- Joined
- Apr 20, 2010
- Messages
- 54
- Reaction score
- 0
...and for white students it is 26.24. Now, close your eyes and imagine that you are a black person living in this country. How would your life be? Now, open your eyes and look at that table again.![]()
and women and native americans have higher GPA's than whites while asians score higher on the mcat overall. should i close my eyes and imagine i'm a white male living in a country full of asian women?
what are you suggesting?
I agree, I could understand a small difference either way as African Americans are a relatively small group of matriculants to osteopathic med school, but that's 4.5 points and that's about an SD on the MCAT if I'm not mistaken.Yeah I don't really get the reference either...it is 2010 not 1968. I just don't get it
Affirmative action is such bull****.
Affirmative Action is illegal my friend. So, before you start jumping up and down pretending to be superior to everyone, think.
In order to fully understand the ramifications of such a wide variety of programs that are installed in an effort to increase diversity, please read the arrogant comments in this thread. For instance, "its 2010, not 1968." Really? You don't think discrimination exists because a half-white guy became the President?
Think people! Perhaps ask your grandpa what he thinks of blacks in medicine and business. He may have the answer for you. Good luck in becoming health care providers. This is frightening!
Affirmative Action is illegal my friend. So, before you start jumping up and down pretending to be superior to everyone, think.
In order to fully understand the ramifications of such a wide variety of programs that are installed in an effort to increase diversity, please read the arrogant comments in this thread. For instance, "its 2010, not 1968." Really? You don't think discrimination exists because a half-white guy became the President?
Think people! Perhaps ask your grandpa what he thinks of blacks in medicine and business. He may have the answer for you. Good luck in becoming health care providers. This is frightening!
I'm a white guy too. Yes, we have been discriminated against for quite some time.![]()
Wish you well. Good luck getting accepted.
Affirmative Action is illegal my friend. So, before you start jumping up and down pretending to be superior to everyone, think.
In order to fully understand the ramifications of such a wide variety of programs that are installed in an effort to increase diversity, please read the arrogant comments in this thread. For instance, "its 2010, not 1968." Really? You don't think discrimination exists because a half-white guy became the President?
Think people! Perhaps ask your grandpa what he thinks of blacks in medicine and business. He may have the answer for you. Good luck in becoming health care providers. This is frightening!
Didn't mean to offend you. Everybody deserves a fair playing field. Analyzing just numbers does not give a fair picture of an applicant. Good luck.
Sorry that you had to go through that. People will be people. I married a black girl and my family hasn't spoken to me since. She is a cardiologist and yet they think she is trash. And yes, its 2010. I don't want my kids to be treated in that manner.
Good luck with school. Kick some butt.
These comments aren't arrogant, they are simply noting the wide gap between African American and average MCAT scores. This is a legitimate discussion, while there is a need for diversity in medicine, it should not come at a cost of quality in the physician pool. As to the second question regarding grandparents, who is to some of ours haven't faced discrimination. I'm a white guy who has been discriminated against because of my religion. I think that to view race in the manner you do is divisive and it is important to recognize no one has a corner on the discrimination and suffering market.
This table makes you think that the average AA accepted VS white is 21 to 26. In reality, it is closer to 24-25 or 24-26 max on average. I personally have no problem with that minimal gap. Relax white americans, the average black person is NOT accepted with a 21, regardless of that stupid table.
Affirmative Action is illegal my friend. So, before you start jumping up and down pretending to be superior to everyone, think.
In order to fully understand the ramifications of such a wide variety of programs that are installed in an effort to increase diversity, please read the arrogant comments in this thread. For instance, "its 2010, not 1968." Really? You don't think discrimination exists because a half-white guy became the President?
Think people! Perhaps ask your grandpa what he thinks of blacks in medicine and business. He may have the answer for you. Good luck in becoming health care providers. This is frightening!
Anyway, I'm not sure how I feel about affirmative action - I'm a Black woman and I got into MSUCOM with a 31 on the MCAT and a 3.9.
I'm pretty sick of feeling like people think I only got into medical school because of the color of my skin not my grades or effort.
lI got into MSUCOM
lol, why does that "half-white" comment make me laugh so hard? Oh right, Sarah Silverman wrote a joke about that....
