A great book for anyone entering medicine

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

DORoe

BWAAA HAAA HAAA
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
893
Reaction score
0
I have begun reading and am almost done with a great book about a man's experience with becoming a surgeon. It is called Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science by Atul Gawande. It deals with his own feelings of nervousness in doing procedures and his thoughts and experiences with medicine in general. I, like many others I would assume, have had doubts about people entrusting me with their lives. The doctors that I see and have talked to seem so confident. This book has showed me that many others feel the same way. I will leave you with a great quote from the book.

"Medicine is, I have found, a strange and in many ways disturbing business. The stakes are high, the liberties taken tremendous. We drug people, put needles and tubes into them, manipulate their chemistry, biology, and physics, lay them unconscious and open their bodies up to the world. We do so out of an abiding confidence in our know-how as a profession. What you find when you get in close, however-close enough to see the furrowed brows, the doubts and missteps, the failures as well as the successes-is how messy, uncertain, and also surprising medicine turns out to be."

Members don't see this ad.
 
This better be good...I just ordered it off of amazon!

can't wait

this will be my next read once i'm done with "Life of Pi":cool:
 
Lot of pressure on me now lol. I think that you will be happy with your purchase it is a great book IMHO.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
The House of God by Samuel Shem is better!
 
That one that the OP is talking about is really good... Michael Crichton's "five patients" and Robin Cook's "The Year of the Intern" are also both really good (although a little outdated, but the central themes are pretty good). If you're into overseas medical trips stuff or ER, Pamela Grim's "Just here trying to gave a few lives, tales of life and death from the ER" is really really good. Read that one while traveling to WVSOM (long lay over in atlanta)... enjoy!

Jon
 
His story about trying to put in a central line is great.
 
I picked this book up on the clearance shelf of the bookstore a week or so ago. Haven't touched it yet, as I'm still busy with "The D.O.'s", "Physics", and "Organic Chemistry".
 
The D.O.'s was not bad but pretty dry at times.
 
Originally posted by SM-UCLA tech
The House of God by Samuel Shem is better!


Mount Misery, the sequel to House of God is not too bad either.

A book that I'm reading now is The Art of Medicine, by Kevin Soden, MD. It has a very good premise and what's funny is it might as well be an Osteopathic medicine book! :clap: The author writes about treating and listening to the whole patient, etc. Very good read for us entering medical school...

Hey UCLA, nice pic!

:laugh:
 
"Becoming a Doctor: A Journey of Initiation in Medical School" by Melvin Konner M.D.

Had to throw that one in there. From his tone throughout the book, I belive he may have been happier as a D.O.

-NS
 
The book, LEARNING TO PLAY GOD, by Dr. Robert Marion is a great book for all pre-med or current medical students. I just finished reading it and it was great reading and so well written. I highly recommend it if you havent read it yet

ROb
 
I read "Complications"----Not bad, not great either, but it's a decent book.


A couple of others that are kind of out dated but still good to read are:

A Case of Need by Jeffery Hudson (Also known as Michael Crichton) and Arrowsmith by Sinclair Lewis.
 
I kind of liked "White Coat: Becoming a doctor at HMS". Some of my classmates felt that the author sounded negative and pessismistic, but I thought that it provided a lot of useful info about how med school works. It's an easy read too.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Great book. Some of it made me think twice about going under the knife for anything, though.
 
Has anyone read " To do no harm, a journey through medical school" by Philip Reilly, M.D. I just took the book out of the library and was wondering if anyone has read it and could comment on it. It is out dated though, written back in 1986.
 
for a light, easy read i suggest picking up, "the ultimate guide to choosing a medical specialty" by brian freeman, MD. its very informative especially those interested in highly competitive specialties where you can't wake up at the end of 3rd year and decide to go into!
 
Just read "House of God" that stuff is funny. I couldn't put it down read it in like 2 days! I've now officially started calling my 6 month old neice a gomere lol. Im checking out Mount Misery after i read "The Art of Medicine"
 
Originally posted by DORoe
Just read "House of God" that stuff is funny. I couldn't put it down read it in like 2 days! I've now officially started calling my 6 month old neice a gomere lol. Im checking out Mount Misery after i read "The Art of Medicine"

Sweet....gotta love the fat man! :clap: Oh, and you'll like The Art of Medicine.
 
