way west of the main hospital.
I enjoy the OR, of course, but I like a lot of other aspects of surgery. I like the types of disease we deal with, the people we interact with, the hospital-based nature of a lot of the work (rather than a strictly clinic-based specialty or a specialty where you're often completely by yourself), the to-the-point nature of surgery with a brief but nuanced physical exam, and I like the people I work with. I like most of the personalities with me in surgery.
Everyone expects everyone else to work hard, which is probably the most important thing. We do have a fair number of funny/sarcastic types, and most people swear pretty regularly (staff and residents). Patient presentations need to be short and sweet, but you need to know a lot more details about the patient than what you're presenting (i.e., pertinent positives only).Can you describe the said personalities? I've heard the stereotypes, but I'm curious if they are true. I shadowed a surgeon the this year, and I found him the funniest, sarcastic, yet most intense guy. Totally loves work...and being stressed out.
Apparently can do an appendectomy on yourself in the antarctic:
http://www.bmj.com/content/339/bmj.b4965.full
I've been as anti-surgery as anyone since I started med school, but lately I've been wondering if maybe I like it more than I think I do. There's something very comforting or something about the single-minded focus of a surgeon. In medicine, I feel like you're carrying around a bunch of patients, getting labs for one, results for the other, rounding 100 times a day and re-doing the same thing over and over again...etc. In surgery, at least when you're in the OR, your entire focus is dedicated to that one patient, that one thing you're doing with your hands. I'm kind of ADD so I find learning surgical skills to be a very nice, calming experience for me.
Who knows. Maybe I'll end up being a surgeon.
Apparently can do an appendectomy on yourself in the antarctic:
http://www.bmj.com/content/339/bmj.b4965.full
Apparently can do an appendectomy on yourself in the antarctic:
http://www.bmj.com/content/339/bmj.b4965.full
I love using saws and power tools, hence ortho...
Heavens no!I'm as perplexed as is the OP. Surgery as a medical student sucks so bad. I really don't see what would attract someone to it. Arrogant personalities, lots of cussing and crude behavior, horrible hours, etc. etc.
👍 I like the idea of getting paid to drill someone, so that left me with ortho or adult films. My wife didn't seem to like the latter unfortunately, so here I am...🙄
I garuantee he drinks dos equis... Lol
Heavens no!
god complex
👍 I like the idea of getting paid to drill someone, so that left me with ortho or adult films. My wife didn't seem to like the latter unfortunately, so here I am...🙄
👍 I like the idea of getting paid to drill someone, so that left me with ortho or adult films. My wife didn't seem to like the latter unfortunately, so here I am...🙄
Yeah I am worried act because I want to be a surgeon but I still have another year before I get to step foot in the OR and actually see what its like and I'm hoping I'm going to like it. If not I guess I'll have to do some serious soul searching because I've felt like surgery is always something I wanted to do..the only thing that deters me are the hours/no life but I figure once your out of residency you have a lot more control over that (not that the hours arer going to be easy regardless..but better).
I was the same way as you. Liked surgery a lot, but the sacrifice seemed a little too much.... I can barely function with less than 7 hours of sleep a night, which is not compatible with a life in surgery. I would get home every night at 7, go to sleep at 9 just to make it to the hospital at 530 the next morning. I couldn't live like that for 7 years. That's why IR is dope. You may not be a "surgeon" but you are definitely operating, doing awesome procedures, and get to go through radiology residency instead.
You get to be INSIDE people and get PAID for it (creepy, but true).
matching into porn as a heterosexual male is probably tougher than matching into surgery.![]()
LOL so good.
In all seriousness, do people seriously go into ortho because they enjoy using power tools? That's... interesting. (This is coming from someone who is considering ortho, but mine comes from the satisfaction of doing joint replacements).
They do use lots of cool toys and gadgetry.LOL so good.
In all seriousness, do people seriously go into ortho because they enjoy using power tools? That's... interesting. (This is coming from someone who is considering ortho, but mine comes from the satisfaction of doing joint replacements).