WW Basic B's Game

[deleted867257]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I like Frosty's point -
@MixedAnimals77 why AM over Nav who brought mylo up first?

Agree with you and paws.
The mylo point is weak and supposed to be supported by an even weaker point of snark? Although I didn’t read all of last game, seemed like it’s pretty normal for AM.
Maybe to push her more, but then to say re-evaluation will happen if play improves? In what way does AM play need to be improved? I think the specific mention of mylo by mod threw people off and needed to be addressed. Personally, I needed clarification.. didn’t know what mylo was
The thought that it’s because it’s D1 and not everyone has checked in yet, has crossed my mind. But wouldn’t want to start a wagon on someone for just that reason.
Also may just be mixy analysis attempt to start convo and get the game rolling. Reasoning still a bit suspect though.

 

[Coopah]

Quick PSA

For our Twoose hydra @mypetmoose will be the player posting on thread. HOWEVER, if MPM is unavailable or busy we are allowing @Miranda Senft to place/change lynch votes on thread, but she will not be allowed to comment otherwise.

Lol I was literally going to be like wtf moose I see those likes why are you lurking... oh

 

[PippyPony]

Why does this make her a lynch target? Lynch pip

Yeah lol, also thought about lynching pip but decided Mixy jumped on the thought process. Though Mixy was much more invested so did consider pips as more shade...

You know, it is sometimes a bummer for me when I realize the art of subtlety has been somewhat lost.

I will shade the both of you though -- as of this morning, I was the only player generating discussion. You're going to lynch the only person who is asking people questions so far? The person who actually drove the things you're now commenting on?

And, a person who just modded two games for you, no less? (Not like that should get me a lot of freebies but I thought it might buy me like, an afternoon, you freeloaders).

 

[PippyPony]

You take one I'll take the other

View attachment 267355

No.

 

[Coopah]

You know, it is sometimes a bummer for me when I realize the art of subtlety has been somewhat lost.

I will shade the both of you though -- as of this morning, I was the only player generating discussion. You're going to lynch the only person who is asking people questions so far? The person who actually drove the things you're now commenting on?

And, a person who just modded two games for you, no less? (Not like that should get me a lot of freebies but I thought it might buy me like, an afternoon, you freeloaders).

Thanks for the guilt trip, but this seems like an overreaction and something I will keep in mind. It's one lynch vote, you modded the last few games so politeness indicates you shouldn't be lynched. That doesn't mean we shouldn't talk about how you're sketchy or place a vote to see what you'd do.

 

[PippyPony]

Thanks for the guilt trip, but this seems like an overreaction and something I will keep in mind. It's one lynch vote, you modded the last few games so politeness indicates you shouldn't be lynched. That doesn't mean we shouldn't talk about how you're sketchy or place a vote to see what you'd do.

Where am I overreacting?

 

[Coopah]

You know, it is sometimes a bummer for me when I realize the art of subtlety has been somewhat lost.

I will shade the both of you though -- as of this morning, I was the only player generating discussion. You're going to lynch the only person who is asking people questions so far? The person who actually drove the things you're now commenting on?

And, a person who just modded two games for you, no less? (Not like that should get me a lot of freebies but I thought it might buy me like, an afternoon, you freeloaders).

Over one lynch vote and one or two other comments = overreaction to me

 

[Coopah]

As something else I didn't like:

You know, it is sometimes a bummer for me when I realize the art of subtlety has been somewhat lost.

I will shade the both of you though -- as of this morning, I was the only player generating discussion. You're going to lynch the only person who is asking people questions so far? The person who actually drove the things you're now commenting on?

And, a person who just modded two games for you, no less? (Not like that should get me a lot of freebies but I thought it might buy me like, an afternoon, you freeloaders).

This morning the game literally just started and in PST lol no way was I going to be on before you. Why does it sound like you're trying to claim village cred for talking?

Ok I'll stop now, I promise I'm not harassing you on purpose

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Ew Pippy are grumpy and snarky gonna be synonymous here? Don’t make me hold back on my snark levels.

Please don’t hold back the snark! 😉

 

[deleted867257]

Yeah lol, also thought about lynching pip but decided Mixy jumped on the thought process. Though Mixy was much more invested so did consider pips as more shade...

Thought about Mixy and Pip as well. Both I think are fair to be looking at right now.

 

[Coopah]

Please don’t hold back the snark! 😉

hi Mizzy!

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

******lynch Mixy******
Seems to be participating quite a bit more than normal at this point.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

hi Mizzy!

Good morning!

 

[PippyPony]

Over one lynch vote and one or two other comments = overreaction to me

Yes, I understand you think it's an overreaction. Maybe I should ask this way -- what do you think is a more "regular reaction" way for me to say I think your reasoning is poor/lazy? At what point does a response cross from reaction to overreaction?

 

[Coopah]

******lynch Mixy******
Seems to be participating quite a bit more than normal at this point.

Wait you're lynching her for participating more?

