A Balanced Review of Harvard Extension

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

noncon

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
172
Reaction score
0
A Balanced Review of Harvard Extension:

The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time. (http://hms.harvard.edu/content/facts-figures-0#numbers)

On the negative side, my sister and her friends constantly bitch about how HES and Harvard do not treat Extension students well. If you go down and talk to one of the advisors or deans on Brattle, you will know because they treat you like ****. There is one Black lady who is one of the dean of students - she absolutely hates HES students. There are also many annoyances you need to put up with at HES. The only bathroom in Sever Hall stinks to high heavens, the computer staff treat you like ****, if you print on only one side of the page the annoying white lady with a foreign accent in Grossman computer lab screams at you. The very tall, bald guy who mans the computer lab in Grossman is an exception - he looks white but he is actually a Black dude - because he is about the only HES employee who is nice. You also cannot print more than 20 pages at one time, Grossman library is as tiny as a matchbox, you cannot even borrow books from Grossman library which is the only library for HES students, the computer lab in Grossman - try to squeeze to the upper level on those stairs if you work out because it is even smaller than a matchbox, the two scanners in Grossman - try to get them to work, the other computer facility on Church Street is just as bad, try going into one of the other Harvard libraries (sadly almost all of the 100 libraries at Harvard don't allow HES students), try calling 495-8400 which other Harvard students get to use to get a free ride back home, try getting a letter of recommendation on Harvard letterheads from your professors, or try getting an on-campus apartment at Harvard - I could go on and on. Oh and the hand sanitizer dispensing machines in Sever are always dry. Why do I keep talking about Sever?? Because you may spend 8 years at Harvard Extension getting an ALB, that's at least how long most people take, but you will see the insides of only 3 or 4 buildings - that dirty Sever for the most part, Brattle, Science Center and one or two others for your finals. One girl was stuck in Sever's elevator during her final when she took a break to use the bathroom. That elevator takes forever and forever but that day it broke down and she was trapped inside for over an hour. The professor said, no way, you won't get a make-up final and after the fire department let her out, she had to go in to take the rest of the final but had only about 10 minutes left. She complained to the deans but nothing came out of it. Don't take the elevator in Sever when you have your exams!!

But their biggest complaint is how HES absolutely murders your transcript with B's and C's and how many, many dreams of law school, PhD school, MD school and MBA programs are killed when HES professors, clearly under instruction from the HES admin, give you B's, C's and D's. You see, HES' ALB degree is a Harvard degree, so they make you "pay your dues" and the only way they know to make you earn Harvard credentials (ALB) is by assigning insane amount of work and murdering your transcript with B's and C's. And by writing very luke-warm recommendation letters to even someone who gets straight A's. Don't get a letter from any HES professor at Harvard!!!!!! Get them from professors who have taught you in your undergraduate college. The rumor is HES faculty are instructed by the HES admin to NOT write strong letters and by all indication those rumors are true.

If you go to HES, your chances of getting into medical school actually get significantly diminished because HES deliberately murders your transcript. Only about 33% of the students - and many drop out even before - manage to get into medical schools, limping on a transcript peppered with B's and C's. The national average is about 44%, so Harvard Extension does significantly worse than the national average because of transcript damage and bad letters of recommendation.

Columbia has the School of General Studies that sounds better than "Extension" although it is the same as Extension. But SGS students are treated well and integrated into the Columbia community. If you want Ivy League credentials, get one from the SGS instead of HES.

On the other hand, if you want the world's best preparation for the MCAT or a chance to encounter some of Harvard's 11,860 medical school professors, then HES is for you (if you don't mind B's, C's, W's and F's on your transcript!)

Your mileage may vary and HES students who get offended may call me a "troll" which really indicates they had nothing substantial to say.
 
