Same! If our exams were essay based rather than multiple choice, I think I would have done better in vet school didactics overall.
Having done both methods of testing-- exam based/verbal/short answer exams and multiple choice exams, there are definitely pros/cons to each.
It is hard to compare which one I did "better" at since the grading systems are so vastly different in the UK and the US, but I can say I felt less overall stress with the frequent, multiple choice US exams than I did with the giant essay based/short answer exams in the UK. However, by the time I was taking US tests I was in third year so I had gotten somewhat adjusted to the stress too.
Let me add in that that elephant estrus question was one of 8 essay questions with each of the 8 essay questions having 10-12 follow us short answer questions and two of the questions required you to plot out graphs. This exam was over material from the entire semester across multiple courses and subject material (this wasn't just an exam on therio), outside of one short quiz that was worth 10% of your grade for all courses/subject material this was the only exam you had to test you on everything taught over the entire semester, if you failed, you failed the course and have to re-take the exam. You only had two hours to take the exam and with 15 minutes remaining of the exam, you were only 50% of the way through so you didn't even finish said exam. That exam gave me some PTSD, I think many of my classmates and I have some serious emotional scars from that exam.
That was how all semesters were in the UK, one exam to cover all material from the semester and topics were all combined together. You didn't get just a therio exam-- you got therio, immunology, cardiology, endocrinology, orthopedics, soft tissue surgery, ophthalmology, think of an ology it was on the exam. There is a different stress level when you only get one chance to show you have mastered the material taught.
Whereas, it seemed to me, the frequent US exams with multiple choice were simpler because it was such a limited amount of material--- here is your one exam on ophthalmology oh and only the stuff that was covered in the two weeks prior to this date. Such a small amount of information. I will say the biggest con to MCQ tests is there is no way to explain your thought process/how you came to an answer which is so beneficial and nice with the essay based short answer question tests.
There is probably some nice middle ground between these two testing methods that really would be best for testing knowledge.