Wonderful.....

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

FutureDoc4

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
595
Reaction score
2
Would you perform surgery on someone you weren't responsible for and risk a malpractice lawsuit while not getting paid?
 
I agree, (maybe I wasn't coming across right)... I think it is ridiculous they are making out that doctor to be a bad guy because he wouldn't perform the surgery (and they had to mention how much money he made... making him seem as evil and greedy as possible)
 
Like most news, there is an unsurprising lack of information about the physician or the situation.
 
yeah...we really don't know much from that article.

i guess it's better than an article about a doctor screwing up someone's noggin because he didn't know the case.
 
Chiari malformations are not life threatening. Brain surgery on a patient you aren't familiar with, however...
 
yeah...we really don't know much from that article.

i guess it's better than an article about a doctor screwing up someone's noggin because he didn't know the case.



Do you mean to say that a surgeon that gets paid over 7 mill/year can't just walk into an OR and perform a surgery? I mean the patient was already under and THEIR HEAD WAS SHAVED! Half the work was already done if you think about it, the surgeon just needed to go in, cut and close. :laugh:
 
That is a highly-****ty article. Did the neurosurgeon who was supposed to do this just not show up, so they paged the on-call neurosurgeon, or a faculty member who happened to be there that day, to see if he'd come down and do it? Without any prior knowledge of why the patient was even there?

The neurosurgeon who teaches our neuro course gives me the impression that there is a lot of thought and planning that goes into any kind of brain surgery he does. It's not like doing an appy.
 
The neurosurgeon who teaches our neuro course gives me the impression that there is a lot of thought and planning that goes into any kind of brain surgery he does.

The Chiari Institute is pretty legendary for deciding that everyone who walks in the door has some degree of malformation and ABSOLUTELY NEEDS their $15,000+ (and that's the surgeon bill only) operation. The place is a cash cow; I don't know any other neurosurgeons who make more than $1-2mil.

The guy, to be fair, could do a decompression in 30 seconds after looking at the patient's MRI.
 
The guy, to be fair, could do a decompression in 30 seconds after looking at the patient's MRI.

I'm sure he could, but the bigger point is, would you want to be the patient and wake up to find out that your operation was performed by someone who could have been Dr. Nick Riviera and not the guy you MET who said he was going to do it?
 
I'd sure be pissed if I woke up from brain surgery with Dr. Nick
 
The Chiari Institute is pretty legendary for deciding that everyone who walks in the door has some degree of malformation and ABSOLUTELY NEEDS their $15,000+ (and that's the surgeon bill only) operation. The place is a cash cow; I don't know any other neurosurgeons who make more than $1-2mil.

Yup. They will take the world's most miniscule anatomic variant, call it a Chiari malformation, convince the patient that it is the cause of all their problems in life (for a $1000+ consultation fee, of course), and then operate on them.
 
I agree, (maybe I wasn't coming across right)... I think it is ridiculous they are making out that doctor to be a bad guy because he wouldn't perform the surgery (and they had to mention how much money he made... making him seem as evil and greedy as possible)

Agree. Also, why was the patient anesthetized if his surgeon was not there. At all the hospitals I've ever worked at, the surgeon has to be in the room or scrubbing before anesthesia will put the patient down... sound kinda fishy to me.
 
Great, now I have Adam Ant stuck in my head, and I've got a neuro final coming up. Wonderful.
 
[/b]


Do you mean to say that a surgeon that gets paid over 7 mill/year can't just walk into an OR and perform a surgery? I mean the patient was already under and THEIR HEAD WAS SHAVED! Half the work was already done if you think about it, the surgeon just needed to go in, cut and close. :laugh:

Lol above. It is really unclear to me what the point of the article was supposed to be. Patient still recieves surgery at a time later than he had originally anticipated! Groundbreaking journalism, folks. Plus, the headline made it seem as though the patient had been left alone. Like all the techs and nurses noticed that the boss hadn't come in and decided to knock off for the day.

"The patient is asleep, so he'll never know we didn't operate!"