Last edited:
A Balanced Review of Harvard Extension:

The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time. (http://hms.harvard.edu/content/facts-figures-0#numbers)

On the negative side, my sister and her friends constantly bitch about how HES and Harvard do not treat Extension students well. If you go down and talk to one of the advisors or deans on Brattle, you will know because they treat you like ****. There is one Black lady who is one of the dean of students - she absolutely hates HES students. There are also many annoyances you need to put up with at HES. The only bathroom in Sever Hall stinks to high heavens, the computer staff treat you like ****, if you print on only one side of the page the annoying white lady with a foreign accent in Grossman computer lab screams at you. The very tall, bald guy who mans the computer lab in Grossman is an exception - he looks white but he is actually a Black dude - because he is about the only HES employee who is nice. You also cannot print more than 20 pages at one time, Grossman library is as tiny as a matchbox, you cannot even borrow books from Grossman library which is the only library for HES students, the computer lab in Grossman - try to squeeze to the upper level on those stairs if you work out because it is even smaller than a matchbox, the two scanners in Grossman - try to get them to work, the other computer facility on Church Street is just as bad, try going into one of the other Harvard libraries (sadly almost all of the 100 libraries at Harvard don't allow HES students), try calling 495-8400 which other Harvard students get to use to get a free ride back home, try getting a letter of recommendation on Harvard letterheads from your professors, or try getting an on-campus apartment at Harvard - I could go on and on. Oh and the hand sanitizer dispensing machines in Sever are always dry. Why do I keep talking about Sever?? Because you may spend 8 years at Harvard Extension getting an ALB, that's at least how long most people take, but you will see the insides of only 3 or 4 buildings - that dirty Sever for the most part, Brattle, Science Center and one or two others for your finals. One girl was stuck in Sever's elevator during her final when she took a break to use the bathroom. That elevator takes forever and forever but that day it broke down and she was trapped inside for over an hour. The professor said, no way, you won't get a make-up final and after the fire department let her out, she had to go in to take the rest of the final but had only about 10 minutes left. She complained to the deans but nothing came out of it. Don't take the elevator in Sever when you have your exams!!

But their biggest complaint is how HES absolutely murders your transcript with B's and C's and how many, many dreams of law school, PhD school, MD school and MBA programs are killed when HES professors, clearly under instruction from the HES admin, give you B's, C's and D's. You see, HES' ALB degree is a Harvard degree, so they make you "pay your dues" and the only way they know to make you earn Harvard credentials (ALB) is by assigning insane amount of work and murdering your transcript with B's and C's. And by writing very luke-warm recommendation letters to even someone who gets straight A's. Don't get a letter from any HES professor at Harvard!!!!!! Get them from professors who have taught you in your undergraduate college. The rumor is HES faculty are instructed by the HES admin to NOT write strong letters and by all indication those rumors are true.

If you go to HES, your chances of getting into medical school actually get significantly diminished because HES deliberately murders your transcript. Only about 33% of the students - and many drop out even before - manage to get into medical schools, limping on a transcript peppered with B's and C's. The national average is about 44%, so Harvard Extension does significantly worse than the national average because of transcript damage and bad letters of recommendation.

Columbia has the School of General Studies that sounds better than "Extension" although it is the same as Extension. But SGS students are treated well and integrated into the Columbia community. If you want Ivy League credentials, get one from the SGS instead of HES.

On the other hand, if you want the world's best preparation for the MCAT or a chance to encounter some of Harvard's 11,860 medical school professors, then HES is for you (if you don't mind B's, C's, W's and F's on your transcript!)

Your mileage may vary and HES students who get offended may call me a "troll" which really indicates they had nothing substantial to say.

Why did you decide to include any of this...?
 
The same person who said their sister was being eaten alive at 8 credits? Not sure how one person's experience is providing a balanced view. Confused...
 
This thread = :beat::shrug::boom:

I feel like I have heard about Harvard Extension 34283784 times the past month. Idk if its the same poster or multiple ones I'm just tired of hearing about it lol

I didn't read the whole post but I would assume that the people applying to this program would at least have half a brain and do their research on what the program is like before they enter it.

If it is that much of a GPA killer and they have dreams of getting into competitive higher education programs where GPA is obviously important (and they could go to any other program with equal reputation and actually get good grades taking more than 8 credits) then they screwed themselves over.

