WW Basic B's Game

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Coopah said:
@Stagg737 some clarification about we can and cannot reveal?
Click to expand...

You may reveal your role name for shiggles since they're NAI. You may not intentionally reveal ability. I realize this is an odd format and there was a very good reason for it which I can't remember at all at this moment but somehow involved game balance and OOE.
 
PippyPony said:
This is a great example of noise bias.

Players who talk a lot in early game often get read as sketchy, because they are more prominent and therefore top of mind.

Be careful to consider people for what they post, not how much they are showing up on the page.
Click to expand...
PippyPony said:
For example, @FrostySparrow (and @Coopah and @StayingPositive2017 since they have apparently forgotten how this works), the second sentence here doesn't make a lot of sense for a villager to say, and we might not have had this comment if I didn't push for clarification.
Click to expand...

mizchiefmanaged said:
@FrostySparrow i find it interesting you’re throwing shade at the other people on the mixy lynch when you were the first one on that lynch to begin with.
Click to expand...

I thought I gave a decent reason.. it wasn't because mixy was one of the first to post like claimed above. I felt her vote was for weak reasons and wanted her to elaborate. I don't think the other votes are for the same reason... especially the posting too much claim.. I think that's as valid a reason to lynch someone as it is one for them being snarky... that is if not clear enough I don't think those are decent reasons at all. Waiting on mixy to reply to questions and will base unlynch action on the responses and how things go from there.
 
Oh pippy[emoji849] if only I was that good.

I voted AM initially because she was talking about mylo on D1 which from what I remember is not her usual. Then her salt rubbed me the wrong way. Still does. I see why moose answers her the way she does. Obviously I'm wrong. Not even sure why I should try getting out of being lynched. Never have been able to before why should it be any different this time? cause everyone thinks I'm so sketchy no matter what I say or do it doesnt ever matter.

###unlynch AM###

Have fun with the runaway train yall. Maybe look at those with less solid reasons on me/flipped at the switch of a hat. I'll have a break again at work so if you have specific questions shoot them my way and I'll do my best to answer them. I just looked at lynch closed time and probably wont have time to come on and give you all the thouroughness youd want from me but I'll try.
 
PippyPony said:
We're probably not supposed to reveal ability because it could hard clear 3 people immediately.

Seems pretty obvious, so I'm not sure why so many people are confused about it.
Click to expand...
It’s more concerning to me that we may accidentally lynch those three people and they won’t be able to appropriately defend.
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Oh pippy[emoji849] if only I was that good.

I voted AM initially because she was talking about mylo on D1 which from what I remember is not her usual. Then her salt rubbed me the wrong way. Still does. I see why moose answers her the way she does. Obviously I'm wrong. Not even sure why I should try getting out of being lynched. Never have been able to before why should it be any different this time? cause everyone thinks I'm so sketchy no matter what I say or do it doesnt ever matter.

###unlynch AM###

Have fun with the runaway train yall. Maybe look at those with less solid reasons on me/flipped at the switch of a hat. I'll have a break again at work so if you have specific questions shoot them my way and I'll do my best to answer them. I just looked at lynch closed time and probably wont have time to come on and give you all the thouroughness youd want from me but I'll try.
Click to expand...
4 votes really isn't a runaway train with this many hours left in the day + >9 players. You can still talk about your reads.
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
It’s more concerning to me that we may accidentally lynch those three people and they won’t be able to appropriately defend.
Click to expand...
It's possible to defend without role revealing. Everyone who is vanilla has to defend without a role mechanically clearing them, no?
 
Animal Midwife said:
4 votes really isn't a runaway train with this many hours left in the day + >9 players. You can still talk about your reads.
Click to expand...
Yeah I have to go back to work in 4 min and only have a 15 min break the rest of the day. I'm more free tomorrow.

Real quick with the 2 mins I have left

Regardless-paws villagey thus far her combing for tiny details remind me of village her
Pippy- unsure
Coop- I'm putting her in my village pile cause I dont think wolf coop would try and help little sketch me.
Miz-concerned about because of her voting reasoning
Frosty-im not sure we have played together before so a question mark for me yet.
SOV-concerned about as well how quickly they flipped.