Followed by:

"Curses, our plan to abandon this patient was foiled by investigative journalism! Now no one will ever have to wait for or reschedule an operation again! Damn you and your investigative journalism, Comcast.net!"
 
He can't compete with this guy.


[youtube]mSt1m4NFUl8[/youtube]
I want to hear him say "I will grant you your request on this, the day of my daughter's wedding."

Also, check out the shakes on that bitch, I wouldn't want him anywhere near my brain.
 
One of the highest-paid doctors in New York refused to perform brain surgery on an already-anesthetized patient whose scheduled surgeon had failed to show up, and the state health department is investigating.

How is this news? How did this "journalist" pitch this opening line to his editor? "Dude! A patient didn't get surgery today! There was some confusion, you think it'll play?"

The suspensions expired this week, but neither Milhorat nor Bolognese have commented because they are attending a medical conference in Italy. Neither physician has responded to an e-mail request for comment.

Haha....you emailed them asking for a comment? From Comcast? And what's the point of mentioning the conference in Italy, you're implying one of two options: 1) you should have KNOWN that they were out of the country before emailing them (and you should be frankly ashamed of yourself for sending a stupid email), or 2) if you're trying to say they're off galavanting on fabulous vacations instead of answering the heinous charges of not performing non-emergent surgery on someone (while refusing to investigate and report the circumstances surrounding the event, and which happens nearly every day in every hospital in the country for legitimate reasons), you probably should have done more than email them.

Claire Pospisil, a spokeswoman for the state Health Department, confirmed the situation was being investigated.

Oh yeah? How many "situations" are investigated by the health department every year? How many are run-of-the-mill nothing happened everyone keep working outcomes? And what role did you media slugs have in spurring that investigation?

The unidentified patient was under anesthesia, head shaved, but the 48-year-old Bolognese could not be found, the Daily News of New York reported on Wednesday, citing sources it did not identify.

Okay...we have absolutely no information about why the surgeon couldn't be found, which could have been an emergency, and we have no information about why they anesthetized the patient without having contacted the surgeon first.

Staffers contacted Milhorat, who refused to do the surgery because the woman was not his patient.

Uh...duh? I wouldn't do it either. Um...you're telling me that her surgeon can't be found and you are realizing someone screwed up by anesthetizing the patient before confirming the surgeon wasn't there, and now you want me to do this lady's non-emergent brain surgery without any knowledge of her case, under time pressure (since she's already under anesthesia), without ever having spoken to her or seen her before, let alone done my own history & physical and interpreted her imaging studies because it's my ass on the line? I don't ****ing think so. How dare this "journalist" imply that the surgeon was out of line. "...refused to do the surgery because the woman was not his patient." You're vilifying him and pretending that he's some egocentric greedy selfish doctor.

A North Shore spokesman said the woman later had successful surgery.

How is this story news again?

Crain's New York, a leading business publication, identified Milhorat and Bolognese as among the New York City area's top medical earners in 2007, with Milhorat taking in $7.2 million and Bolognese earning $2.4 million.
They help run North Shore's Chiari Institute, which draws patients worldwide who have a rare congenital brain defect that can cause headaches, dizziness and other pain. It wasn't clear whether the woman whose surgery was canceled had the condition.
Dr. Lawrence Smith, chief medical officer for the North Shore-LIJ Health System, said in a statement that Milhorat "is widely regarded as one of the world's foremost experts on Chiari malformation, and his surgical expertise has benefitted thousands of patients around the world."
Milhorat joined the North Shore-LIJ Health System in 2002 and has been practicing medicine since 1961.

This guy's all over the place. I have no idea what he's legitimately trying to imply, there's nothing to imply here. He's overpaid? Well, you just made reference to his extensive qualifications and involvement in numerous medical institutes and is CHAIRMAN of the neurosurgery department at the hospital. Come on.

This "journalist" should be ashamed of himself.
 
Every day, I grow closer and closer to taking my joke about specializing in hair transplants, and turning it into reality.
 
Top