i'll start by doing a quick copy-and-paste of what i wrote in another thread:
3) there are too few decent living options around dartmouth. apartments in and around hanover are either buildings that would be condemned where i live or $1050/mo and higher. dartmouth's grad apartments are the housing equivalent of eating 12 chili cheese burritos at taco bell and then participating in a hula-hoop marathon. dartmouth is also a solid 13-hour drive from home.
4) dartmouth is a
great school and the hospital is my personal favorite (along with barnes-jewish) of any i've seen on the interview trail.
5) undergrads at dartmouth piss me off. they ALL look like the same backwards-hat, sandal-wearing goofs in abercrombie catalogues who will gladly and unknowingly ram into you on the sidewalk while giving their ultra-preppy friends incredibily obnoxious surfer-dude high-fives.
seriously, i got another tour with andy welch, talked to the financial aid people, and went in every building on campus that you don't need a keycard to enter. the people are uber-nice. its a wonderful place to learn. but its pretty far removed from the rest of the world, and after 3 solid days of apartment-hunting, i was quite displeased with the selection (everything that is nice/close to campus/DHMC is $$$$$$, and everything else is spread out all over hell and hard to find.
overall i like dartmouth, but if they stiff me in financial aid, i'm going to case.