Anyway, I'm not sure how I feel about affirmative action - I'm a Black woman and I got into MSUCOM with a 31 on the MCAT and a 3.9. Then again, I know one man in particular who got a 22 with a 3.0 who got into MSUCOM, and to be honest I believe it was because he was a URM.
I personally, rather Affirmative action be eliminated. I'm pretty sick of feeling like people think I only got into medical school because of the color of my skin not my grades or effort.
That's my 10 cents (yes, my opinion is worth 10 cents more than your 2 cents), feel free to disagree.
On that note, btw, stop calling people who disagree with AA racist, that's stereotyping. I know plenty of people who aren't racist but disagree, like me, on moral grounds.
Here come the flames....
Wow! Congratulations!!! Now, we can stop all efforts in enrolling people from disadvantaged backgrounds. Case closed.
If you want to establish to your fellow students that you are a person of sound intellect, then be on the top of your class. Don't correlate your lack of self confidence with a need for social change.
Yes, there are blacks who have a very good and stable family background. This helps them to concentrate on school and go on great Spring Breaks. 🙂 However, a large group of minorities come from a very poor background. These students have to work 50-70hrs a week to support their families and still manage to get a 3.0 GPA in premedical curriculum. Yes, I will be more impressed with them, than some rich white guy who did nothing but study all day and went to frat parties at night.
I can honestly say that over 50% of students in my class are arrogant elitists. They would probably prefer to touch a poor patient with a stick if they could get away with it. Having a 3.9999 GPA and a 45T MCAT does not guarantee you a magic wand. Medicine is not premed. It's about taking care of another human being who so desperately needs a caring hand.
When I look around in my class it makes me realize how bad of a job our medical school admissions committee is doing. Our diversity department is a window dressing. It helps get federal funding. I guess that's all that matters to medical schools and medical students. How sad.😡
Wow! Congratulations!!! Now, we can stop all efforts in enrolling people from disadvantaged backgrounds. Case closed.
If you want to establish to your fellow students that you are a person of sound intellect, then be on the top of your class. Don't correlate your lack of self confidence with a need for social change.
Yes, there are blacks who have a very good and stable family background. This helps them to concentrate on school and go on great Spring Breaks. 🙂 However, a large group of minorities come from a very poor background. These students have to work 50-70hrs a week to support their families and still manage to get a 3.0 GPA in premedical curriculum. Yes, I will be more impressed with them, than some rich white guy who did nothing but study all day and went to frat parties at night.
I can honestly say that over 50% of students in my class are arrogant elitists. They would probably prefer to touch a poor patient with a stick if they could get away with it. Having a 3.9999 GPA and a 45T MCAT does not guarantee you a magic wand. Medicine is not premed. It's about taking care of another human being who so desperately needs a caring hand.
When I look around in my class it makes me realize how bad of a job our medical school admissions committee is doing. Our diversity department is a window dressing. It helps get federal funding. I guess that's all that matters to medical schools and medical students. How sad.😡
Yes, I agree. However, medical schools are under a lot of pressure to stay on top of the ranking lists. As a result, they want students with very high numbers as opposed to those who have "good" academic background concomitant with great people skills.
Someone in another thread posted an article that you may find interesting:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/15/health/14chen.html
...a large group of minorities come from a very poor background. These students have to work 50-70hrs a week to support their families and still manage to get a 3.0 GPA in premedical curriculum.
Yes, I will be more impressed with them, than some rich white guy who did nothing but study all day and went to frat parties at night.
I can honestly say that over 50% of students in my class are arrogant elitists. They would probably prefer to touch a poor patient with a stick if they could get away with it. Having a 3.9999 GPA and a 45T MCAT does not guarantee you a magic wand.
Medicine is not premed. It's about taking care of another human being who so desperately needs a caring hand.
When I look around in my class it makes me realize how bad of a job our medical school admissions committee is doing.
most medical schools put too much emphasis on GPA/MCAT scores... They should probably put some more emphasis on personality/judge the entire applicant, not just their academic performance.
because there are just too many doctors that don't have an ounce of empathy in their bodies.