I know theres more people I'm missing but I gotta go. Will try and fill it in more on my break. If I happen to live to tomorrow I'll be better since I'm not working.
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Ugh my phone didnt quote it. The post where you tag 3 people and say that isnt something a villager would say. Have you seen the things I've said and done before? I've never claimed to be good at this game.
Click to expand...
I think your reads tend to be pretty good, for the record. But I agree you do often phrase things in a sketchy manner.
 
Ugh I’m trying really hard not to think Miz is sketchy because I do every game and I’m always wrong but I don’t like the reasoning for her vote

I think AM sounds normal and I’ve seen her talk about mylo/lylo enough that I don’t think it’s weird lol

One of mixy’s early long posts set off some feels for me but all her posts since then have felt better and I don’t like how easily people are voting there

Annndd I feel like I’ve been gone long enough that this has all already been said
 
PippyPony said:
For example, @FrostySparrow (and @Coopah and @StayingPositive2017 since they have apparently forgotten how this works), the second sentence here doesn't make a lot of sense for a villager to say, and we might not have had this comment if I didn't push for clarification.
Click to expand...
Do you still believe this? If so why are you voting AM? And regardless why are you voting AM?
 
PippyPony said:
You may have missed one of my earlier questions because I edited it in while you were responding to another post.

Who do you think I am shading?

And who do you think Paws is shading?
Click to expand...
I'm not sure if paws is shading anyone technically speaking, she putting pressure on mixy for answers and making good points. I think you're shading me and paws with that little post that literally said you were shading both of us 🙄
 
Animal Midwife said:
Where are the feels coming from? She is one of my strongest village reads atm.
Click to expand...

The AM/mixy ordeal just isn't doing it for us. It feels like normal bickering...Paws' shiftiness has caught our eyes more -- and Moose says that you felt strong village about genny last game
These are the posts that pinged our feeldar mostly.

StayingPositive2017 said:
This is the oddest D1 reason but I'm not sure if it seems sketchy
Click to expand...
StayingPositive2017 said:
Yeah lol, also thought about lynching pip but decided Mixy jumped on the thought process. Though Mixy was much more invested so did consider pips as more shade...
Click to expand...

Coopah said:
Hm, do you two think she is wrong about the content of the shade?
Click to expand...
For me, it feels a little all over. Some of her points are more valid than others.
(Moose will elaborate more on what she is thinking on this tomorrow morning.)
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Yeah I have to go back to work in 4 min and only have a 15 min break the rest of the day. I'm more free tomorrow.

Real quick with the 2 mins I have left

Regardless-paws villagey thus far her combing for tiny details remind me of village her
Pippy- unsure
Coop- I'm putting her in my village pile cause I dont think wolf coop would try and help little sketch me.
Miz-concerned about because of her voting reasoning
Frosty-im not sure we have played together before so a question mark for me yet.
SOV-concerned about as well how quickly they flipped.

I know theres more people I'm missing but I gotta go. Will try and fill it in more on my break. If I happen to live to tomorrow I'll be better since I'm not working.
Click to expand...
When you're free I'd like more of your thoughts on pip
 
People who have played with mixy more than I have - am I off base here? She was a LOT quieter in the game or two I’ve played with her in the past.
 
PippyPony said:
I know I complain about this mechanic but that doesn't make sense to me. What would be the point of no lynching?

But also, why are we talking about mylo already?
Click to expand...
muttmanager said:
I like Frosty's point -
@MixedAnimals77 why AM over Nav who brought mylo up first?
Click to expand...
I feel like if you go back and look at all the ways MYLO was brought up in the convo it comes across a bit different with each person, at least to me. I think I quoted pip’s post to show that (but I also quoted pip’s post awhile ago soooo).
Animal Midwife said:
I see Stagg liked this post. Highly unusal to allow name reveal and not ability. It's always the other way around if one is prohibited. Regardless, thanks for asking.

