ACL surgery is considered to be one of the surgeries that most general orthops should be able to do. more important than the surgery is the rehab and rehab protocol. most cities have very good to great sports (acl) surgeons. you should ask who is the guy/girl locally.
then names mentioned are nationally recognized names. if you want name and centers of the who's who in sport medicine, here are some.
Fu (Pitt)
Bach (Rush)
Wjotys (Michigan)
Harner (Pitt)
Matava (Wash U.)
Andrews (Andrew/clancy center)
Warren, wickiwicz (HSS)
i could keep going, but i don't thing it is the point. the surgery is simple. there are some controversies, double bundle vs single bundle, rehab protocols, graft types, etc. that is why you go to the centers or if you get paid millions of dollars. for the average joe, it is probably not necessary.