Doing this program when you aren't William Hwang is like applying to medical school with a 15J MCAT-- It just doesn't make sense.

I just don't get what all the fuss is about.
 
This thread = :beat::shrug::boom:

I feel like I have heard about Harvard Extension 34283784 times the past month. Idk if its the same poster or multiple ones I'm just tired of hearing about it lol

I didn't read the whole post but I would assume that the people applying to this program would at least have half a brain and do their research on what the program is like before they enter it.

If it is that much of a GPA killer and they have dreams of getting into competitive higher education programs where GPA is obviously important (and they could go to any other program with equal reputation and actually get good grades taking more than 8 credits) then they screwed themselves over.

Doing this program when you aren't William Hwang is like applying to medical school with a 15J MCAT-- It just doesn't make sense.

I just don't get what all the fuss is about.

It's not just you, I think OP has been bringing this up everywhere, especially on LizzyM's Ask (Almost) Anything, not really sure why though...
 
People like William Hwang burn out rather rapidly. I know someone like that well. She was much more, MUCH more accomplished than William Hwang. She didn't burn out but followed her passion. BS and MS in Engineering, PhD from Stanford, then a professor of mechanical engineering at MIT (http://www.mit.edu/~pucci/) and also at NYU. She was very young too! Then she decided to follow her passion. She followed her heart and gave up her superbly brilliant career to dance tango. She became a professional tango dancer. Here's why in her own words http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BbAt1gnkBE
 
Here's the deal. LizzyM shows her face first, then I show my sister's face. 😉

Things just got weird.
weird-eyebrows-0.jpg
 
People like William Hwang burn out rather rapidly. I know someone like that well. She was much more, MUCH more accomplished than William Hwang. She didn't burn out but followed her passion. BS and MS in Engineering, PhD from Stanford, then a professor of mechanical engineering at MIT (http://www.mit.edu/~pucci/) and also at NYU. She was very young too! Then she decided to follow her passion. She followed her heart and gave up her superbly brilliant career to dance tango. She became a professional tango dancer. Here's why in her own words http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BbAt1gnkBE

Okay? She published a couple things and had some advanced degrees. What makes her more special than any other professor at MIT? By the time Hwang was 22 he had finished a triple (quadruple?) major degree at Duke, a Master's at Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar, and had started a nonprofit that had been very successful among other things. And he didn't have a page of his professional website dedicated to his cats. :meanie:
 
People like William Hwang burn out rather rapidly. I know someone like that well. She was much more, MUCH more accomplished than William Hwang. She didn't burn out but followed her passion. BS and MS in Engineering, PhD from Stanford, then a professor of mechanical engineering at MIT (http://www.mit.edu/~pucci/) and also at NYU. She was very young too! Then she decided to follow her passion. She followed her heart and gave up her superbly brilliant career to dance tango. She became a professional tango dancer. Here's why in her own words http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BbAt1gnkBE

Thanks for that info, I actually added that to my favorites.
 
Okay? She published a couple things and had some advanced degrees. What makes her more special than any other professor at MIT? By the time Hwang was 22 he had finished a triple (quadruple?) major degree at Duke, a Master's at Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar, and had started a nonprofit that had been very successful among other things. And he didn't have a page of his professional website dedicated to his cats. :meanie:

For one, by the age Hwang had his undergrad degree, she already had a BS, MS, PhD from Stanford and a professor position at not one but two top universities (MIT and NYU) in a country FOREIGN to her with much brighter credentials along the way - does that count? Anyway, I don't like to argue or debate, so I am out.

Plus my friend is WAY cuter and sexier than Hwang, which you will know if you ever dance with her 😉

All I will say is, do what your heart tells you to do, do what you are really passionate about, instead of pursuing medicine just because your parents tell you or because it is good money or because it is the done thing or because it brings prestige, etc. Follow your heart. Cause you live only once. My friend is really very happy dancing tango to her heart's content.
 
Last edited:
For one, by the age Hwang had his undergrad degree, she already had a BS, MS, PhD from Stanford and a professor position at not one but two top universities (MIT and NYU) in a country FOREIGN to her with much brighter credentials along the way - does that count? Anyway, I don't like to argue or debate, so I am out.