 

[Coopah]

Yes, I understand you think it's an overreaction. Maybe I should ask this way -- what do you think is a more "regular reaction" way for me to say I think your reasoning is poor/lazy? At what point does a response cross from reaction to overreaction?

When you respond with just the first bit, no guilt trip or extra shade thrown

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Wait you're lynching her for participating more?

Her participation amount is against my meta for her. It’s day 1 so I’m taking what I can get

 

[PippyPony]

As something else I didn't like:

This morning the game literally just started and in PST lol no way was I going to be on before you. Why does it sound like you're trying to claim village cred for talking?

Because I am claiming village cred for talking. I should get village cred for activities like generating real discussion lol

 

[PippyPony]

When you respond with just the first bit, no guilt trip or extra shade thrown

Ah I see. I am sorry for making you already feel guilty about your bad lynch vote then 😉

 

[StartingoverVet]

I think AM is being a bit snarky and aggressive, but I think that every game, so biz as usual.
Pippy was a bit sensitive, but I also find that normal after modding.

Mixed is too defensive, so...

Unlynch the plant Lynch mixed.

 

[Coopah]

Ah I see. I am sorry for making you already feel guilty about your bad lynch vote then 😉

You have such creative interpretations

Because I am claiming village cred for talking. I should get village cred for activities like generating real discussion lol

Except you didn't. Otherwise I'd be able to claim cred for every discussion about me being sketchy. I know you'll disagree but that's ok. We'll agree to disagree

 

[Coopah]

I think AM is being a bit snarky and aggressive, but I think that every game, so biz as usual.
Pippy was a bit sensitive, but I also find that normal after modding.

Mixed is too defensive, so...

Unlynch the plant Lynch mixed.

the plant?
Edit NVM he meant BBC lol

 

[MixedAnimals77]

What's the day before or two days before mylo in this game?

We have numbers this game so we could figure it out when closer. Just seems odd coming from you D1.

Ah ok. So you meant you will reevaluate your own vote for her, not reevaluate how you feel about her voting for Allie? Am I understanding that correctly?


But as a follow up... Do you think her game play so far is not sound?

Correct not the vote for allie

Also who starts a game at 4am lol.

lynch Mixy

AMs snark level is similar to last two games, vill both times so no idea what you are talking about

Why wouldn't we clarify rules D1?

Nav clarified I didnt really see AMs post I quoted as clarification.

Interesting that you say "you" instead of including yourself in that discussion

You as a general you potatoes potatos. Come on paws I think you can do better than that. I say wolfy dumb stuff all the time. Hence why I end up dead early most times. The few times I live long enough wolves kept me around as an easy lynch.

******lynch Mixy******
Seems to be participating quite a bit more than normal at this point.

Meh. I had some time this morning. I can push and nudge or be slightly more aggressive. Your base is also only 1 game so NIA. Go find the one where I was working nights and you'll understand

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Ah ok. So you meant you will reevaluate your own vote for her, not reevaluate how you feel about her voting for Allie? Am I understanding that correctly?


But as a follow up... Do you think her game play so far is not sound?

Sorry my phone is being dumb. To answer the second question. I think it has been good so far which is what is making me skeptical and when I get home tonight off mobile will be able to go back through.

 

[Coopah]

Village will have 3 power roles:
1 Protector
1 Blocker
1 Gossip
Protector and Blocker are as usual.
Gossip will be allowed to open a PM with 1 person each night which will remain open until lynch close the following day.

Just realized the gossip will essentially clear themselves to everyone they talk to. They should tell the last person they spoke with who they will speak with next so the wolves will have to be careful when they find the gossip not to kill them right away

 

[Coopah]

Sorry my phone is being dumb. To answer the second question. I think it has been good so far which is what is making me skeptical and when I get home tonight off mobile will be able to go back through.

What? Could you elaborate please? You think her play has been good and that's sketchy?

 

[PippyPony]

Thought about Mixy and Pip as well. Both I think are fair to be looking at right now.

This is a great example of noise bias.

Players who talk a lot in early game often get read as sketchy, because they are more prominent and therefore top of mind.

Be careful to consider people for what they post, not how much they are showing up on the page.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Also who starts a game at 4am lol.

lynch Mixy

AMs snark level is similar to last two games, vill both times so no idea what you are talking about

Also didnt play last game and died super early the game before and then I dont pay attention and it's been a long time since I've played. Like I said when I get off work and get home to computer I'll go back and reevaluate

 

[MixedAnimals77]

What? Could you elaborate please? You think her play has been good and that's sketchy?

No. I think her play so far has been good hence my skepticism that she is a wolf. I felt the mylo thing is out if character for her hence my original lynch.

 

[PippyPony]

Sorry my phone is being dumb. To answer the second question. I think it has been good so far which is what is making me skeptical and when I get home tonight off mobile will be able to go back through.

For example, @FrostySparrow (and @Coopah and @StayingPositive2017 since they have apparently forgotten how this works), the second sentence here doesn't make a lot of sense for a villager to say, and we might not have had this comment if I didn't push for clarification.

