- Joined
- Aug 6, 2007
- Messages
- 58
- Reaction score
- 0
Will both degrees enable you to practice medicine? Why do more peopel on here want M.D rather than DO?
Will both degrees enable you to practice medicine?
Why do more peopel on here want M.D rather than DO?
Will both degrees enable you to practice medicine? Why do more peopel on here want M.D rather than DO?
Will both degrees enable you to practice medicine? Why do more peopel on here want M.D rather than DO?
DOs make about 15% more than MD's while practicing the same medicine.![]()
Do you have evidence to back up this claim?
Do you have evidence to back up this claim?
Will both degrees enable you to practice medicine? Why do more peopel on here want M.D rather than DO?
After more than a century of often bitterly contentious relationships between the osteopathic and allopathic medical professions, we now find ourselves living at a time when osteopathic and allopathic graduates are both sought after by many of the same residency programs; are in most instances both licensed by the same licensing boards; are both privileged by many of the same hospitals; and are found in appreciable numbers on the faculties of each other's medical schools.
Jordan J. Cohen, M.D.; AAMC President
DOs make about 15% more than MD's while practicing the same medicine.![]()
Interestingly enough, I just asked my dentist that very question a couple of weeks ago. Good analogy (from the very little I know about the two degrees).
Are there any special procedures for someone graduating from a school of osteopathic medicine who wishes to do a residency at an allopathic-affiliated residency program? In other words, can a DO graduate apply for every single residency that a MD graduate can apply for?
Are there any special procedures for someone graduating from a school of osteopathic medicine who wishes to do a residency at an allopathic-affiliated residency program? In other words, can a DO graduate apply for every single residency that a MD graduate can apply for?
I think you have to take the USMLEs in addition to the COMLEX but I could be wrong.
It would be wise.
congrats on >3000 posts.
Taking the USMLE is not a necessity, but there are allo programs that "prefer" you take the USMLE (as in if you don't they won't really look at you). The number of programs that will take either exam are increasing. I would recommend you contact every residency program you are interested in and asking them if USMLE is necessary or they will accept COMLEX.
Why, thank you.🙂
Now, I have to get back to work. The number of pages that I need to read are also increasing; quite rapidly, in fact.![]()
![]()
One thing is certain: osteopathic, or allopathic, philosophy difference, or whatnot, it's all medical school. And I'll tell you, who ever said that MS1 is like taking a drink out of a fire hose is dead right. I'm struggling to keep up here and it's only been the first few days.
Good luck everyone. 🙂
In all honesty, and this is not one of those DO versus MD flame wars.
I seriously considered DO because I have relatively low GPA (3.5), but at the end of the day, I selected to only apply to MD schools for the following reasons:
1) I do not believe in most of the DO-specific techniques. Rearrange skull bones to cure diseases? I just cannot bring myself to believe in that, and would not want to spend time learning how to do it.
2) MD schools typically have higher calibered students. I just think I will meet more people with similar personality and lifestyle at an MD school.
3) I don't want to have to explain what a DO is to all my Asian relatives (shallow reason, I know).
4) I am not interested in primary care. While you can match into specialties from a DO school, the DO philosophy favors primary care.
I guess at the end of the day, I felt that if I were to apply DO, I would only be using it as a backup. I lacked real reasons to WANT to be a DO instead of an MD. I just felt that my attitudes were unfair to those who actually want to be a DO, and I thought not applying would allow those who truly prefer a DO degree to have a better chance of getting in.
Ego.
Why do they pursue a DO degree if they do not believe in crianial manipulation?
The best DO schools are better than quite a few MD schools, and the DO match lists are typically fairly impressive. When it comes to medical schools and residency, going to a particular school provides you with resources but what you get out of it is determined by the individual.
So why pursue an education that teaches quite a few things that you never plan on practicing?
How many DO doctors actually practice cranial manipulation out of school? Why spend the extra hours on that when you could spend it, I don't know, kayaking?
Why do they pursue a DO degree if they do not believe in crianial manipulation?
The best DO schools are better than quite a few MD schools, and the DO match lists are typically fairly impressive. When it comes to medical schools and residency, going to a particular school provides you with resources but what you get out of it is determined by the individual.
So why pursue an education that teaches quite a few things that you never plan on practicing?
How many DO doctors actually practice cranial manipulation out of school? Why spend the extra hours on that when you could spend it, I don't know, kayaking?
In all honesty, and this is not one of those DO versus MD flame wars.
I seriously considered DO because I have relatively low GPA (3.5), but at the end of the day, I selected to only apply to MD schools for the following reasons:
1) I do not believe in most of the DO-specific techniques. Rearrange skull bones to cure diseases? I just cannot bring myself to believe in that, and would not want to spend time learning how to do it.
2) MD schools typically have higher calibered students. I just think I will meet more people with similar personality and lifestyle at an MD school.
3) I don't want to have to explain what a DO is to all my Asian relatives (shallow reason, I know).
4) I am not interested in primary care. While you can match into specialties from a DO school, the DO philosophy favors primary care.
I guess at the end of the day, I felt that if I were to apply DO, I would only be using it as a backup. I lacked real reasons to WANT to be a DO instead of an MD. I just felt that my attitudes were unfair to those who actually want to be a DO, and I thought not applying would allow those who truly prefer a DO degree to have a better chance of getting in.
LOL Kayaking... 👍
Suggesting you'd meet "higher caliber" people in an allopathic school is pure malarkey. I've been there (research capacity) and the grass always appears greener on the other side, especially to pre-meds who don't really know the ins-and-outs of medicine (i.e. you). That was a really ridiculous bullet, IMO.