Plus my friend is WAY cuter and sexier than Hwang, which you will know if you ever dance with her 😉

All I will say is, do what your heart tells you to do, do what you are really passionate about, instead of pursuing medicine just because your parents tell you or because it is good money or because it is the done thing or because it brings prestige, etc. Follow your heart. Cause you live only once. My friend is really very happy dancing tango to her heart's content.
Well that statement means absolutely nothing unless you intend it to compare her age at completion of those degrees with his age at completion of his undergrad. In which case, you'll need to provide proof she got her Master's and PhD before age 20. :laugh:
 
Thanks for that info, I actually added that to my favorites.

You're welcome. She is indeed an inspiration to many.

We've gotta do what our heart tells us to do.

As I wrote, do what you are really passionate about, instead of pursuing medicine just because your parents tell you or because it is good money or because it is the done thing or because it brings prestige, etc. Follow your heart. Cause you live only once. My friend is really very happy dancing tango to her heart's content.
 
A Balanced Review of Harvard Extension:

The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time. (http://hms.harvard.edu/content/facts-figures-0#numbers)

On the negative side, my sister and her friends constantly bitch about how HES and Harvard do not treat Extension students well. If you go down and talk to one of the advisors or deans on Brattle, you will know because they treat you like ****. There is one Black lady who is one of the dean of students - she absolutely hates HES students. There are also many annoyances you need to put up with at HES. The only bathroom in Sever Hall stinks to high heavens, the computer staff treat you like ****, if you print on only one side of the page the annoying white lady with a foreign accent in Grossman computer lab screams at you. The very tall, bald guy who mans the computer lab in Grossman is an exception - he looks white but he is actually a Black dude - because he is about the only HES employee who is nice. You also cannot print more than 20 pages at one time, Grossman library is as tiny as a matchbox, you cannot even borrow books from Grossman library which is the only library for HES students, the computer lab in Grossman - try to squeeze to the upper level on those stairs if you work out because it is even smaller than a matchbox, the two scanners in Grossman - try to get them to work, the other computer facility on Church Street is just as bad, try going into one of the other Harvard libraries (sadly almost all of the 100 libraries at Harvard don't allow HES students), try calling 495-8400 which other Harvard students get to use to get a free ride back home, try getting a letter of recommendation on Harvard letterheads from your professors, or try getting an on-campus apartment at Harvard - I could go on and on. Oh and the hand sanitizer dispensing machines in Sever are always dry. Why do I keep talking about Sever?? Because you may spend 8 years at Harvard Extension getting an ALB, that's at least how long most people take, but you will see the insides of only 3 or 4 buildings - that dirty Sever for the most part, Brattle, Science Center and one or two others for your finals. One girl was stuck in Sever's elevator during her final when she took a break to use the bathroom. That elevator takes forever and forever but that day it broke down and she was trapped inside for over an hour. The professor said, no way, you won't get a make-up final and after the fire department let her out, she had to go in to take the rest of the final but had only about 10 minutes left. She complained to the deans but nothing came out of it. Don't take the elevator in Sever when you have your exams!!

But their biggest complaint is how HES absolutely murders your transcript with B's and C's and how many, many dreams of law school, PhD school, MD school and MBA programs are killed when HES professors, clearly under instruction from the HES admin, give you B's, C's and D's. You see, HES' ALB degree is a Harvard degree, so they make you "pay your dues" and the only way they know to make you earn Harvard credentials (ALB) is by assigning insane amount of work and murdering your transcript with B's and C's. And by writing very luke-warm recommendation letters to even someone who gets straight A's. Don't get a letter from any HES professor at Harvard!!!!!! Get them from professors who have taught you in your undergraduate college. The rumor is HES faculty are instructed by the HES admin to NOT write strong letters and by all indication those rumors are true.

If you go to HES, your chances of getting into medical school actually get significantly diminished because HES deliberately murders your transcript. Only about 33% of the students - and many drop out even before - manage to get into medical schools, limping on a transcript peppered with B's and C's. The national average is about 44%, so Harvard Extension does significantly worse than the national average because of transcript damage and bad letters of recommendation.