First off, I have not seen a post on here where you were not acting like a complete jack*** Man you really are miserable huh! We all know that medical schools take URMs to keep the federal funding rolling in. However, this doesn't take away from the fact that underqualified applicants are getting into medical school because of it. That is all the girl was trying to say in her orginal post. And what about all the poor white kids who "have to work 50-70hrs a week to support their families," but still manage to get great grades and MCAT scores. Yet they don't get into medical school because they fall into the wrong catagory. Forget about them right... I think the girl had a nice story, and I can totally understand where she is coming from (as a URM). We should all be judged on our ability, not the color of our skin.
A. The material during pre-med doesn't even begin to compare to the material you get during med school.
B. "Handling it" doesn't come from an academic standpoint - it's emotional, social, and psychological just as much as it is academic. If you think grades and ECs can tell ADCOMs all they need to and should know about what might make an applicant a good doctor, then you're nuts. It's not all about book smarts and the ability to score well on standardized exams. House is a fictional character who, by real life standards, would not be practicing or be allowed to treat patients, imho. Stop using a TV character as your example.
ok i'll clarify-
reminds me of the age old question, what makes a better doctor? competent or compassionate?
First off, I have not seen a post on here where you were not acting like a complete jack*** Man you really are miserable huh! We all know that medical schools take URMs to keep the federal funding rolling in. However, this doesn't take away from the fact that underqualified applicants are getting into medical school because of it. That is all the girl was trying to say in her orginal post. And what about all the poor white kids who "have to work 50-70hrs a week to support their families," but still manage to get great grades and MCAT scores. Yet they don't get into medical school because they fall into the wrong catagory. Forget about them right... I think the girl had a nice story, and I can totally understand where she is coming from (as a URM). We should all be judged on our ability, not the color of our skin.
Yes, I will be more impressed with them, than some rich white guy who did nothing but study all day and went to frat parties at night.
.😡
Obviously the answer to that question is mediocrity. Dude, you are a white guy who got mediocre grades and a lame MCAT (25) and got into medical school. What do you have to say about that? A 25? I could get a 25 on the MCAT drunk. Get over yourself dude! I'm white too but not an arrogant a-hole like you.
Obviously the answer to that question is mediocrity. Dude, you are a white guy who got mediocre grades and a lame MCAT (25) and got into medical school. What do you have to say about that? A 25? I could get a 25 on the MCAT drunk. Get over yourself dude! I'm white too but not an arrogant a-hole like you.
When I look around in my class it makes me realize how bad of a job our medical school admissions committee is doing. Our diversity department is a window dressing. It helps get federal funding. I guess that's all that matters to medical schools and medical students. How sad.😡
Can I just give my 2 cents... I think that if we're going to eliminate segregation then we need to stop trying to differentiate between the races. We need to stop saying that Blacks bring this, or Asians that. But rather say that everyone can contribute something.Perhaps because "diversity" involves more than skin color?![]()
Can I just give my 2 cents... I think that if we're going to eliminate segregation then we need to stop trying to differentiate between the races. We need to stop saying that Blacks bring this, or Asians that. But rather say that everyone can contribute something.
What your doing by saying that race "involves more than skin color" is essentially perpetuating the idea that there are differences between the races. I disagree. Then again, I'm from England which is about as homogeneous as you can get.
Not to bring up the "URM Card" but wow...a 21.77 mean MCAT for African American Matriculants?
Idiot said:Affirmative action is such bull****.
Stoptouchingme, I only read your posts from quotes, but I don't see your logic in how unstable family backgrounds are going to really affect your studies in college.
I mean, assuming someone with an unstable background is living on campus with students from a variety of backgrounds, I don't see how their past is really going to affect what they get done in the library during the school year.
I know this may sound ignorant, but I've always wondered how someone could argue this point. By accepting someone with lower stats you can't say for sure if it was a growing up in a poor environment, or just lack of preparation or studying.
These comments aren't arrogant, they are simply noting the wide gap between African American and average MCAT scores. This is a legitimate discussion, while there is a need for diversity in medicine, it should not come at a cost of quality in the physician pool. As to the second question regarding grandparents, who is to some of ours haven't faced discrimination. I'm a white guy who has been discriminated against because of my religion. I think that to view race in the manner you do is divisive and it is important to recognize no one has a corner on the discrimination and suffering market.