I read Complications b4--it's a great book. Another great book is ?f I get to Five"by Fred Epstein--A neurosurgeon @ Beth Israel in NYC.
 
along with complications and the house of god, i liked "the intern blues" by robert marion, and " the dressing station" by jonathan kaplan.

and....take a break from obsessive reading of medical memoirs and get some leisure reading in!
"the unbearable lightness of being" by milan kundera, "ask the dust" by john fante and everything by david sedaris (especially "naked" and "me talk pretty one day") are not medical reading but are nonetheless essential for perspective, IMHO.
 
I'll second Learning to Play God and White Coat.

My favorite was, Body of Knowledge by Steve Geigerich It's the true story of four lab mate's semester of gross anatomy. It was great!

Good Ostopathic Book: The Difference a DO Makes by Bob E. Jones. I think you can only get it here http://www.okosteo.org/book.html

BTW: I didn't make it through Kaplan's The Dressing Station.
 
Originally posted by SM-UCLA tech
The House of God by Samuel Shem is better!

I'm reading it right now. I swear the Fatman, with his understanding of the body healing itself, has to be a DO.
 
Can't agree more! Complications is a great book and a must-read for anyone going in to medicine!! :clap:
 
are you entering med school in the fall pegasus? If so are you going to be a classmate of mine at OU? (I saw that you are from C-bus)
 
I've read Becoming a Doctor by Melvin Konner. He has another book out called Medicine at the Crossroads that is pretty good as well. In this book, Konner details the problems with medicine and insurance companies in general. It's a book related more towards the business side of medicine.
 
I've read Becoming a Doctor by Melvin Konner. He has another book out called Medicine at the Crossroads that is pretty good as well. In this book, Konner details the problems with medicine and insurance companies in general. It's a book related more towards the business side of medicine.


Great i will check that book out. I admit I know very little about the business side of medicine and maybe i will have a better understanding after reading it.
 
yes, house of god is great book. first read it 3 years ago. truly, i laughed out loud while reading it. actually read it a second time last month. complications: was also good (but in a more sobering and realistic way). read it while on a cruise in december.

a couple of other books i recommend:

a case of need by Michael Crichton; very cool and suspenseful medical thriller, a real page turner.

bringing out the dead by Joe Connelly; written by a paramedic from NYC's upper west side (hell's kitchen), if you scare easily don't read this one at night.

crime zero by Michael Cordy; interesting twist on how far genetic manipulation could go.

and of course, if you haven't read it:

brave new world by Alduous Huxley; most definitely one of my favorite books ever. don't let anyone convince you that the movie Gataca is even close; it's not.

also, anyone who didn't have to read zen and the art of motorcycle maintainance by Robert Pirsig in high school or college, it is worth the effort. i read this twice also. ceratinly not a 2 or 3 dayer, but an enlightening read.

i'll stop now

k
 
Let's keep this going. I am really bored this semester and have been spending a lot of time reading various books.

DORoe's Top 10 book list:
10. Slaughterhouse Five by Kurt Vonnegut.
9. Catch 22 by Joseph Heller
8. Breakfast of Champions by Kurt Vonnegut
7. The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner
6. House of God by Samuel Shem
5. 1984 by George Orwell
4. The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick
3. Galapagos by Kurt Vonnegut (I see a theme here lol)
2. Hatchet by Gary Paulsen (I know it's a kid's book but i have fond memories of it from childhood)

and my altime favorite book....

1. Native Son by Richard A. Wright
 
Roe, you're forgetting Vonnegut's "The Sirens of Titan"! Easily the best book (Vonnegut or not) ever made!!!!
 
well to tell you the truth i haven't gotten to that one yet. That is next on my list after Mount Misery. I'm looking forward to it. My physics prof. highly recommended it.
 
I'm actually readin one right now that's had a great start so far and it's really new so you might like it.

"Stiff: The curious lives of human cadavers" by Mary Roach

peep it
 
On my way to KCOM I "listened" (I know it was a lazy choice) to Complications. I thought it started out great and then kind of faded toward the end. Or was that just me?

I bought House of God today. $12 This better be good. I'm reading it on my way to Miami.

(They didn't have an audio of it j/k) :D
 
Dude House of God will change your life. No not really but you will be laughin your @ss off for sure.
 
I have read two great books so far, somewhat similar but so well written and great to read before medical school or during it.

1) Learning to Play God by Robert Marion, M.D.
2) Art of Medicine by Kevin Soden, M.D.

I'm currently reading Lost Art of Healing by Bernard Lown, MD

I strongly recommend any three of these, while probably my favorite was art of medicine.
 