Columbia has the School of General Studies that sounds better than "Extension" although it is the same as Extension. But SGS students are treated well and integrated into the Columbia community. If you want Ivy League credentials, get one from the SGS instead of HES.

On the other hand, if you want the world's best preparation for the MCAT or a chance to encounter some of Harvard's 11,860 medical school professors, then HES is for you (if you don't mind B's, C's, W's and F's on your transcript!)

Your mileage may vary and HES students who get offended may call me a "troll" which really indicates they had nothing substantial to say.


Getting A's at a postbac that is known to give out B's, C's and D's and F's is actually beneficial. Med schools absolutely give more credence to certain postbacs than others, and while the overall nongraduate GPA is what matters most, some postbacs are better respected than others. The folks I know who did well at Harvard Extension did very well. I'm sure there are places where those same applicants wouldn't have gone as far.
 
For one, by the age Hwang had his undergrad degree, she already had a BS, MS, PhD from Stanford and a professor position at not one but two top universities (MIT and NYU) in a country FOREIGN to her with much brighter credentials along the way - does that count? Anyway, I don't like to argue or debate, so I am out.

Plus my friend is WAY cuter and sexier than Hwang, which you will know if you ever dance with her 😉

All I will say is, do what your heart tells you to do, do what you are really passionate about, instead of pursuing medicine just because your parents tell you or because it is good money or because it is the done thing or because it brings prestige, etc. Follow your heart. Cause you live only once. My friend is really very happy dancing tango to her heart's content.

So you admit that you think Hwang is sexy?
 
So you admit that you think Hwang is sexy?

He's not bad-looking for a guy from Taiwan/Hong Kong. He is also probably tall for an Asian as he was the captain of his volleyball team. Many Asian girls look cute. Asian guys? Nah. Sorry Asian guys.
 
A Balanced Review of Harvard Extension:

The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time. (http://hms.harvard.edu/content/facts-figures-0#numbers)

On the negative side, my sister and her friends constantly bitch about how HES and Harvard do not treat Extension students well. If you go down and talk to one of the advisors or deans on Brattle, you will know because they treat you like ****. There is one Black lady who is one of the dean of students - she absolutely hates HES students. There are also many annoyances you need to put up with at HES. The only bathroom in Sever Hall stinks to high heavens, the computer staff treat you like ****, if you print on only one side of the page the annoying white lady with a foreign accent in Grossman computer lab screams at you. The very tall, bald guy who mans the computer lab in Grossman is an exception - he looks white but he is actually a Black dude - because he is about the only HES employee who is nice. You also cannot print more than 20 pages at one time, Grossman library is as tiny as a matchbox, you cannot even borrow books from Grossman library which is the only library for HES students, the computer lab in Grossman - try to squeeze to the upper level on those stairs if you work out because it is even smaller than a matchbox, the two scanners in Grossman - try to get them to work, the other computer facility on Church Street is just as bad, try going into one of the other Harvard libraries (sadly almost all of the 100 libraries at Harvard don't allow HES students), try calling 495-8400 which other Harvard students get to use to get a free ride back home, try getting a letter of recommendation on Harvard letterheads from your professors, or try getting an on-campus apartment at Harvard - I could go on and on. Oh and the hand sanitizer dispensing machines in Sever are always dry. Why do I keep talking about Sever?? Because you may spend 8 years at Harvard Extension getting an ALB, that's at least how long most people take, but you will see the insides of only 3 or 4 buildings - that dirty Sever for the most part, Brattle, Science Center and one or two others for your finals. One girl was stuck in Sever's elevator during her final when she took a break to use the bathroom. That elevator takes forever and forever but that day it broke down and she was trapped inside for over an hour. The professor said, no way, you won't get a make-up final and after the fire department let her out, she had to go in to take the rest of the final but had only about 10 minutes left. She complained to the deans but nothing came out of it. Don't take the elevator in Sever when you have your exams!!