You're right on one thing: A number of osteopathic schools are better than some of the allopathic schools. This is the reason a large majority of us rank schools the way we do and have no qualms about osteopathic or allopathic medicine when compared. I know MDs who practice different forms of medicine, including accupuncture. It's up to the individual as to what they - and their patients, see as effective. We are all physicians and there is no need for such a divisive perspective from either side. The sparks are typically fanned by pre-meds who have no real idea about medicine and frankly, make the same assumptions that you did in your original, obviously mis-informed post. Anybody who has an real foresight or is actually on the "other side" (practicing) knows that this competitive bull**** between the disciplines is unfounded and the result of ignorant pre-meds.
The inherent problem with you not wanting to explain to your family about DOs is probably sheer laziness or insecurity. I know about the pressures of family and how they can be set in their ways but most of it is pure ignorance on their part and YOU can educate them if that type of thing is actually important to you. But first, you must educate yourself on medicine without compartmentalizing DO/MD. Don't buy stock in all the pre-conceived notions and pre-med misbeliefs; be your own man.
As far as the cranial therapy, there are benefits to manipulation of the skull but not insofar as "moving the bones", IMHO - but I'm not qualified to make any real assumption here. I think cranial manipulation is somewhat of a mischaracterization of what OMM is all about as it relates to the larger picture. There are many debates and there is a considerable amount of research money (millions) being dumped into TCOM (Texas) for OMM research. Put it this way, OMM is MUCH more than just cranial.
I think I'll defer to JPHazleton who could respond to your OMM inquiry. He's a surgeon who uses OMT and knowledgeable on the subject.
For the record, I also agree with BTH7's response.
Oh I agree with you that much of the reasons of not wanting to explain to my family what a DO is stems of insecurities. DO is a relatively unknown branch of medicine, and I've never personally met a DO, which may contribute to my ignorance.
As for "higher caliber", I apologize for that phrasing. I just meant that most MD schools have much higher averages. Growing up in a background where most of my peers averaged 1500 SATs and 34+ MCATs, I'm not sure if I will fit in well into a DO school.
BTH7 I really appreciate your response by the way. You two had taught me that I don't know, well, jack, about OMM. It doesn't make me want to learn it really, but it did teach me that I should not speak ill of something I don't know.
As I said in my original post, I didn't mean to make a post bashing DO, or to start a flame war. I was merely listing my personal reasons for not wanting to apply to a DO. In the end, I just feel like there is no compelling reason for me to go DO instead of MD.
DOs know how to use google
DOs know how to use google
Wikipedia: Comparison of allopathic and osteopathic medicine
recent thread discussing this topic: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=429376
bth
DOs know how to use google
actually DO's use Yahoo, although some use the outdated lycos search engine and some use alta vista
Reasons why I want to be a D.O. over an M.D.
1. I don't suffer from a low GPA
2. I'm assuming my MCAT, soon to be scored, will be around a 32 or so
3. I'm applying to both MD and DO just to prove I can get into both but will choose DO anyways
4. Their DO symbol is the rod of Ascelpius vs MD's caduceus.
5. I like to be different
6. DO schools are nearer to me
7. I like vowels
8. I like to prove people wrong so by being a better physician, coming from a DO background, to an MD physician.
9. Less competition in school for higher rankings.
10. Somewhat better pick up line than an MD requiring more talking.😎
I got into many schools for undergraduate including UCLA, USC, Berkeley, JHU, etc but chose UCSD so I can have a higher GPA while still receiving a good education.
It's all about compromise. 😀
Reasons why I want to be a D.O. over an M.D.
1. I don't suffer from a low GPA
2. I'm assuming my MCAT, soon to be scored, will be around a 32 or so
3. I'm applying to both MD and DO just to prove I can get into both but will choose DO anyways
4. Their DO symbol is the rod of Ascelpius vs MD's caduceus.
5. I like to be different
6. DO schools are nearer to me
7. I like vowels
8. I like to prove people wrong so by being a better physician, coming from a DO background, to an MD physician.
9. Less competition in school for higher rankings.
10. Somewhat better pick up line than an MD requiring more talking.😎
I got into many schools for undergraduate including UCLA, USC, Berkeley, JHU, etc but chose UCSD so I can have a higher GPA while still receiving a good education.
It's all about compromise. 😀
In all honesty, and this is not one of those DO versus MD flame wars.
I seriously considered DO because I have relatively low GPA (3.5), but at the end of the day, I selected to only apply to MD schools for the following reasons:
1) I do not believe in most of the DO-specific techniques. Rearrange skull bones to cure diseases? I just cannot bring myself to believe in that, and would not want to spend time learning how to do it.
2) MD schools typically have higher calibered students. I just think I will meet more people with similar personality and lifestyle at an MD school.
3) I don't want to have to explain what a DO is to all my Asian relatives (shallow reason, I know).
4) I am not interested in primary care. While you can match into specialties from a DO school, the DO philosophy favors primary care.
I guess at the end of the day, I felt that if I were to apply DO, I would only be using it as a backup. I lacked real reasons to WANT to be a DO instead of an MD. I just felt that my attitudes were unfair to those who actually want to be a DO, and I thought not applying would allow those who truly prefer a DO degree to have a better chance of getting in.
You are a shallow person; I'm glad you made everyone aware of that.
Yeah, let's just let this thread die, folks. Let me be the last to post in it.
Resist the urge!!!!!! You can do it!!!![]()