I just started reading "First, Do No Harm" by Lisa Belkin. It follows the cases and decisions of the ethics committee at a hospital in Houston. So far, I've found it to be very interesting.

Ms. Belkin is a journalist, I think. She gives you the background on the patients as well as several of the doctors and other committee members. At times, it has the feel of "small town gossip"--and I'm not sure if she took some artistic license here or not in her characterizations of the thoughts/motivations of different people in the story.

The one recurring motif is the idea of "when have doctors done too much?" She comes back to it a lot. Compare to just a few years ago when we couldn't do enough to save a patient, how do you know when it's time to let one go?

Probably not the best book I've ever read, but certainly thought-provoking.

Willow (who is going to make a trip to the library tomorrow and fill up her spring break with books!)
 
Originally posted by DORoe
Dude House of God will change your life. No not really but you will be laughin your @ss off for sure.

I liked this book too. Although it is a little outdated, I think it is an acurate description of medicine in the 70's; and I can definitely see some of these ideas continuing today.
When I was reading this book, my hubby occasionally looked over to see what I was reading, and dubbed this book "Doctor Porn" :laugh:
He said this all in good fun, as long as we didn't turn into a ROR -
"relationship on the rocks"
;)
 
I just got done reading "Mount Misery" the sequel to House of God and it is very good as well. If you liked "House of God" I think you will enjoy "Mount Misery" as well.
 
I read House of God a while back, currently reading Mount Misery and A Life in Medicine.

Read Complications a while ago too and loved it. Gawande does a great job of showing how physicians are not infallible even at the top of their field.

-J
 
I am about half way through The House of God and I have laughed several times out loud.

It is kind of depressing though. I am sure it is pretty realistic. I hope it ends on a good note so I am not scared chitless when I graduate and step into the wards.

I am not looking forward to being an intern.
 
First Cut - a journalist follows first year med students through gross anatomy

Intern Blues - scary thoughts, but realistic, a quick read

The Measure of Our Days: A Spiritual Exploration of Illness, Jerome Groopman (inspired the short-lived television series "Gideon's Crossing." - cancer patients, very well-written

Just my 2 cents on House of God: I have tried to begin reading it a few times and was always offended and put it down. Maybe I was being too sensitive, but as a wife and mother I found it irrelevant to my goals as a physician to be reading about doctors mentally undressing (etc.) the nurses, etc...
 
Originally posted by Maisy
Just my 2 cents on House of God: I have tried to begin reading it a few times and was always offended and put it down. Maybe I was being too sensitive, but as a wife and mother I found it irrelevant to my goals as a physician to be reading about doctors mentally undressing (etc.) the nurses, etc...

I can see how the language in House of God would be offending to some people. However, I don't think that this book falls very far from the truth. Especially if you are examining specialties like neurosurgery, etc. Women will still encounter this kind of behavior and mentality in a paternalistic field such as medicine.

check out this book for a realistic situation of a woman in a male-dominated specialty, and academic medicine
Walking Out on the Boys
I recommend it-
I read this book for a wonderful seminar I took in undergrad called "The myths and metaphors of medicine"
A pediatric anesthesiologist from Children's Memorial in Chicago taught the class. It was a MUST for anyone thinking about med school. A few pre-meds decided not to apply to med school b/c of this class and the reality of it all.
 
i don't know if someone said it earlier...the best book i read before school, and then again after anatomy was BODY OF KNOWLEDGE. It was an excelent book that really helped me with adjusting to the anatomy lab thing.
 
Originally posted by jhug
i don't know if someone said it earlier...the best book i read before school, and then again after anatomy was BODY OF KNOWLEDGE. It was an excelent book that really helped me with adjusting to the anatomy lab thing.

who's the author of Body of Knowledge?
 
stephen geigrich I believe is the author of Body of Knowledge, One semester of gross anatomy
 
I just finished Stiff by Mary Roach. I loved it! She is so funny--imagine humor about cadaevers! She gives a great history of how cadaevers have been used in medicine and research from the days of grave-robbing up through gross anatomy lab and all points in between.

All humor aside, she really emphasizes respect for those people who will their bodies to science. I was very impressed by how she was able to separate in her mind the "person" from the body in front of her without showing a lack of respect for who the person was in life.
 
I agree "Stiff" was a good read!
 
I think Stiff will be my next read as soon as I'm done with House of God!

Then its off to Mount Misery!
 
Top