But their biggest complaint is how HES absolutely murders your transcript with B's and C's and how many, many dreams of law school, PhD school, MD school and MBA programs are killed when HES professors, clearly under instruction from the HES admin, give you B's, C's and D's. You see, HES' ALB degree is a Harvard degree, so they make you "pay your dues" and the only way they know to make you earn Harvard credentials (ALB) is by assigning insane amount of work and murdering your transcript with B's and C's. And by writing very luke-warm recommendation letters to even someone who gets straight A's. Don't get a letter from any HES professor at Harvard!!!!!! Get them from professors who have taught you in your undergraduate college. The rumor is HES faculty are instructed by the HES admin to NOT write strong letters and by all indication those rumors are true.

If you go to HES, your chances of getting into medical school actually get significantly diminished because HES deliberately murders your transcript. Only about 33% of the students - and many drop out even before - manage to get into medical schools, limping on a transcript peppered with B's and C's. The national average is about 44%, so Harvard Extension does significantly worse than the national average because of transcript damage and bad letters of recommendation.

Columbia has the School of General Studies that sounds better than "Extension" although it is the same as Extension. But SGS students are treated well and integrated into the Columbia community. If you want Ivy League credentials, get one from the SGS instead of HES.

On the other hand, if you want the world's best preparation for the MCAT or a chance to encounter some of Harvard's 11,860 medical school professors, then HES is for you (if you don't mind B's, C's, W's and F's on your transcript!)

Your mileage may vary and HES students who get offended may call me a "troll" which really indicates they had nothing substantial to say.

Just FYI because I know a lot of GS students who would be upset by this: GS is not a continuing education program. It is another undergraduate school at Columbia. There is a different school of continuing education.
 
People like William Hwang burn out rather rapidly. I know someone like that well. She was much more, MUCH more accomplished than William Hwang. She didn't burn out but followed her passion. BS and MS in Engineering, PhD from Stanford, then a professor of mechanical engineering at MIT (http://www.mit.edu/~pucci/) and also at NYU. She was very young too! Then she decided to follow her passion. She followed her heart and gave up her superbly brilliant career to dance tango. She became a professional tango dancer. Here's why in her own words http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BbAt1gnkBE

She was assistant professor, not professor. There's a big difference, especially these days when fewer and fewer are granted tenure. There has been a trend of institutions bringing in new faculty, working them like dogs, and then kicking them to the curb just before they were to be granted tenure. They end up (rightfully) feeling jaded and many move onto something else...like Tango dancing.
 
Getting A's at a postbac that is known to give out B's, C's and D's and F's is actually beneficial. Med schools absolutely give more credence to certain postbacs than others, and while the overall nongraduate GPA is what matters most, some postbacs are better respected than others. The folks I know who did well at Harvard Extension did very well. I'm sure there are places where those same applicants wouldn't have gone as far.

You are 100% correct. If anyone does well at Harvard Extension, then they are among the very top candidates that year. There is no doubt about that.

The problem is students get C's for the most part, when they could have gotten As at any other school. The second problem is, even if you get A's, Harvard Extension professors are under instructions to not write glowing recommendation letters. Many Extension professors misunderstand this directive and write poor letters even for straight-A students. Despite the superlative quality education that Extension provides, Harvard Extension is a dream killer for most students when it comes to not only MD admissions but also MBA, JD, grad school or PhD admissions in other disciplines. No one wants students with C's on their transcript, even if it is from Harvard (Extension).
 
You are 100% correct. If anyone does well at Harvard Extension, then they are among the very top candidates that year. There is no doubt about that.

The problem is students get C's for the most part, when they could have gotten As at any other school. The second problem is, even if you get A's, Harvard Extension professors are under instructions to not write glowing recommendation letters. Many Extension professors misunderstand this directive and write poor letters even for straight-A students. Despite the superlative quality education that Extension provides, Harvard Extension is a dream killer for most students when it comes to not only MD admissions but also MBA, JD, grad school or PhD admissions in other disciplines. No one wants students with C's on their transcript, even if it is from Harvard (Extension).

i am not questioning this, but what could possible be a reason for this? do they not want extension students doing so well that they overshadow regular harvard kids? this seems absurd.
 
i am not questioning this, but what could possible be a reason for this? do they not want extension students doing so well that they overshadow regular harvard kids? this seems absurd.

