- Joined
- Dec 18, 2007
- Messages
- 5,072
- Reaction score
- 55
Does anyone else find it creepy/cool that most schools include a tour of their anatomy lab, complete with cadavers & formaldehyde scent?
I secretly enjoy it as well. I think the med students just enjoy freaking out the premeds and seeing our reaction to dead bodies. This hand doesn't shake med students!!!I get upset when the tour doesn't involve the anatomy lab
I get upset when the tour doesn't involve the anatomy lab
I think it is unnecessary as it plays 0 role in my choice for med school.
Does anyone else find it creepy/cool that most schools include a tour of their anatomy lab, complete with cadavers & formaldehyde scent?
I agree with that. I think the anatomy lab speaks to the quality of the facilities of the school more than anything. I thought it was weird that at Downstate the classrooms & facilities were lackluster to say the least but their anatomy lab was really nice... very stark contrastIf your school had an anatomy lab like Vanderbilt's, you'd show it to all the pre-meds too. OSU's was quite nice as well. There's something cool about being on the top of a building surrounded by huge windows and nice views when you're doing something that calls to mind dank basements.
And I am also somewhat disappointed when I don't get to see the anatomy labs, though if it's not going to be a big draw, why show it to people?
Most schools I've been to (all but 1) have not had cadavers out. I actually preferred the schools without the cadavers out. I just don't think it was necessary to have them out, as it added nothing to the tour. If you're looking at a lab you should care more about ventilation, light, number of people per tank, maybe camera/TV setups instead of if they let interviewees see their cadavers during a tour.
Well, some schools had people who were working / dissecting while the tour was being given. At OSU, our interview group got handed a human heart (no one took it). But yeah, I was more impressed by the lighting and the windows than the demonstration.
any time a school did not show me their anatomy lab it was because dissections were taking place. so of all of the labs I saw, only 1 had a cadaver out, while other schools didn't show us their lab because cadavers were out. I thought that was more respectful and I understood it. they took us into a very similar room next door and it was easy to imagine how nice/new the anatomy lab next door was.Well, some schools had people who were working / dissecting while the tour was being given. At OSU, our interview group got handed a human heart (no one took it). But yeah, I was more impressed by the lighting and the windows than the demonstration.
Took the words right out of my fingers.frankly, i don't know what amenities you would need in an anatomy lab aside from ventilation. it's pretty much your group and the cadaver. dissecting a cadaver is a pretty low tech undertaking.
all the "nice" stuff will eventually become covered with a layer of cadaver slime anyways. i don't know why you'd waste the money for that.
you'd have to see Vandy's lab though, it's pretty sweet. you have a big touch-screen monitor connected to the internet for looking up other sourcesfrankly, i don't know what amenities you would need in an anatomy lab aside from ventilation. it's pretty much your group and the cadaver. dissecting a cadaver is a pretty low tech undertaking.
all the "nice" stuff will eventually become covered with a layer of cadaver slime anyways. i don't know why you'd waste the money for that.
you'd have to see Vandy's lab though, it's pretty sweet. you have a big touch-screen monitor connected to the internet for looking up other sources
you'd have to see Vandy's lab though, it's pretty sweet. you have a big touch-screen monitor connected to the internet for looking up other sources
well the student say it's the responsibility of someone who isn't dissecting to take control of the atlas and working the computer.but don't they get slimy?
at my school, every tank has a netter's and dissection manual. plus, we have 2 TAs for every 6 tanks that help with dissections.
yeah, and a pit with monitors for people to stand around and watch the professor dissect. and huge walls of windows. very cool place.Also, doesn't the instructor sometimes demonstrate a dissection on a cadaver up front that can be broadcasted right before your eyes? So sweet. Can't deny that's a big plus. (and a time saver if you were to otherwise walk up front multiple times for direction)
I personally think schools do it because it's a cheap thrill, and gross anatomy is one the things that people associate strongly with medical school. I also think it's a little disrespectful to the people who donated their bodies.
but don't they get slimy?
at my school, every tank has a netter's and dissection manual. plus, we have 2 TAs for every 6 tanks that help with dissections.
I think the "respect the bodies" message is extremely overrated. As long as you're not doing something totally inappropriate (throwing parts at each other or whatever), why does it matter? Also, how is seeing a body while on a tour not instructive? You're getting a taste of what you'll be doing for the next year (or more). I think the people would be happy they had some kind of influence in your decision to pursue medicine.
Because its essentially the same everywhere. Honestly I dont give a **** if it has panoramic views or is in a cement basement, I have been in lots of labs and when I am doing my work I dont really notice the "environment" which is overrated by premeds that are looking for something to distinguish between schools.
haha. I love how on one of my tours, the MS2 repeatedly said... "If anyone needs to step out please don't hesitate!" Makes we wonder, if anyone really ended up-chucking their free lunch or fainting... did hear one story on SDN where the guy fainted and cracked open his skull...
Personally, I find the skin on the cadavers especially surprising. It looked so real... I guess I thought it would be more dried.
I think the "respect the bodies" message is extremely overrated. As long as you're not doing something totally inappropriate (throwing parts at each other or whatever), why does it matter? Also, how is seeing a body while on a tour not instructive? You're getting a taste of what you'll be doing for the next year (or more). I think the people would be happy they had some kind of influence in your decision to pursue medicine.
I secretly enjoy it as well. I think the med students just enjoy freaking out the premeds and seeing our reaction to dead bodies. This hand doesn't shake med students!!!
Yes, I've heard the rationale before. I'm saying that I don't get why some people think it's necessary to walk on eggshells when dealing with the bodies. There's not really any discomfort to break after the first day, so you're essentially forbidding all jokes that involve the cadaver. Everyone respects that these people gave their bodies for us to learn, but that doesn't obligate us to be prim and proper at all times. Friends make fun of each other constantly, but that doesn't mean they don't respect each other. It wouldn't bother me if someone was joking around about one of my family members' bodies as long as they were using it to learn as they were supposed to. Gross lab sucks enough with comic relief, and It'd be sheer hell without.Because it is still someone's loved one. My grandmother donated her body to science and the last thing I want to think about is a group of premeds or med students cracking jokes about her after she did something to benefit you. I'm not talking jokes to break the discomfort. I've simply overheard some comments or witnessed some cavalier attitudes. I think it probably begins to seem a little more significant when a loved one does it and that very same person may end up in the room with you.