University Hospitals Case Medical Center

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Andrew_Doan

Ophthalmology, Aerospace Medicine, Eye Pathology
Moderator Emeritus
Lifetime Donor
20+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2002
Messages
5,643
Reaction score
29
Points
4,746
Location
United States
Website
dr.andrew-doan.com
  1. Attending Physician
Posting Anonymously for SDN User

Easily the most disorganized program I interviewed at. Did not seem to know which interviewees belonged in the morning/afternoon groups. Once they got past that, program seemed alright but it left a bad taste in my mouth. They have a great VA (best VA in the country, so they say) with a fancy Ophtho clinic, as well as separate sites for peds and their UH. Major red flag is that the program is on probation (for inadequate numbers), and they were quite shady about how many surgeries residents performed. The only solid number I got was "over 600 surgeries including primary and secondary", which really says nothing. Also, their chair doubles as their PD. He's a nice man, I'm sure, but the program clearly has some problems. Also had my home school insulted by a couple of the residents, which was . Cleveland is meh, but hopefully Kyrie Irving will bring them around .
 
Does anyone else have input on the program? How can we find out if the program has been on probation? Kind of scary to hear that especially when I'm interviewing there soon (and I'm sure a large number of other users here)..
 
You are right Speyder. I just checked. It doesn't show up any more as an affiliated school.
 
You are right Speyder. I just checked. It doesn't show up any more as an affiliated school.

NYMC is affiliated with Westchester Medical Center in Valhalla NY. Their ophtho residency is based there primarily. They rotate through a couple of other hospitals in NYC (Metropolitan Hospital & Our Lady of Mercy I believe).
 
Thanks for the link! I wonder why someone said the program was on probation a year ago? Strange. Anyway, anyone with insight into the Case program? Thanks,
 
Greeniris, I think with sites like SDN, we have to take the info with a pinch of salt. Posters have their own biases that come through. That's why it's critical that we hear from residents/sr residents from Case.

Reg NYMC, some years ago, I recall seeing NY Pres affiliation on a banner right above the NYMC campus entrance. It no longer seems to exist now.
 
The program was on probation last year.
It is no longer on probation from what I understand. The Chair is no longer doubles as the PD.
They have a new chair http://casemed.case.edu/newscenter/news-release/newsrelease.cfm?news_id=166
Probation was never about surgery. They have 5 or 6 residents per year, and the volume/cachement/VA to support it.

I'm Not a Case Resident, and the info is second hand from former Case colleague. i suspect a quick google search or so can answer most of your questions.
 
Unsubstantiated rumors...probation was regarding work hours...and they still consistently break / lie about their work hours. Can anybody confirm or deny?
 
I graduated from case a couple years ago before the probation so I may be able to help out (hopefully).
Pros: 6 residents a year- has been that way for a while which is great from a call perspective, Great VA- now with 2 teams of 3 residents each at a given block- if they are able to have that many residents at the va at a given time, i'm sure they have enough surgical volume. I wouldn't go so far as to say its the best in the country, but it is great for ophtho residents. Most of the surrounding VA's in Ohio and western PA had optometry departments and would refer all surgical eye patients over to wade park. No fellows in the program either ensures residents get to do the surgeries. The whole probation thing is blown out of proportion. I never ever felt I was overworked. Some days you work harder than others and that's just the nature of any residency. Either way the program is off probation and is accredited currently.
Cons: Lots of faculty turnover, new chair- could be good or bad, didactics when I was there was pretty poor- may have changed since, Cleveland is not quite like any other major metropolitan city in the country unfortunately!

In the end I feel I got the most out of my residency experience. Hope that helps!
 
The residents here were great. The hospital is a nice facility with a lot of prestige in the greater academic world. The clinics were nice, and the VA was fantastic and among the busiest in the country. Surgical numbers were a little below average, and call is light (Q9 I seem to remember). The new-ish chair, Dr. Rhee, is a big plus for the program. Very sharp, good sense of humor, but can be a bit intense. I didn't really enjoy my interview with him, but did have good interactions with him throughout the day. He is well-known, and arrived only 3 years ago(?) from MEEI. The program seemed particularly strong in peds (Rainbow is a top children's hospital) and glaucoma. Cleveland is not as bad as I’d anticipated, and the area around Euclid is charming and affordable. I think this program is rapidly rising under new direction. They were open with their probation 6 years ago-due to disparity in cat numbers, low plastics, and admin issues. It was all fixed or is being fixed, and I don’t think applicants should worry much about this when ranking. They have a strong match list too, including glaucoma and cornea at Wills since the arrival of Rhee (trained at Wills). Chair did admit that retina was weakest area, but that they are recruiting new faculty. Overall a solid program, and improving by the year.
 
Top Bottom