I think the Mixy pressuring looks good.
Click to expand...
I saw something about four votes not being a bandwagon this early with so many missing and while I agree I also think it sets up a super easy either/or scenario if Mixy stays the leader with you (AM) being the other wagon.
 
mypetmoose said:
The AM/mixy ordeal just isn't doing it for us. It feels like normal bickering...Paws' shiftiness has caught our eyes more -- and Moose says that you felt strong village about genny last game
These are the posts that pinged our feeldar mostly.
Click to expand...
MOOSE also thought genny was strong village so that's an irrelevant point. Which points are valid from these two posts?
 
mizchiefmanaged said:
People who have played with mixy more than I have - am I off base here? She was a LOT quieter in the game or two I’ve played with her in the past.
Click to expand...
I can't do activity reads. I'm only interested in content (or lack thereof).
dolphin106258 said:
I saw something about four votes not being a bandwagon this early with so many missing and while I agree I also think it sets up a super easy either/or scenario if Mixy stays the leader with you (AM) being the other wagon.
Click to expand...
Why would this ever be an either/or situation unless no one here has played any WW? That would either mean no one else is posting reads beyond what's up to my post today or we're getting no more votes today.

What are your thoughts on both of us btw since either/or crossed your mind?
 
Last edited:
MixedAnimals77 said:
Oh pippy[emoji849] if only I was that good.

I voted AM initially because she was talking about mylo on D1 which from what I remember is not her usual. Then her salt rubbed me the wrong way. Still does. I see why moose answers her the way she does. Obviously I'm wrong. Not even sure why I should try getting out of being lynched. Never have been able to before why should it be any different this time? cause everyone thinks I'm so sketchy no matter what I say or do it doesnt ever matter.

###unlynch AM###

Have fun with the runaway train yall. Maybe look at those with less solid reasons on me/flipped at the switch of a hat. I'll have a break again at work so if you have specific questions shoot them my way and I'll do my best to answer them. I just looked at lynch closed time and probably wont have time to come on and give you all the thouroughness youd want from me but I'll try.
Click to expand...
MixedAnimals77 said:
Yeah I have to go back to work in 4 min and only have a 15 min break the rest of the day. I'm more free tomorrow.

Real quick with the 2 mins I have left

Regardless-paws villagey thus far her combing for tiny details remind me of village her
Pippy- unsure
Coop- I'm putting her in my village pile cause I dont think wolf coop would try and help little sketch me.
Miz-concerned about because of her voting reasoning
Frosty-im not sure we have played together before so a question mark for me yet.
SOV-concerned about as well how quickly they flipped.

I know theres more people I'm missing but I gotta go. Will try and fill it in more on my break. If I happen to live to tomorrow I'll be better since I'm not working.
Click to expand...


Thank you for these, I'd like to hear more reads on people from you when you get a chance. I've only played 1 other game, and I think I died pretty early (I don't remember what game it was). So chances are, we haven't played together or only played very little.
I'm satisfied with the acknowledgement of the play read on AM as well (about salt rubbing the wrong way) along with other's corrections they've offered.

mizchiefmanaged said:
People who have played with mixy more than I have - am I off base here? She was a LOT quieter in the game or two I’ve played with her in the past.
Click to expand...


I won't be able to do activity reads because I'm not familiar with how everyone is as village vs w/w. So I'm just going on context and feels.

For now ##unlynch mixy##

Has everyone checked in? If not, I'd like to hear from people who haven't yet.
 
mypetmoose said:
The AM/mixy ordeal just isn't doing it for us. It feels like normal bickering...Paws' shiftiness has caught our eyes more -- and Moose says that you felt strong village about genny last game
These are the posts that pinged our feeldar mostly.





For me, it feels a little all over. Some of her points are more valid than others.
(Moose will elaborate more on what she is thinking on this tomorrow morning.)
Click to expand...
It's a very short read so I recommend you read the first two days of the speed game last night to see me "all over the place" trying to figure things out. I get lynched village pretty quick
 
Animal Midwife said:
I can't do activity reads. I'm only interested in content (or lack thereof).

Why would this ever be an either/or situation unless no one here has played any WW? That would either mean no one else is posting reads beyond what's up to my post today we're getting no more votes today.

What are you thoughts on both of us btw since either/or crossed your mind?
Click to expand...
I have just felt like in recent games we’ve had a lot of either/or situations that make me feel like it’s the norm, but you don’t have to agree it was just an observation. I have you as village currently and mixy as a ? because I am super bad at reading her correctly.
But like I said before the context in which mylo was brought up by everyone is different, so for mixy to isolate you for it was weird, but better than mutts just saying why not Nav (since his mylo post was first) when his post about mylo was different than yours just like Pip’s and MsPro who all brought up mylo.
 