 

[Coopah]

No. I think her play so far has been good hence my skepticism that she is a wolf. I felt the mylo thing is out if character for her hence my original lynch.

Oh! Well to give you context then since you've been away, Mylo has been discussed a few times the past few games and AM is a big lover of it, and I don't think it's very much out of character for her. So I respectfully disagree with your assessment but I can see where you're coming from now

 

[Coopah]

For example, @FrostySparrow (and @Coopah and @StayingPositive2017 since they have apparently forgotten how this works), the second sentence here doesn't make a lot of sense for a villager to say, and we might not have had this comment if I didn't push for clarification.

JFC why are you trying to take credit for paws pushing to get more answers? You asked for clarification once or twice a few hours ago, everything that happens after the fact you don't also get credit for.

Edit: and you as a wolf can definitely be pushing for clarification to throw shade and/or to look more like your village self. Stop insinuating we're stupid for thinking you're a wolf

 

[PippyPony]

Unofficial D1 Do These Votes Make Me Look Fat? Lynch Tally

Fern () -
AM (2) - pippy, mixalot
Allie (1) - AM
Ms P (1) - Barks
Mixalot (4) - Frosty, paws, Miz, SOV
Pip (1) - Coop

9/16 voting

Lynch close at 10 PM EST

 

[PippyPony]

JFC why are you trying to take credit for paws pushing to get more answers? You asked for clarification once or twice a few hours ago, everything that happens after the fact you don't also get credit for.

You mean where I pushed for more answers? 😉

 

[deleted867257]

We have numbers this game so we could figure it out when closer. Just seems odd coming from you D1.



Correct not the vote for allie







Nav clarified I didnt really see AMs post I quoted as clarification.



You as a general you potatoes potatos. Come on paws I think you can do better than that. I say wolfy dumb stuff all the time. Hence why I end up dead early most times. The few times I live long enough wolves kept me around as an easy lynch.



Meh. I had some time this morning. I can push and nudge or be slightly more aggressive. Your base is also only 1 game so NIA. Go find the one where I was working nights and you'll understand

Can you elaborate why you didn’t feel AM was clarifying? What specifically seemed sketch to you in AM posts regarding mylo? Have your feels changed since then?

 

[PippyPony]

Wow Mixalot seems pretty popular all of a sudden

 

[PippyPony]

Edit: and you as a wolf can definitely be pushing for clarification to throw shade and/or to look more like your village self. Stop insinuating we're stupid for thinking you're a wolf

Do you think I'm a wolf?

Edit to add: who do you think I'm throwing shade at?

 

[Coopah]

Do you think I'm a wolf?

I think you're sketchy but I can't be certain of your affiliation yet. Highest wolf lean though

 

[Coopah]

Wow Mixalot seems pretty popular all of a sudden

Yeah I don't like it, particularly this

******lynch Mixy******
Seems to be participating quite a bit more than normal at this point.

and this

I think AM is being a bit snarky and aggressive, but I think that every game, so biz as usual.
Pippy was a bit sensitive, but I also find that normal after modding.

Mixed is too defensive, so...

Unlynch the plant Lynch mixed.

 

[PippyPony]

@Animal Midwife any thoughts?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Yeah I don't like it, particularly this

and this

I actually had that opinion before I was all caught up on the thread and saw other people on her lynch

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

@FrostySparrow i find it interesting you’re throwing shade at the other people on the mixy lynch when you were the first one on that lynch to begin with.

 

[Animal Midwife]

So role reveal is allowed but ability reveal and results are not?

I see Stagg liked this post. Highly unusal to allow name reveal and not ability. It's always the other way around if one is prohibited. Regardless, thanks for asking.

@Animal Midwife any thoughts?

I think the Mixy pressuring looks good.

 

[Coopah]

I actually had that opinion before I was all caught up on the thread and saw other people on her lynch

placement is placement, it's not damning I just want to point it out to be taken into consideration with everything else

 

[PippyPony]

@FrostySparrow i find it interesting you’re throwing shade at the other people on the mixy lynch when you were the first one on that lynch to begin with.

I think Frosty is a noob, if that affects your interpretation of waffles at all.

 

[PippyPony]

I think the Mixy pressuring looks good.

All of it?

You're voting for Allie, btw. (In case you forgot.)

 

[Animal Midwife]

All of it?

You're voting for Allie, btw. (In case you forgot.)

Yes, early votes only help me down the road. And I'm well aware of where my vote is.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I see Stagg liked this post. Highly unusal to allow name reveal and not ability. It's always the other way around if one is prohibited. Regardless, thanks for asking.

I think the Mixy pressuring looks good.

That’s... interesting that ability reveals arent allowed if that’s the way we’re taking it?

 

[Coopah]

@Stagg737 some clarification about we can and cannot reveal?

 

[mypetmoose]

Twoose is having some feels towards Paws. There has been some shade throwing and we feel good lynching there today. Lynch Paws.