- Joined
- May 6, 2009
- Messages
- 1,377
- Reaction score
- 1,150
I've had it. I give up.
Today's case:
44M PMHx mild HTN on a touch of HCTZ with femur fracture s/p admittedly significant bike accident (vs. car) but without any other significant injuries and excessive trauma work-up (near pan-man CT; no CT Chest but normal AP CXR).
Ortho will actually take the case with little resistance and plans for OR in mid-morning. CRNA comes down (quickly! - yes) for some "pre-op" nonsense and states there must be a medicine consult to "clear" the patient for surgery (acutally, cardiology or IM may have been requested - I don't remember).
No discussion with anesthesiology or resident (I'm told they don't do overnight pre-ops for non-emergent cases).
At my hospital, there is no such thing as a medicine consult in the ED. I (EM attending) finally stop laughing, consider arguing for a MEDICAL evaluation (ie anesthesiologist/doctor), and then realize the path of least resistance is best...I just talk the ortho resident into taking the admission (actually, I just admit the patient to ortho, as we have admitting rights to any service).
Then I sit back and reconsider:
WTF?
Why I am even listening to a nurse when I wouldn't listen to an intern without attending or senior supervision?
Please, for the love of god and the love of medicine (not nursing) - and I hope - the love of anesthesiology, why are nurses making independent MEDICAL evaluations?
Why is this tolerated?
1. Why is it OK for a nurse to make a MEDICAL evaluation without supervision (very different than OR anesthesia, I would argue; indeed, the benefit of medical school in pre-op eval is the key)?
2. How come anesthesiology puts up with the idea of medicine consults for "pre-op clearance"? Are you kidding me? As an educated potential patient, I could care less what some PGY2 IM resident has to say about my care in the OR? Why does anesthesiologists care?
In the constant CRNA vs. anesthesiology battle, this is the one area that I would argue nurses have NO INPUT. This is one more area where anesthesiologist should demand (unless lazy) complete control.
Yes, I am EM-trained and know little about anesthesiology. So, please educate me. Why are nurses allowed to do pre-ops? Shouldn't at least anesthesiologists be supervising?
Granted, I work in a hospital where anesthesiology is not a strong department, but come on! There is a residency and we send some crazy unstable cases from the ED to the OR. I am tired of seeing nurses come to the ED. I am tired as a PHYSICIAN, I am tired as an ED doc, and I am tired as a doc who actually respects ANESTHESIOLOGISTS and has a peripheral interest in anesthesiology (hence me constant reading and occassional posting on this forum).
This has to stop.
HH
Post-script: I DO NOT want to start a CRNA vs. MD war here. Consequently, I would prefer to hear from attendings and residents about this. Please, if you are a CRNA or "health student" or nurse, hold your comments for another thread; especially if the comments detail a CRNAs experience in evaluating the complete patient or describe a CRNAs evaluation of the complete patient based on ICU experience as an RN.
Today's case:
44M PMHx mild HTN on a touch of HCTZ with femur fracture s/p admittedly significant bike accident (vs. car) but without any other significant injuries and excessive trauma work-up (near pan-man CT; no CT Chest but normal AP CXR).
Ortho will actually take the case with little resistance and plans for OR in mid-morning. CRNA comes down (quickly! - yes) for some "pre-op" nonsense and states there must be a medicine consult to "clear" the patient for surgery (acutally, cardiology or IM may have been requested - I don't remember).
No discussion with anesthesiology or resident (I'm told they don't do overnight pre-ops for non-emergent cases).
At my hospital, there is no such thing as a medicine consult in the ED. I (EM attending) finally stop laughing, consider arguing for a MEDICAL evaluation (ie anesthesiologist/doctor), and then realize the path of least resistance is best...I just talk the ortho resident into taking the admission (actually, I just admit the patient to ortho, as we have admitting rights to any service).
Then I sit back and reconsider:
WTF?
Why I am even listening to a nurse when I wouldn't listen to an intern without attending or senior supervision?
Please, for the love of god and the love of medicine (not nursing) - and I hope - the love of anesthesiology, why are nurses making independent MEDICAL evaluations?
Why is this tolerated?
1. Why is it OK for a nurse to make a MEDICAL evaluation without supervision (very different than OR anesthesia, I would argue; indeed, the benefit of medical school in pre-op eval is the key)?
2. How come anesthesiology puts up with the idea of medicine consults for "pre-op clearance"? Are you kidding me? As an educated potential patient, I could care less what some PGY2 IM resident has to say about my care in the OR? Why does anesthesiologists care?
In the constant CRNA vs. anesthesiology battle, this is the one area that I would argue nurses have NO INPUT. This is one more area where anesthesiologist should demand (unless lazy) complete control.
Yes, I am EM-trained and know little about anesthesiology. So, please educate me. Why are nurses allowed to do pre-ops? Shouldn't at least anesthesiologists be supervising?
Granted, I work in a hospital where anesthesiology is not a strong department, but come on! There is a residency and we send some crazy unstable cases from the ED to the OR. I am tired of seeing nurses come to the ED. I am tired as a PHYSICIAN, I am tired as an ED doc, and I am tired as a doc who actually respects ANESTHESIOLOGISTS and has a peripheral interest in anesthesiology (hence me constant reading and occassional posting on this forum).
This has to stop.
HH
Post-script: I DO NOT want to start a CRNA vs. MD war here. Consequently, I would prefer to hear from attendings and residents about this. Please, if you are a CRNA or "health student" or nurse, hold your comments for another thread; especially if the comments detail a CRNAs experience in evaluating the complete patient or describe a CRNAs evaluation of the complete patient based on ICU experience as an RN.