The rest of Harvard HATES Extension. Check out the Crimson, the newspaper at Harvard. They bash Extension all the time. They also bash Hilary Duff who studied at Harvard Extension.

In the history of Harvard Extension's ALB (not HCP) program only about 4 students got into medical schools. Others are NOT getting in because of transcript damage! More here http://extensionstudent.com/discussion/4024/thread-for-alb-to-md-experience
 
Looks like somebody needs to call...

wambulance_logo.jpg



But seriously though. I don't even understand your beef with Harvard Extension. "Your sister and her friends" went through it. Not you.
 
But seriously though. I don't even understand your beef with Harvard Extension. "Your sister and her friends" went through it. Not you.

I don't have a beef with Harvard Extension, just concern that they are destroying dreams of many, many, many students who go there because of the Harvard name and then find they cannot get into medical school. I have also talked about the positives of Harvard Extension. If you didn't read them, here they are again: The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time.
 
I don't have a beef with Harvard Extension, just concern that they are destroying dreams of many, many, many students who go there because of the Harvard name and then find they cannot get into medical school. I have also talked about the positives of Harvard Extension. If you didn't read them, here they are again: The positive aspects about HES are that you get genuine Harvard credentials. Fixsen, who runs HCP, the Health Careers Program at HES, is quite responsive, whether in person or over email. HES offers fantastic and unparalleled preparation for the MCAT - you cannot beat that!! You get to live in the Cambridge area. There are many opportunities for shadowing, volunteer work, hospital work, etc. There are also some unexpected positives. Like, you don't need a car, some apartments actually let you rent without a deposit and without a lease, the dating scene is superb, it is a perfect town to find a life partner. Or like the condensed Jan semester which many Harvard students take advantage of. And on any given day, you can find a talk by a Nobel prize winning economist or a world-famous poet or a prominent politician or someone else at Harvard or the Kennedy School or elsewhere in the Harvard system. I wish more HES students took advantage of such opportunities. On any given day you can find free food at Harvard (http://events.college.harvard.edu/ and check free food). I spend Decembers and summers with my sister at Harvard and I eat FREE every day somewhere in Boston or at Harvard - been doing this for 4 years now. Most HCP students don't even know of such opportunities. Free food saves a lot on expenses! If you like Arts, you cannot be in a better city! Check out http://ofa.fas.harvard.edu/cal/. Harvard has about 100 libraries! Harvard Medical School has over 11,860 professors. 11,860 professors!!! Of which 8,924 are full time.

How do you even have time to write these rants?
 
How do you even have time to write these rants?

Thank you for reminding me that I should be studying instead of hanging out on these forums! You will hardly ever see me here again.
 
Is it just me that I would never equate Harvard Extension with Harvard College and thus would never consider "credentials" from a post-bacc there to be worth the trouble?


Sent from my iPhone using SDN Mobile
 
Is it just me that I would never equate Harvard Extension with Harvard College and thus would never consider "credentials" from a post-bacc there to be worth the trouble?


Sent from my iPhone using SDN Mobile

You are not alone.

Many of these programs are "easy to get in, hard to stay in". Those who do very well are deserving of respect but those who do very well are few and far between as a large proportion wash out.
 
You are 100% correct. If anyone does well at Harvard Extension, then they are among the very top candidates that year. There is no doubt about that.

The problem is students get C's for the most part, when they could have gotten As at any other school. The second problem is, even if you get A's, Harvard Extension professors are under instructions to not write glowing recommendation letters. Many Extension professors misunderstand this directive and write poor letters even for straight-A students. Despite the superlative quality education that Extension provides, Harvard Extension is a dream killer for most students when it comes to not only MD admissions but also MBA, JD, grad school or PhD admissions in other disciplines. No one wants students with C's on their transcript, even if it is from Harvard (Extension).

