? about Dean's letter

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Plinko

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2003
Messages
259
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Texas
I was just emailed my Dean's letter for review and I am a little concerned about its contents. Our Dean of Education simply writes some background info on us, puts in our class rank, board scores, his thoughts about us as future doctors, and then third year core rotation grades and excerpts from our attendings' evaluations. Two phrases in particular are worrisome to me: from my Family Medicine attending..."Good student. Good knowledge base. Does not seem very interested in being here as he wants to be a surgeon" and from my OB/GYN attending..."Attentive and diligent. Able to take criticism well and do his work well. Did well on our final exam. Always speaks in a low, very serious voice – he needs to lighten up somewhat with patients." Everything else from my other attendings/rotations seems to be pretty complimentary, including the Dean's personal comments. As you probably guessed, I am applying to General Surgery programs, and I was curious if this is something I need be overly concerned about.

At our school it seems the Dean's letters don't get padded very much. They pretty much include everything they have one you. I was wondering if other schools only put in the good stuff and leave out all the bad?
 
My school doesn't pad our letters. EVERY single comment from our clerkship evaluations get on the Dean's letter, good or bad. Hopefully the rest of your comments and LoR's can show that those two bad comments are just random flukes.
 
Our school doesn't even include excerpts from our evaluations (despite opposition) and our biographical information is written in first person: "I am a fourth year student at..." Sucks.
 
I'm surprised that your school would include a comment that was not complimentary in that fashion. The two comments that you were a good student with a good knowledge base are really enough. The other I would not worry about - that won't reflect badly that you are a serious student doctor. I would email the office that writes the letter and see if you could get that small comment removed.

Otherwise, let it go. The rest of your letter is fine, and one comment from one FP doc will not hurt you.
 
my school let us preview our dean's letters as well. however, we could suggest changes and have a meeting with the dean who wrote our letters to go over this in person.
 
I wish my school would let us preview our dean's letter. It's contents are a big mistery to all in my school.
 
Top Bottom