What qualifies as leadership?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

cherrycokeicee

New Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Messages
10
Reaction score
1
Are leadership positions only the executive formal titles of clubs/organizations? I recently just got the position to be a student Ambassador for my school, where I'll be giving tours to prospective students. There are leadership roles within that organization (like the president of the ambassadors) so I'm wondering - does this count as leadership by itself or...?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Are leadership positions only the executive formal titles of clubs/organizations? I recently just got the position to be a student Ambassador for my school, where I'll be giving tours to prospective students. There are leadership roles within that organization (like the president of the ambassadors) so I'm wondering - does this count as leadership by itself or...?
Giving tours to prospective students wouldn't be a leadership role, but being in charge of others who give the tours could be. If you want to call something leadership, be sure you are can give a description of the way in which you led others. Merely being voted into office often doesn't qualify.
 
I believe the rule of thumb is any position where you are taking a forefront role and/or organizing/planning by yourself. This could include anything from tutoring to intra organization positions. Though how you write about it and what you actually do will be much more important than a title; i.e. being the "secretary" of a branch of some club at your college where all you do is take notes at the meetings would probably be viewed less favorably than someone who volunteer tutors ESL learners and has to make their own lesson plans for said student. Despite this comparison, the title of "secretary" probably is seemingly more impressive than "tutor," when the reality is quite different.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I believe the rule of thumb is any position where you are taking a forefront role and/or organizing/planning by yourself. This could include anything from tutoring to intra organization positions. Though how you write about it and what you actually do will be much more important than a title; i.e. being the "secretary" of a branch of some club at your college where all you do is take notes at the meetings would probably be viewed less favorably than someone who volunteer tutors ESL learners and has to make their own lesson plans for said student. Despite this comparison, the title of "secretary" probably is seemingly more impressive than "tutor," when the reality is quite different.
While volunteering as a tutor is admirable and demonstrates many positive qualities, I do not see tutoring in and of itself as being an example of leadership. At the collegiate level, being a leader most often involves organizing a team of your peers to accomplish a mutual goal.

An example of leadership would be a student who is the head tutor for a department, organizing and facilitating the schedules for other student tutors. You are correct though that simply holding a fancy title means nothing without the deeds to back it up. Just my thoughts.
 
Are leadership positions only the executive formal titles of clubs/organizations? I recently just got the position to be a student Ambassador for my school, where I'll be giving tours to prospective students. There are leadership roles within that organization (like the president of the ambassadors) so I'm wondering - does this count as leadership by itself or...?
For the purposes of medical school application, leadership usually means you have taken a substantial oversight/management role in an organization. If you have to question whether or not you are in an oversight/management role then you are almost certainly not in an oversight/management role.

It is also fairly common for applicants to start new organizations and endeavors that involve other people. This would also qualify.
 
While volunteering as a tutor is admirable and demonstrates many positive qualities, I do not see tutoring in and of itself as being an example of leadership. At the collegiate level, being a leader most often involves organizing a team of your peers to accomplish a mutual goal.

An example of leadership would be a student who is the head tutor for a department, organizing and facilitating the schedules for other student tutors. You are correct though that simply holding a fancy title means nothing without the deeds to back it up. Just my thoughts.
Oops, my bad. I guess it must depend on the school. Georgetown's md website classifies tutoring under leadership; my undergrad's med school info session also has that classification.
 
Giving tours to prospective students wouldn't be a leadership role, but being in charge of others who give the tours could be. If you want to call something leadership, be sure you are can give a description of the way in which you led others. Merely being voted into office often doesn't qualify.
Thank you so much, this helps a lot. What about being a mentor to freshman college students? I am really lacking leadership and trying to find activities that I would enjoy, but I feel like a lot of them are just non-clinical volunteering instead of leadership haha. But the peer mentor thing is with my honors college at school, and we can mentor groups of freshman as they adjust to college. There is also a mental health ambassador position I recently got where I will help with outreach events with my school and possibly come up with new ideas for these, but again, I feel like this is just non-clinical volunteering. Thank you so much for responding though, your feedback has been very insightful!
 
Thank you so much, this helps a lot. What about being a mentor to freshman college students? I am really lacking leadership and trying to find activities that I would enjoy, but I feel like a lot of them are just non-clinical volunteering instead of leadership haha. But the peer mentor thing is with my honors college at school, and we can mentor groups of freshman as they adjust to college. There is also a mental health ambassador position I recently got where I will help with outreach events with my school and possibly come up with new ideas for these, but again, I feel like this is just non-clinical volunteering. Thank you so much for responding though, your feedback has been very insightful!
A lot of the big organizations usually have leadership positions that are pretty easy to get once you have volunteered with them for a few months. Off the top of my head, the Red Cross has plenty, like vaccination ambassadors, where you oversee the vaccine drives. I'm not an AO but the mental health ambassador position definitely sounds like leadership to me.
 
What about being a mentor to freshman college students? I am really lacking leadership and trying to find activities that I would enjoy, but I feel like a lot of them are just non-clinical volunteering instead of leadership haha. But the peer mentor thing is with my honors college at school, and we can mentor groups of freshman as they adjust to college. There is also a mental health ambassador position I recently got where I will help with outreach events with my school and possibly come up with new ideas for these, but again, I feel like this is just non-clinical volunteering. Thank you so much for responding though, your feedback has been very insightful!
Mentoring is another form of teaching. If you manage/train/take responsibility for the efforts of other mentors, that would be a form of leadership.

I agree with your thoughts on the Ambassadorship.
 
Mentoring is another form of teaching. If you manage/train/take responsibility for the efforts of other mentors, that would be a form of leadership.

I agree with your thoughts on the Ambassadorship.
so just to clarify even the mental health ambassador is just volunteering? within that position I have the opportunity to come up with ideas for outreach events or possibly leading specific outreach events, so I would hope that that might qualify in the sense that I can use my position to, say, lead a particular event for mental health and student athletes, things like that. so essentially the position might not be leadership by itself but the things I can do within the position, like planning my own outreach event, might show initiative? I know the student ambassador is for sure just volunteering because I'm just doing tours, but I was hoping I can use the mental health ambassador for a form of leadership. again, thank you so much for your input!
 
so just to clarify even the mental health ambassador is just volunteering? within that position I have the opportunity to come up with ideas for outreach events or possibly leading specific outreach events, so I would hope that that might qualify in the sense that I can use my position to, say, lead a particular event for mental health and student athletes, things like that. so essentially the position might not be leadership by itself but the things I can do within the position, like planning my own outreach event, might show initiative? I know the student ambassador is for sure just volunteering because I'm just doing tours, but I was hoping I can use the mental health ambassador for a form of leadership. again, thank you so much for your input!
If you come up with a new initiative and direct other students to implement the plan (for outreach, fundraising, or whatever), that would be leadership, whether it comes with an impressive title or not.
 
Would being a full-time teacher count as leadership? Particularly if one writes their own lessons plans and manages their classrooms independently?
 
Top