I looked at Extension's exams for orgo and physics. Everything looks fair game. I didn't see anything outrageously difficult. Actually, the exams look somewhat easier than the ones I took at my non-Ivy undergrad.

Probably a lot of people do poorly because they're used to easy classes at whatever community college or unknown school they were at before. Average SAT for an Extension student is probably below a top 50 undergrad.
 
You are not alone.

Many of these programs are "easy to get in, hard to stay in". Those who do very well are deserving of respect but those who do very well are few and far between as a large proportion wash out.

LizzyM,

What do you think of the "grads" coming out of the Harvard Extension postbac? Do you look upon them favorably being that they completed a rigorous postbac as compared to say a lesser known postbac that is not known for being as challenging?
 
LizzyM,

What do you think of the "grads" coming out of the Harvard Extension postbac? Do you look upon them favorably being that they completed a rigorous postbac as compared to say a lesser known postbac that is not known for being as challenging?

I don't see many. Those I do see have often taken just a course or two for enrichment while working in a Harvard-affiliated lab.
 
http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2005/2/28/duff-at-harvard-hilary-duff-is/
Also shows how the rest of Harvard hates Harvard Extension.

That article is from 2005.

And I would be annoyed too if people went to MyUndergrad-extension school and went around saying they went to MyUndergrad College. There's a big difference between getting into a very selective undergrad college (go through application process, write essays, SAT, interviews, etc.) and taking classes (fill out name, DOB, pay money) there.

That's not to say that people who do well at HES (and Harvard) aren't smart and talented, just that those in HES do not "go to Harvard College."

Also, I've taken several science classes through HES and haven't found them to be "GPA killers."
 
You are 100% correct. If anyone does well at Harvard Extension, then they are among the very top candidates that year. There is no doubt about that.

The problem is students get C's for the most part, when they could have gotten As at any other school. The second problem is, even if you get A's, Harvard Extension professors are under instructions to not write glowing recommendation letters. Many Extension professors misunderstand this directive and write poor letters even for straight-A students. Despite the superlative quality education that Extension provides, Harvard Extension is a dream killer for most students when it comes to not only MD admissions but also MBA, JD, grad school or PhD admissions in other disciplines. No one wants students with C's on their transcript, even if it is from Harvard (Extension).

There are no prereqs for JD or MBA. There are no accepted mechanisms for people to rehabilitate an undergraduate GPA to get into these paths -- ie postbacs aren't widely used for these as they are for premed. There is no AAMC to combine undergrad and postbac GPAs. So it's a Silly comparison. If you graduated college with above a C average, you could get into a law program somewhere. Most MBAS put more stock in work experience than postgraduate grades. If you need to rehabilitate, this is simply a Poor path to choose, as would be any post bac program. So I don't buy your premise. Nobody is going to HES or any other postbac to get into law school or business school. It's such a low yield move to start with that you'd be hard pressed to say it hurt anyone's chances.
 
There are no prereqs for JD or MBA. There are no accepted mechanisms for people to rehabilitate an undergraduate GPA to get into these paths -- ie postbacs aren't widely used for these as they are for premed. There is no AAMC to combine undergrad and postbac GPAs. So it's a Silly comparison. If you graduated college with above a C average, you could get into a law program somewhere. Most MBAS put more stock in work experience than postgraduate grades. If you need to rehabilitate, this is simply a Poor path to choose, as would be any post bac program. So I don't buy your premise. Nobody is going to HES or any other postbac to get into law school or business school. It's such a low yield move to start with that you'd be hard pressed to say it hurt anyone's chances.

Wow I always assumed it was similar to med competitiveness
 
So OP is not enrolled at HES but is writing a long diatribe that he calls a fair review? Wtf?
 
:hijacked:There were 44,000 new grads produced out of law schools last year according to a story in today's Wall Street Journal. (That's almost equal to the number of medical school applicants.) Alas there are only 23,000 jobs for new law school grads who have passed the bar. Many of the rest are in low paying jobs that make it tough to pay off their school loans.

🙁
 
Top