####
Unlynch mixalot
###
I like the reads given, not sure I'm ready to Lynch there and am willing to give more time there. Gonna look through the thread and read the roster to see who isn't participating
 
Barkley13 said:
Ugh I’m trying really hard not to think Miz is sketchy because I do every game and I’m always wrong but I don’t like the reasoning for her vote

I think AM sounds normal and I’ve seen her talk about mylo/lylo enough that I don’t think it’s weird lol

One of mixy’s early long posts set off some feels for me but all her posts since then have felt better and I don’t like how easily people are voting there

Annndd I feel like I’ve been gone long enough that this has all already been said
Click to expand...
We tend to tunnel each other, I think.

@muttmanager how you doing?
 
Why do people like Mixy's reads so much?
StayingPositive2017 said:
####
Unlynch mixalot
###
I like the reads given, not sure I'm ready to Lynch there and am willing to give more time there. Gonna look through the thread and read the roster to see who isn't participating
Click to expand...
FrostySparrow said:
Thank you for these, I'd like to hear more reads on people from you when you get a chance. I've only played 1 other game, and I think I died pretty early (I don't remember what game it was). So chances are, we haven't played together or only played very little.
I'm satisfied with the acknowledgement of the play read on AM as well (about salt rubbing the wrong way) along with other's corrections they've offered.




I won't be able to do activity reads because I'm not familiar with how everyone is as village vs w/w. So I'm just going on context and feels.

For now ##unlynch mixy##

Has everyone checked in? If not, I'd like to hear from people who haven't yet.
Click to expand...
What about her reads makes you feel so warm and fuzzy?
 
mypetmoose said:
The AM/mixy ordeal just isn't doing it for us. It feels like normal bickering...Paws' shiftiness has caught our eyes more -- and Moose says that you felt strong village about genny last game
These are the posts that pinged our feeldar mostly.
Click to expand...
Us?
Our?

Who are you talking with? Fellow wolves? Very strange.
 
Coopah said:
Why do people like Mixy's reads so much?


What about her reads makes you feel so warm and fuzzy?
Click to expand...

They don’t, but it’s a response to what I was initially wanting. She claimed she can’t be on much today, could that be a wolfy claim?
Sure, but It’s not a lynch I’m entirely positive would result in wolf and comfortable ending today with before hearing other people post. I need to check if that’s everyone.

StartingoverVet said:
Us?
Our?

Who are you talking with? Fellow wolves? Very strange.
Click to expand...

Us and ours would be her hydra part I’d assume.
 
FrostySparrow said:
They don’t, but it’s a response to what I was initially wanting. She claimed she can’t be on much today, could that be a wolfy claim?
Sure, but It’s not a lynch I’m entirely positive would result in wolf and comfortable ending today with before hearing other people post. I need to check if that’s everyone.



Us and ours would be her hydra part I’d assume.
Click to expand...
Fair enough
 
Official D1 Do These Votes Make Me Look Fat? Lynch Tally

Fern () -
AM (1) - Pippy
Allie (1) - AM
Ms P (1) - Barky
Mixalot (2) - Mizzy, SOV
Pippy (1) - Coops
Pawsy (1) - Twoose

7/16 voting

Lynch close in exactly 4 hours


THE MODS DEMAND MORE MURDER, BISHES!!!!!
 
muttmanager said:
I'm well, how are you?
Click to expand...
Can’t complain! He likes his new maraca :laugh:
267417


What’re your thoughts so far?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
HolloWW's End: A Spooky WW Game
108 109 110 111 112
Replies
6K
Views
86K
kaydubs
kaydubs
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
104K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
Halloween Horrors WW Game Sign Ups [CLOSED]
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
313
Views
9K
supershorty
supershorty
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
73K
katiemcat
katiemcat
kaydubs
Snack WWars (Game Thread)
55 56 57 58 59
Replies
3K
Views
28K
JaggedJimmyJay
JaggedJimmyJay
Top Bottom